NewsBite

Advertisement

Is swanky Sydney steakhouse Poetica the Rockpool Bar & Grill of the north?

Callan Boys
Callan Boys

The dining room is decked out in soft oak and steel-blue hues.
1 / 7The dining room is decked out in soft oak and steel-blue hues.Jennifer Soo
The 250g rump cap with grilled vegetable salad.
2 / 7The 250g rump cap with grilled vegetable salad.Jennifer Soo
Flambadou oysters with ’nduja and guindilla.
3 / 7Flambadou oysters with ’nduja and guindilla.Jennifer Soo
Spring vegetables with herb cream fraiche.
4 / 7Spring vegetables with herb cream fraiche.Jennifer Soo
Dry-aged swordfish with horseradish.
5 / 7Dry-aged swordfish with horseradish.Jennifer Soo
Brown butter cake with apple.
6 / 7Brown butter cake with apple. Jennifer Soo
Poetica Bar and Grill fills the fancy steak gap in North Sydney.
7 / 7Poetica Bar and Grill fills the fancy steak gap in North Sydney.Jennifer Soo

Good Food hat15/20

Steakhouse$$

For all the blue-chip properties around North Sydney, Kirribilli and Neutral Bay, there aren’t too many places where you can gorge on steaks more expensive than a Paul McCartney ticket and drink the appropriate shiraz. A bistro for steak frites, sure – and there’s no end of chips-or-salad pub rump specials – but any north-of-the-bridge locals jonesing for high-end wagyu have long needed to venture into the city or grill their own.

At least, I would have said that until Poetica opened in North Sydney’s central business hub four weeks ago. It hasn’t just filled the fancy steak gap: it’s stuffed to the brim with hulking sirloins, rib-eyes and tomahawks to share. Floor-to-ceiling fridges display gnarly cuts of maroon-red beef tagged with the farm of origin and dry-ageing date, some waiting more than a month to be cooked over charcoal and served with a herb sauce so green it almost looks radioactive.

If you’re a local who has long dreamt of dropping $280 on a one-kilogram T-bone and walking home, this is exciting stuff. I was champing for the restaurant to open: The Sydney Morning Herald is based in the same office block and it would be nice to have a swanky bolt-hole for cocktails after work. Poetica, I declared to any colleagues who’d listen, would be our Rockpool Bar & Grill of the north.

Advertisement
Beef and bordeaux fans of the lower north shore, your new clubhouse has arrived.

Etymon Projects – the group in charge – also operates The Charles Grand Brasserie & Bar in the CBD and hatted Lavender Bay bistro Loulou. They know a thing or two about stiff drinks and French sauces. The team also knows how to gussy up a room and the long, first-level dining area is decked out in soft oak and steel-blue hues. A semi-concealed bar is impressively comfortable and a beaut spot to hide out with a smoky house martini ($26) and half a dozen oysters ($46). Is this what the Qantas Chairman’s Lounge feels like?

Culinary director Sebastien Lutaud has worked with chef Connor Hartley-Simpson to create a menu that’s more contemporary than Etymon’s other venues. A lot of fuss is made about the open kitchen’s charcoal oven and wood-burning hearth, and the steaks, such as a 400-gram wagyu sirloin ($120) from King River in North Queensland, are indeed full of potent, concentrated flavour.

Go-to dish: Spring vegetables with herb cream fraiche.
Go-to dish: Spring vegetables with herb cream fraiche.Jennifer Soo

But – and here’s the hot tip – I think the salads are better. Assorted spring vegetables ($23) grown near Lake Macquarie by Newcastle Greens are as addictive as any hot chip: a jumble of pickled and just-cooked beetroot, radish, green beans and snowpeas sharpened with seaweed vinaigrette and pretty daubs of creme fraiche. A bright and light broad bean salad ($24) with mixed leaves and milky ricotta is precisely calibrated with a pickled lemon dressing.

Advertisement

If you worked in North Sydney and needed a spot for a quick lunch with clients, sharing those two salads and a velvety, 250-gram rump cap (the cheapest steak on the carte at $55) should have you back at your desk without suffering food-induced narcolepsy. A glass of smooth and savoury Woodlands 2019 Cabernet Merlot from Margaret River ($16) is optional.

Spicy-sweet flambadou oysters with ’nduja and guindilla.
Spicy-sweet flambadou oysters with ’nduja and guindilla.Jennifer Soo

However, if time and budget are less of a concern, there’s ample opportunity to have more fun. Oysters flambadou (I mean, it’s fun just to say “flambadou”!) translates to Sydney rocks kicked up with a guindilla pepper and ’nduja salami and drizzled with sizzling-hot beef fat. Yours for $10 a spicy-sweet pop.

Meanwhile, nubs of smoked eel and braised leeks are wrapped in nori and presented like pâté en croute ($25). An eel-bone broth poured over the dish makes it a smart and deeply flavoured choice for the table.

Focaccia di Recco ($16) is another fine idea, stuffed with gruyere cheese and capers, and baked so it’s thin and crispy and looks like something you might find at the Pizza Hut buffet. Team it with a punchy beef tartare honed by green mustard and crunchy with flecks of caramelised onion ($26).

Advertisement

The flavour of buttery fish stock accompanying 200 grams of dry-aged, lightly charred swordfish ($42) is clean and direct, but I’m less taken by the fillet’s too-soft texture.

This is a new charcoal and wood-fired kitchen, though, and it’s going to take time for the chefs to work out its sweet spots. There’s plenty to keep me coming back, not least of all a wonderfully spongy, syrupy, brown butter cake ($20) and a wine list rich with French and Australian reds.

Beef and bordeaux fans of the lower north shore, your new clubhouse has arrived. See you at the bar after knock-off on Friday.

The low-down

Vibe: Smart-casual grill-house for all occasions and very good oysters

Go-to dish: Spring vegetables with herb creme fraiche ($23)

Drinks: Wide-ranging Old and New World wine list featuring well-priced options among the trophy bottles, plus several commendable cocktails

Cost: About $180 for two, excluding drinks and dry-aged steaks

This review was originally published in Good Weekend magazine

Continue this edition

The September 30 edition
Up next

Why some winemakers think filtering removes the ‘goodness’ of the wine

Unfiltered white wines may appear cloudy, but it doesn’t necessarily mean it’s worse than a clear wine.

Good Weekend Quiz online index image

Good Weekend Superquiz and Saturday Target Time, September 30

Trivia buffs: test your knowledge with today's interactive superquiz and target.

Previous
The margherita pizza passes with flying colours.

This stylish Richmond newcomer boasts Milan supermodel looks, but are its Naples-style pizzas the goods?

Da Bruno Pizzeria serves extremely good pizza in an unusually stylish space. Meet you on the rooftop for a margherita and martini.

See all stories
Callan BoysCallan Boys is editor of SMH Good Food Guide, restaurant critic for Good Weekend and Good Food writer.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Original URL: https://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/goodfood/sydney-eating-out/is-swanky-sydney-steakhouse-poetica-the-rockpool-bar-and-grill-of-the-north-20230928-p5e8fe.html