NewsBite

Advertisement

Vinny’s sandwich shop brings wine-bar panache to Sydney’s south

Locals are flocking to the Oatley newcomer for golden slabs of focaccia by day and cocktails at night.

Lenny Ann Low

Vinny’s is a cafe that transforms into a hopping neighbourhood bar come week’s end.
1 / 13Vinny’s is a cafe that transforms into a hopping neighbourhood bar come week’s end.Rhett Wyman
Chicken Cotoletta (“Number Seven”).
2 / 13Chicken Cotoletta (“Number Seven”). Rhett Wyman
Mortadella share plate.
3 / 13Mortadella share plate.Rhett Wyman
Vegie sandwich (“Number Six”).
4 / 13Vegie sandwich (“Number Six”). Rhett Wyman
Co-owners Louis Sobb and Simon Nardo of Vinny’s Bread & Wine.
5 / 13Co-owners Louis Sobb and Simon Nardo of Vinny’s Bread & Wine. Rhett Wyman
Focaccia slab of the week (zucchini).
6 / 13Focaccia slab of the week (zucchini).Rhett Wyman
Hot salami sandwich (“Number Four”).
7 / 13Hot salami sandwich (“Number Four”).Rhett Wyman
Buffalo mozzarella with tomato and basil.
8 / 13Buffalo mozzarella with tomato and basil.Rhett Wyman
Meatball sandwich (“Number One”).
9 / 13Meatball sandwich (“Number One”).Rhett Wyman
10 / 13 Rhett Wyman
11 / 13 Rhett Wyman
12 / 13 Rhett Wyman
13 / 13 Rhett Wyman

Bakery$

No shade on Oatley, a village suburb in Sydney’s south with manicured gardens, quiet foot traffic and tree-lined shopping streets, but it’s a surprise to discover Vinny’s Bread & Wine in the middle of it.

Serving eight kinds of focaccia sandwiches by day, it’s a cafe that transforms into a hopping neighbourhood bar come week’s end. Sangers are swapped for charcuterie share plates, live music kicks in, and a throng of customers sip on wine and cocktails from late afternoon.

Chicken Cotoletta (“Number seven”).
Chicken Cotoletta (“Number seven”). Rhett Wyman
Advertisement

Visit at lunchtime, however, and there’s still a buzz in the air from locals keenly lining up for the Mediterranean-style sandwiches. The most popular is the “Number One”, which features golden focaccia filled with rich, golf ball-sized meatballs, a herby tomato sauce, rocket, basil pesto and Parmesan. It’s beautifully plump, made to order and even better laced with zinging chilli sauce, available for an extra $2.

“Number Four” – a hot salami number with 𝄒nduja paste, sun-dried tomato and rocket – is memorable for the amount of good cured meat, the fiery buzz and the way the 𝄒nduja’s dark oils infiltrate the bread and turn the crust rosy and transparent. A tradie waiting for his “Number Seven” (chicken cotoletta) tells a staff member he’ll be back for the bar service at 4pm, after he’s scraped spattered concrete off his legs.

The standout order is the “Number Six”, a salad sandwich that piles on pickled carrot, a door stopper-sized slab of mushroom, luscious red peppers, macadamia cream and sprouts. Crunchy, fresh and salubrious. This goes in between slurps of house-made strawberry and watermelon punch – cool, not too sweet, excellently fresh – and a strong tiramisu iced latte served with a ladyfinger biscuit.

Meatball sandwich (“Number One”).
Meatball sandwich (“Number One”).Rhett Wyman

Vinny’s, which opened in September last year, is run by childhood friends Simon Nardo and brothers Louis and Jackson Sobb, who also operate Respite, a five-year-old bar in nearby Lugarno. Head chef and baker for both venues is Samuel Jerry, who worked with the trio on the focaccia menu and bar snacks. Meanwhile, drinks swing from cocktails and a dependable house red by the carafe to Italian and French bottles.

Advertisement

In a beautifully symbiotic relationship, Vinny’s bar menu (cheese, meat, dips, olives) coincides with the next door pizzeria Tutto Vero cranking up its oven. This means, Thursday to Sunday, you can follow your focaccia and fava bean dip with a margherita fresh out of the wood-fire.

Tutto’s “Pachi” pizza – ricotta-stuffed crust, twirled handkerchiefs of mortadella, fior di latte, pistachio crumb and lemon zest – is a marvel, as is the San Marzano’s fiery combination of salami, 𝄒nduja, honey, fresh ricotta and garlic oil. Pizza will be delivered to your table at Vinny’s, perhaps just as musicians start their set on a Sunday afternoon.

Three more spots for sandwiches and drinks

Norma’s Deli

A cafe, diner, food hall and bakery, Norma’s – named after owner James Sideris’ grandmother – is a sprawling one-stop shop of luscious groceries plus a cornucopia of Greek-inspired breakfast and lunch dishes. Grab a booth and pair a hot salami, eggplant and spiced honey mayo sandwich with Greek beer or Sicilian wine.

74-78 The Corso, Manly, normasdeli.com

Sol Bread and Wine

As the sun kapows into this European-style bistro-bakery’s front window, try finessed seafood, pasta, charcuterie and sandwiches (hello salted beef and sauerkraut), all available with wine and cocktails until 4pm.

Shop 2, 168 Walker Street, North Sydney, solbreadandwine.sydney

Randy’s Wine

This small bar-cafe serves beach vibes, piadinas and coffee by day before oysters, charcuterie and cocktails at night. Match sunset views with an oyster-shell martini and caraway focaccia smeared with smoked butter, or fried chicken on a dainty milk bun. 

Shop 1, 50 Old Barrenjoey Road, Avalon, randyswine.com.au

Good Food reviews are booked anonymously and paid independently. A restaurant can’t pay for a review or inclusion in the Good Food Guide.

Continue this series

Your June hit list: The hot, new and just-reviewed places to check out this month
Up next
Yan’s dining room feels much cosier than the building it inhabits.

‘Damn good value’: Why it’s worth visiting this humble suburban bolthole

Locals flock to one-hatted Yan for natural-born-killer dishes humming with garlic, a towering dessert and moments of elegance.

Assorted flavour-packed dishes at Onice.

The ‘mouth-smacking’ menu ensures you’ll never be bored at this cosy corner restaurant

Onice merges Vietnamese, Thai and Japanese flavours in an inviting space where service reigns supreme.

Previous
Dry chilli chicken.

India meets Chinatown in this chicken dish that’s not to be missed

Up-and-coming chef Ahana Dutt offers an inviting crash course in Bengali cuisine at Kolkata Social.

See all stories
Lenny Ann LowLenny Ann Low is a writer and podcaster.Connect via Twitter or email.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Original URL: https://www.watoday.com.au/goodfood/sydney-eating-out/vinny-s-sandwich-shop-brings-wine-bar-panache-to-sydney-s-south-20250513-p5lyrd.html