NewsBite

Advertisement

Ritz-Carlton’s sky-high Atria restaurant has the hype, glitz and views, but how’s the food?

At one of the Melbourne’s swankiest fine-dining restaurants, you can order steak and salad if that’s what you fancy.

Besha Rodell

Cheese ravioli draped with sea urchin and served with mussels and yuzu butter.
1 / 9Cheese ravioli draped with sea urchin and served with mussels and yuzu butter.Penny Stephens
The go-to daily crudo, featuring fish such as snapper and duckfish from local waters.
2 / 9The go-to daily crudo, featuring fish such as snapper and duckfish from local waters.Penny Stephens
Atria Restaurant, on the 80th floor of the Ritz-Carlton Hotel at 650 Lonsdale Street, Melbourne.
3 / 9Atria Restaurant, on the 80th floor of the Ritz-Carlton Hotel at 650 Lonsdale Street, Melbourne.Penny Stepehns
Executive chef Michael Greenlaw (second from right) at the bar, which doubles as an open kitchen.
4 / 9Executive chef Michael Greenlaw (second from right) at the bar, which doubles as an open kitchen.Penny Stephens
Tasmanian crab with coral custard, finger lime and makrut leaf.
5 / 9Tasmanian crab with coral custard, finger lime and makrut leaf.Penny Stephens
Rum baba dessert.
6 / 9Rum baba dessert.Penny Stephens
The dining room has soaring windows with widescreen views.
7 / 9The dining room has soaring windows with widescreen views.Chris Cypert
At night, Atria offers views of the twinkling landscape laid out below.
8 / 9At night, Atria offers views of the twinkling landscape laid out below.Chris Cypert
Culinary advisor Mark Best (left) and executive chef Michael Greenlaw at Atria.
9 / 9Culinary advisor Mark Best (left) and executive chef Michael Greenlaw at Atria.Jason Loucas

Good Food hat15.5/20

Modern Australian$$$

In recent years, I’ve occasionally wanted to scream this from the rooftops: Not all fancy restaurants need to rely upon a degustation format.

In the right hands, degustation has the potential to excite diners in exactly the way a chef intended, to tell a complete story. It also can be a useful tool in terms of pacing and economics.

But sometimes? You want all the pomp, all the trappings of fine dining, but you just want a steak and a salad.

Advertisement

This is one of the many gifts of Atria, the restaurant on the 80th floor of the new Ritz-Carlton on Lonsdale Street in the CBD. Because it functions as a hotel restaurant, it needs to be accommodating to guests as well as the public, and as such, it is now one of the fanciest restaurants we have in town that is also totally a la carte.

What do I mean when I say “fancy”? I mean a 24-carat gold wall facing the elevator bank in the lobby. I mean servers wearing gloves to set out the cutlery. I mean $30 to $60 entrees and $200 steaks.

The restaurant’s main design feature is the wall of windows and the stunning twinkling landscape laid out below: the skyscrapers of the CBD and the neighbourhoods to the north.

Atria Restaurant, on the 80th floor of the Ritz-Carlton Hotel at 650 Lonsdale Street, Melbourne.
Atria Restaurant, on the 80th floor of the Ritz-Carlton Hotel at 650 Lonsdale Street, Melbourne.Penny Stepehns
Advertisement

The best vantage point from which to take in this vista is from a long bar that doubles as a kind of kitchen counter. Larger tables are placed further back in the room, under a long chandelier that looks as though a cluster of glass mushrooms has erupted from a light sabre.

The food is a collaboration between culinary adviser Mark Best and executive chef Michael Greenlaw. This is Best’s first attachment to a single venue since he closed Marque in Sydney in 2016, and Greenlaw comes from a long background in hotel restaurants, most recently at Melbourne’s Westin. (He also spent some time cooking overseas, and at Vue de Monde from 2008 to 2010.)

The best vantage point ... is from a long bar that doubles as a kind of kitchen counter

The menu, we were told by our waiter, is inspired by traditional Indigenous seasons, this currently being the season of the Waring Wombat. I’m assuming they’re referring to the seasonal calendar of the Eastern Kulin Nation, though that wasn’t specified. Nor was it explained in what ways that calendar influenced the food we were eating. I greatly admire the intent here – to give this food a sense of place, a grounding in First Nations tradition – but it comes across as slightly cynical when the context is removed.

