NewsBite

Advertisement

This indoor-outdoor Argentinian-inspired grillfest boasts Balmain-to-Buenos Aires vibes

Casa Esquina’s menu includes 10 different dishes from the parrilla, from Gundagai lamb tomahawk chops to a one-kilo dry-aged Ranger’s Valley Black Market rib-eye.

Terry Durack
Terry Durack

Casa Esquina’s sprawling indoor-outdoor vibe has a special sense of freedom.
1 / 7Casa Esquina’s sprawling indoor-outdoor vibe has a special sense of freedom.Wolter Peeters
Empanadas are ideal snackage while you’re waiting for your steak.
2 / 7Empanadas are ideal snackage while you’re waiting for your steak.Wolter Peeters
The 275-gram Tajima wagyu picanha steak, served with chimichurri sauce.
3 / 7The 275-gram Tajima wagyu picanha steak, served with chimichurri sauce.Wolter Peeters
Charcoal sweet potatoes are split open at the table to show off the fluor orange flesh.
4 / 7Charcoal sweet potatoes are split open at the table to show off the fluor orange flesh.Wolter Peeters
Sweetbread and prawn paella, the rice turned pitch-black with squid ink.
5 / 7Sweetbread and prawn paella, the rice turned pitch-black with squid ink. Wolter Peeters
Alfajores are all crisp, biscuity dacquoise sandwiching rich dulce de leche and toasted coconut.
6 / 7Alfajores are all crisp, biscuity dacquoise sandwiching rich dulce de leche and toasted coconut.Wolter Peeters
The indoor space, for when the weather isn’t playing nice.
7 / 7The indoor space, for when the weather isn’t playing nice.Wolter Peeters

14/20

Argentinian$$$

Dining out is great, but dining outside is even better. There’s a special sense of freedom to drinking a margarita and nibbling empanadas while basking in the last of the day’s rays.

Since Casa Esquina opened on February 15, however, the weather has been volatile, so it’s just as well they have options. There is some undercover seating outside, or you can move into the buzzy, long walk-in bar that ends in the grill kitchen. Or head upstairs to a light-filled dining room that spills out onto a curved concrete balcony, lined with stools and fringed by the leaves of two magnificent 80-year-old camphor laurel trees.

Sometimes being sent to dine indoors by the weather feels like punishment, but Michael Fegent of Atticus Hospitality (Tequila Mockingbird, Esteban) has done a great job with this reinvention of the former Efendy site. The clean lines of poured concrete, rotating grills, shapely chairs, artful lamps and random vignettes of cactus against Victorian railing give a real Balmain-to-Buenos Aires vibe.

Advertisement
Hard-to-resist empanadas made from rough, rustic pastry.
Hard-to-resist empanadas made from rough, rustic pastry.Wolter Peeters

Fegent and head chef Will Quartel recently ate their way through Argentina, and have had fun with a menu that runs to 10 different grills from the parrilla, from Gundagai lamb tomahawk chops to a one-kilogram dry-aged Ranger’s Valley Black Market rib-eye.

To begin, it’s hard to resist the empanadas, fashioned in rough, rustic pastry, enclosing chicken and chorizo or juicy beef (both $10), or try the playful kangaroo and maraschino cherry version ($12). Consider also Esquina’s take on a Fernandito, with Fernet-Branca and cola foam ($23) or a salt-rimmed margarita of Patron Silver, Cointreau and lime ($21).

Quartel hails from Washington, DC, and has proudly put his grandmother’s lemon chess pie (a Southern US classic) on the menu, in another clue to the free-ranging approach. The kitchen loves a char – there’s a sweet potato ($15) that comes in a completely blackened sarcophagus, split open at the table to show off its fluorescent orange flesh. Waitstaff suggest the skin can be eaten, but I wouldn’t.

Besides, blackened mahimahi and black garlic pasta await for those who want it painted black. Paella, too, is pitch-black with squid ink, topped with fat lobes of Cowra lamb sweetbreads and curls of prawns ($36). It’s listed as an entree (it isn’t), and quickly makes your face look, shall we say, Halloween-ish.

Advertisement
Rice, pitch-black with squid ink, is topped with fat lobes of sweetbread and prawns.
Rice, pitch-black with squid ink, is topped with fat lobes of sweetbread and prawns.Wolter Peeters

Thank you for waiting; we are now ready to discuss the steak. Because if you know anything about cooking over coals, then you’ll know the importance of being patient. Order even a modestly sized 275-gram wodge of Tajima wagyu picanha ($76), or rump cut fringed with fat, and you’ll be in for a 30- to 40-minute wait (which is why the country invented its cocktails and snacks, let’s face it).

This isn’t meat slapped on a hot griddle and sent out sizzling. Its exposure to heat is slow and steady, leaving the meat consistently ruby-pink medium-rare from one side to the other, and the outside darkly bitumenised. Add an OK chimichurri ($3) of parsley, garlic and vinegar for acidity and piquancy.

Red wine is required, and who better to make it than Telmo Rodriguez, one of Spain’s most passionate pioneers, whose fleshy, floral LZ tempranillo ($100) is pure village-style Rioja.

The chocolate-cloaked alfajor is all crisp dacquoise sandwiching dulce de leche and toasted coconut.
The chocolate-cloaked alfajor is all crisp dacquoise sandwiching dulce de leche and toasted coconut.Wolter Peeters
Advertisement

Alfajores ($20) are cutely done here: all crisp, biscuity dacquoise sandwiching rich dulce de leche and toasted coconut, with way too much chocolate poured over the top.

There’s a slight disconnect when you can’t see, hear or smell your steak cooking, so make a point of checking out the grills yourself to close that gap. Or come for lunch on Tuesday and Wednesday when a spit grill and barbecue is set up outside for porchetta, chorizo and morcilla in rolls and burgers; or the monthly Sunday lunch asado with a whole pig or lamb on the cross, plus live music ($155 a head).

In other words, Casa Esquina has loads and loads of options and ideas. But in a changing world, and climate, you can’t have too many.

The low-down

Vibe: Mendoza grill-house with backyard barbecue

Go-to dish: 275-gram Tajima wagyu picanha, $76

Drinks: Deep dive into the wines of Spain and South America, Latin-leaning cocktails

Cost: About $270 for two, plus drinks

Continue this series

Your April hit list: The hot, new and just-reviewed places to check out, right now
Up next
Santino

Why it’s worth building a long weekend around this slick trattoria in a shopping mall

Wollongong is currently experiencing a food and wine boom. You really should go.

Chip butty with gravy sauce.

‘So damn good’: The chip butty our reviewer ordered five times in three days

From carb-loaded marvels to the Bradman burger, there’s plenty to lap up at this family-friendly cafe.

Previous
Inside Sydney’s new late-night supper club, The Caterpillar Club.

Arrive early, stay late: Your plan of attack for Sydney’s super popular new supper club

The Caterpillar Club’s very long bar rarely has a free seat. Here’s how to nab one.

See all stories

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up
Terry DurackTerry Durack is the chief restaurant critic for The Sydney Morning Herald and Good Food.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Original URL: https://www.smh.com.au/goodfood/sydney-eating-out/this-indoor-outdoor-argentinian-inspired-grillfest-boasts-balmain-to-buenos-aires-vibes-20240305-p5fa0t.html