NewsBite

Advertisement

New modern Mexican brings the fiesta to the inner west, and gets a hat straight off the bat

Comedor nails warehouse party vibes, with a buzzy open kitchen, park views and plenty of salsa.

Callan Boys
Callan Boys

Comedor is a good-looking space set in a century-old warehouse.
1 / 8Comedor is a good-looking space set in a century-old warehouse.Jennifer Soo
Pork tonkatsu with salsa verde and chayote.
2 / 8Pork tonkatsu with salsa verde and chayote.Jennifer Soo
Gold Street Dairy jersey cheese with salsa roja and nopales.
3 / 8Gold Street Dairy jersey cheese with salsa roja and nopales.Jennifer Soo
Margarita de Nuez.
4 / 8Margarita de Nuez.Jennifer Soo
5 / 8 Jennifer Soo
Snapper crudo with salted green apple, grapes and furikake.
6 / 8Snapper crudo with salted green apple, grapes and furikake.Jennifer Soo
Persimmon and manchego tart.
7 / 8Persimmon and manchego tart.Jennifer Soo
8 / 8 Jennifer Soo

Good Food hat15/20

Mexican$$

I’ve found it. Stop looking. The hunt is over. No need to read any of those “Hottest new spots for summer” lists rolled out every November. When daylight savings comes around, I’ll be heading straight to Camperdown Memorial Rest Park and one of the eight outdoor deck chairs at the east-side Comedor. You’ll be able to eat snacky, corn-based Mexican things, sink cold brew coffee, and – if the licensing gods are kind and giving – you may also bring your own bottle of wine.

I say “will be able” because Comedor opened only five weeks ago and venue manager Kieran Took is under the pump just trying to keep up with demand for a table, let alone launch a snack deck in the park.

To be honest, I wasn’t sure if a modern Mexican restaurant would take off in a residential part of Newtown, a block up from the Courthouse Hotel – it’s not quite King Street – but on a recent Thursday night the place was pumping with a who’s who of the inner west – brewers, designers, musicians and artists. Butchers, bakers and at least one candle-stick maker.

Advertisement

You can see the appeal; it’s a good-looking space. Set in a century-old warehouse owned by Newtown local Walter Shellshear, deep blues and earthy reds frame distressed bricks and a long stone bar that’s one of the most comfortable counters in town. So much elbow room! Natural light floods the space at lunch, and I’m jonesing to return for another afternoon session with Took’s cocktails.

Margarita de nuez.
Margarita de nuez.Jennifer Soo

The “margarita de nuez” ($22), especially, feels like a five-minute holiday in Jalisco, teaming cardamom-infused reposado tequila with almond syrup, rosé vermouth, lemon juice and rosewater. Floral. Nutty. Very refreshing.

Shellshear doesn’t have much hospitality experience, but he does love Mexico and its food and knows that Alejandro Huerta is the right choice to lead Comedor’s kitchen. You may have previously encountered his cooking at Paddington’s mezcal-fuelled El Primo Sanchez.

Pork tonkatsu with salsa verde and chayote.
Pork tonkatsu with salsa verde and chayote.Jennifer Soo
Advertisement

The inspiration here comes from contemporary Mexico City restaurants with some Japanese and Italian influences thrown in. Linguine with aged cheese sauce ($30), say, and a hefty pork tonkatsu cutlet ($45) on salsa verde and a pea-green blitz of chayote. (If you grew up in suburban Sydney and don’t speak Spanish, chayote is good ol’ choko.)

The inspiration comes from Mexico City restaurants with Japanese and Italian influences thrown in.

The closest thing to a taco at Comedor is one meaty tiger prawn – as thick as a front-rower’s thumb – laid across a soft tortilla, charred head attached ($15). A clam-infused sauce of morita chillies (like chipotles, but not as smoky) covers the prawn, and … it’s fine. I was just expecting bigger, brighter flavours.

Gold Street Dairy jersey cheese with salsa roja and nopales.
Gold Street Dairy jersey cheese with salsa roja and nopales.Jennifer Soo

Consider the creamy Jersey milk cheese ($16), made by Marrickville’s Goldstreet Dairy, as a starter instead. The halloumi-adjacent slab is covered in fruity salsa roja and soft strips of nopales (read: prickly pear cactus), and you may be reminded of a slice of Pizza Hut’s Veggie Sensation.

Advertisement

Another highlight is Huerta’s complex mole coloradito, made to his grandmother’s recipe with tomato, cocoa beans, garlic and assorted dried chillies I struggle to pronounce. It’s cooked for at least eight hours until it thumps with flavour and history, and later enhances a jumble of zucchini flowers and yellow squash ($30).

Meanwhile, Jerusalem artichokes are pureed, roasted and fashioned into chip form, and amped up by nutty salsa macha of creeping heat ($18). Plant-based eaters, book now.

There’s also impeccably crunchy fried chicken with an intense chilli jam ($28), and a retired dairy cow steak with mushroom jus and XO ($79).

Snapper crudo ($24) should stick around until spring (fingers crossed), the cured fish sent out in a pool of fermented green apple juice with grapes and toasty furikake seasoning. It’s a deftly balanced dish, but it’s not crudo weather yet.

Persimmon and manchego tart.
Persimmon and manchego tart.Jennifer Soo
Advertisement

A persimmon and manchego tart ($16), however, is perfect August eating: butter-loaded pastry filled with salty, whipped cheese, and lightly sweetened by persimmon jam. A dessert for people who don’t like dessert.

Safe to say, I’m a big fan of the place. Floor staff are invested in their work, the open kitchen has a kinetic buzz. A proper job has been done on the interiors so you can still hear the person across from you over the packed dining room and the soundtrack, which swings between 1970s Columbian pop and Seals and Crofts’ Summer Breeze.

And if the parkside deck plans are fully realised – and you can bring gamay and eat fried chicken and listen to American soft rock? My gosh. The Good Food Guide may need to introduce a fourth hat.

The low-down

Vibe: Low-key warehouse party with park views and plenty of salsa

Go-to dish: Persimmon and manchego tart ($16)

Drinks: Fun list of natural wines and fizz with most bottles below $100; excellent cocktails and agave-based spirits

Cost: About $145 for two, excluding drinks

This review was originally published in Good Weekend magazine

Continue this series

The new Sydney restaurants, bars and cafes we got excited about in August
Up next
A wall of vending machines at Gacha Cafe.

Getcha self to this fun gacha spot for snacks that taste just like Japan

Visiting this George Street spot is like cracking open a toy capsule as it swooshes down the machine.

Allta’s timber slats arch over diners like a blond wood Hokusai wave.

‘One to watch and then some’: Two-hatted newcomer is fancy, but also a lot of fun

Allta is one of Sydney’s best new restaurants to open this year. It’s also the most expensive.

Previous
Crisp-skinned red mullet on sauce Americaine with fregola.

‘Make a mess’: This beachside bolthole puts the fun into fine dining

Head chef Luke Churchill’s menu is simultaneously serious and playful, running from sultry little snacks to big-ticket, kick-up-your-heels items.

See all stories

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Original URL: https://www.theage.com.au/goodfood/sydney-eating-out/new-modern-mexican-brings-the-fiesta-to-the-inner-west-and-gets-a-hat-straight-off-the-bat-20240815-p5k2qk.html