NewsBite

Advertisement

This tiny Fitzroy eatery is a buzzy hot spot for home-style southern Indian dishes

Toddy Shop, Mischa Tropp’s popular Melbourne version of a Keralan eating house, pays fond homage to the food stands of the same name, without getting bogged down in authenticity. Thankfully, you can now make a booking.

Dani Valent
Dani Valent

Clockwise from bottom left: Dishes of egg, cabbage, dry pork and prawns with okra at Toddy Shop.
Clockwise from bottom left: Dishes of egg, cabbage, dry pork and prawns with okra at Toddy Shop.Luis Enrique Ascui

Indian$

If you name your restaurant “Toddy Shop” some people will expect it to be a replica of toddy shops they know from Kerala in southern India, informal worker cafes that serve toddy, an alcoholic beverage made from freshly fermented coconut sap, and spicy dishes such as meen pollichathu, fish wrapped in banana leaf.

You won’t find either at Mischa Tropp’s Fitzroy version of a Keralan eating house. His Toddy Shop pays fond homage to these beloved food stands without getting bogged down in strictures of authenticity. There’s toddy, but it’s a Sri Lankan bottled brew. The fish will come, once the tiny kitchen is expanded.

Toddy Shop’s tiny kitchen and bar.
Toddy Shop’s tiny kitchen and bar.Luis Enrique Ascui
Advertisement

I’m glad this cute bolthole is an ode to toddy shops rather than an attempt to replicate them, because it means I’m sitting here with a Toddy Colada, which spins a staple cocktail by shaking Kerala’s key flavours – coconut, lime, curry leaf, pineapple, toddy – and pouring them over ice. India is endlessly innovative, but even so, I don’t reckon I’d find this fun drink out the back of Kochi.

We’re in the space that previously housed grill bar Mono-XO, one that I remember fondly as the place pastry whiz (and now fireman) Pierre Roelofs ran dessert evenings almost 15 years ago.

The Keralan bar and diner has just 20 seats.
The Keralan bar and diner has just 20 seats.Luis Enrique Ascui

It’s tiny: the kitchen fits one chef and when Toddy Shop opened in December, it was a chaotic crush of inner-city foodies who loved Tropp’s pop-ups and lockdown butter chicken, and southern Indian diners from all over, hungry for a taste of home.

Tropp cooked in a solo frenzy, serving 750 people over five days at one period, rather a lot for a 20-seat restaurant. It’s settled now: you can book and the feeling is energetic, not stressed. Service is well-drilled and friendly.

Advertisement
This is home-style food for sharing, spooned into stainless-steel trays with a focus on flavour and immediacy rather than show-off presentation.

Some dishes are toddy shop classics but many are home-style, either from Mischa Tropp’s mother or from aunties who taught him in Kerala.

Coconut and curry leaves are roasted to dark golden for the prawns theeyal, the base for a sauce sharpened with tamarind and eased with jaggery.

Cabbage is fried with curry leaves and turmeric to make the sweet, simple thoran.

Peppery dry pork curry.
Peppery dry pork curry.Luis Enrique Ascui
Advertisement

Pork cubes are fried and fried and fried in their own fat until they dry to a firm, almost jerky-like texture, dense and peppery.

Boiled eggs are oozy treasures in rich onion-tomato gravy. Beetroot is cooked with ground mustard to make a perky pachadi. Polished red matta rice, fluffy and nutty, is perfect.

This is food for sharing, spooned into stainless-steel trays with a focus on flavour and immediacy rather than show-off presentation.

When I ate here, there were posters on the opposite side of the street saying, “Thank god for immigrants”. Of course, unless we’re First Nations, we are all immigrants here.

But I take it to mean, “thanks for diversity”, thanks for the waft of curry leaves down Smith Street and yes, thanks for Toddy Shop.

Continue this series

Your August hit list: The hot, new and just-reviewed places to check out, right now
Up next
The go-to dish: Pappardelle ripiene (pasta filled with Jerusalem artichoke).

Cosy Italian wine bars are a dime a dozen in Carlton. What makes this one so special?

Bar Olo was intended as the support act for sibling restaurant Scopri. Locals had other ideas.

Tasmanian produce-focused restaurant Pure South celebrates two decades in business this year.

This 20-year-old restaurant showcases Tassie, but its riverside setting is pure Melbourne

Pure South has matured into a great Melbourne restaurant: committed, consistent, creative and, in the right light, prone to making a person emotional.

Previous
Visit from 4pm for martinis and apertivi.

In Fitzroy’s backstreets glows a charming little newcomer with serious cooking cred

Go to Carnation Canteen for the $12 wines and salty snacks at aperitivo hour, stay for a lavish produce-driven dinner with back-vintage wines.

See all stories
Dani ValentDani Valent is a food writer and restaurant reviewer.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Original URL: https://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/goodfood/melbourne-eating-out/750-diners-in-five-days-tiny-20-seater-is-a-hot-spot-for-home-style-southern-indian-dishes-20240628-p5jpks.html