On the other hand, I’m heartened by the true sense of place that Best and Greenlaw are conjuring. There are native ingredients, yes; a rich and fragrant wallaby broth ($28) poured over raw slices of tender wallaby meat, topped with a flurry of herbs and flowers, like a modern Australian version of noodleless pho; hand-picked Tasmanian crab ($63) with coral custard, finger lime and makrut leaf.

Advertisement
Tasmanian crab with coral custard, finger lime and makrut leaf.
Tasmanian crab with coral custard, finger lime and makrut leaf. Penny Stephens

A Victorian crudo plate ($32) is as simple as it is arresting, the freshest fish sliced and laid out with minimal accoutrements and white soy for dipping. Don’t expect kingfish or salmon; you’re more likely to find duckfish, its opalescent flesh firm and sweet, or pinkish snapper.

There is so much potential in the seafood of our state, and too few chefs are exploring that potential the way it is presented on this one plate.

The go-to daily crudo, featuring fish such as snapper and duckfish from local waters.
The go-to daily crudo, featuring fish such as snapper and duckfish from local waters.Penny Stephens

Seafood is a strong point on the main courses, too, with a cheese ravioli ($39) draped in sea urchin so subtle and creamy it was almost floral, along with mussels and yuzu butter.

Advertisement

Half a rock lobster ($190) is one of the more expensive versions in town, but it does come with plates of reginette pasta, frilly at its edges and swathed in a simple tomato seafood sauce.

And, yes, if you just want a giant steak, you can get one; a dry-aged 1.2kg rib-eye ($210) that is a bloody, hulking glory of a thing.

Something happened during one of my visits to Atria that must be mentioned, as much as I’d like to ignore it or dismiss it as an unfortunate anomaly. We arrived, ordered from our extremely professional server, and then … sat. And sat, as guests at the tables around us moved from snacks to entrees to mains. We sat for more than an hour before any food hit the table – delicious little Jerusalem artichoke cigars ($10 each) – and then sat for another 30 minutes before our entrees arrived.

As I said, this was an anomaly. During other visits, the timing was perfect, and no one around me seemed to have any issues. A ticket got lost; accidents happen. And the staff worked hard to make it up to us, comping our desserts and apologising profusely.

But at a restaurant this expensive, with service this formal, it is astounding that no one noticed that we were sitting for so very long with nothing to eat.

Advertisement

Regardless, I will think of Atria when special occasions arise, or when friends come to town. There’s a dedication to presenting Australian ingredients in a way that’s unfussy and luxurious that is, at its best, thrilling. Add that to the beauty of our fine city stretching out before you, and you get an experience you just couldn’t have anywhere else.

The low-down

Vibe: Posh but modern; dramatic in all the right ways

Go-to dish: Daily crudo ($32)

Drinks: Wine list that goes quickly from local and affordable to international and astronomical, with little in between

Cost: About $250 for two plus drinks; more for big-ticket items

Continue this series

Melbourne’s most recently hatted restaurants to add to your wishlist
Up next
Little Picket at Lorne Bowls Club.

How humble bowlo restaurant Little Picket bowled our critic over (and gained a hat)

The pretension is low but the quality is high at Jo Barrett’s charming restaurant that embraces homely bowlo awesomeness.

Melbourne’s newest dining cathedral, Reine & La Rue.

$150 for an entree? The verdict on Melbourne’s newest, and grandest, dining room

At Reine & La Rue, the bill may be almost as breathtaking as the room. Besha Rodell ventures inside to find out whether it’s worth the cost.

Previous
Spanakopita at Hellenic House Project in Highett.

The critic’s verdict on George Calombaris’ new restaurant, Hellenic House Project

Whatever your feelings about the celebrity chef, there’s no doubting he’s an excellent cook.

See all stories
Default avatarBesha Rodell is the anonymous chief restaurant critic for The Age and Good Weekend.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Original URL: https://www.watoday.com.au/goodfood/melbourne-eating-out/ritz-carlton-s-sky-high-atria-restaurant-has-the-hype-glitz-and-views-but-how-s-the-food-20230511-p5d7o7.html