NewsBite

Advertisement

‘Supernaturally crunchy spuds’: We revisit Sydney’s most beautiful open kitchen, Fred’s

Callan Boys
Callan Boys

Inside Merivale’s farmhouse-chic Fred’s restaurant.
1 / 7Inside Merivale’s farmhouse-chic Fred’s restaurant.Jennifer Soo
Pappardelle with pork ragu bianco, rosemary and pangrattato.
2 / 7Pappardelle with pork ragu bianco, rosemary and pangrattato.Jennifer Soo
Roasted maryland of Sommerlad chicken with borlotti beans and cavolo nero.
3 / 7Roasted maryland of Sommerlad chicken with borlotti beans and cavolo nero.Jennifer Soo
Supernaturally crunchy spuds: Fred’s wood-oven roasted potatoes.
4 / 7Supernaturally crunchy spuds: Fred’s wood-oven roasted potatoes.Jennifer Soo
Salad of Moonacres Farm radicchio, sunchokes, walnuts and blue cheese.
5 / 7Salad of Moonacres Farm radicchio, sunchokes, walnuts and blue cheese.Jennifer Soo
Crispy panisse with spanner crab and kohlrabi.
6 / 7Crispy panisse with spanner crab and kohlrabi.Jennifer Soo
The marble- and linen-heavy dining room.
7 / 7The marble- and linen-heavy dining room.Jennifer Soo

Good Food hatGood Food hat16/20

Contemporary$$$

“Fred! What’s happening? How’s Sydney’s most beautiful open kitchen? Are the workbenches still covered in bitter greens with fun-to-say Italian names? Is the wood oven still roasting those supernaturally crunchy spuds? Has the warm rice pudding with cider made a winter return? It’s been too long!”

Or, at least, that’s what I might say if there were a real-life Fred behind Fred’s. Merivale boss Justin Hemmes coined the name when his hospitality group opened the farmhouse-style restaurant in 2016. It was supposed to convey the humble nature of a new venue focused on “honest” food at the posh end of Oxford Street. I’m not sure a dining room with so much marble and heavy linen can ever be considered humble, but it was a nice pitch and the fine diner has been awarded two hats in the Good Food Guide ever since.

Founding chef [and now Good Food contributor] Danielle Alvarez was key to Fred’s success, developing relationships with NSW farmers and building on the rock-solid techniques she learned at California’s legendary, produce-championing Chez Panisse. The US-born chef left a little over 12 months ago, but there’s still a strong narrative of “farm to table” cooking. It’s also a wonderfully plush place to lose track of the time and consider another martini.

Advertisement

Irish-born chef Hussein Sarhan is now the head rattler of Fred’s hammered-copper pans, and he cooks the kind of minimal intervention, vaguely French food I like to imagine serving friends in my own kitchen (if only my apartment had a two-metre-long, coal-filled hearth).

Crispy panisse topped with spanner crab and kohlrabi.
Crispy panisse topped with spanner crab and kohlrabi.Jennifer Soo

We start with two-bite bricks of toasted panisse topped with a crab and kohlrabi sort-of-slaw. Delicious, albeit $18 each. The bill can skyrocket before you’ve even ordered booze.

Speaking of, Fred’s was the first Merivale restaurant to prominently feature natural wine, and there’s plenty of additive-free gear listed next to historic French and Australian drops (more bottles for less than $100 would be nice, though).

Roast chook is on the way and our sommelier recommends Alpha Box & Dice’s bright and leesy 2021 “Corrugated Castle” ($110), made from Adelaide Hills chardonnay. The 1989 Chateau Margaux ($5800) can wait. A one-kilogram rib-eye ($210) and whole eastern rock lobster ($250) can wait, too.

Advertisement
Salad of Moonacres Farm radicchio, sunchokes, walnuts and blue cheese.
Salad of Moonacres Farm radicchio, sunchokes, walnuts and blue cheese.Jennifer Soo

Sarhan grills a fine steak and shellfish, I’m sure, but he also approaches seasonal greens with the same enthusiasm I have for eating jaffles in bed. The salads are better value: bitter leaves of lettuce-like castelfranco, for instance, are teamed with walnuts, blue cheese and thin-sliced discs of raw Jerusalem artichoke ($28). It’s everything a salad should be: modest, beautifully dressed and alive with texture.

A ball of olive oil-drizzled mozzarella is $34, but it’s handmade from the milk of buffalo raised on pasture near Myall Lake, and you won’t taste a more luscious cheese outside of Italy. Silky ribbons of speck and confit chestnuts provide extra interest and crunch. Share a salad, the mozzarella and a pasta or two and you can leave Fred’s without haemorrhaging too much cash.

The weather demands something with heft, so we gravitate towards a well-executed white ragu of pork, with pappardelle so wide it could audition for lasagne ($34).

Supernaturally crunchy spuds: Fred’s wood-oven roasted potatoes.
Supernaturally crunchy spuds: Fred’s wood-oven roasted potatoes.Jennifer Soo
Advertisement

And yes, those rosemary-enhanced spuds ($16) are still rustling about, and still a glorious triumph of crackled edges and steaming white flesh.

Roast potatoes need roast chicken, and there’s a flattened maryland of Sommerlad-breed chook ($49) with borlotti beans and blitzed cavolo nero for the occasion. The skin is taut and a deep shade of amber, the meat long-flavoured and juicy.

Go-to dish: Sommerlad chicken with borlotti beans and cavolo nero (and a side of wood-oven roasted potatoes, top left).
Go-to dish: Sommerlad chicken with borlotti beans and cavolo nero (and a side of wood-oven roasted potatoes, top left).Jennifer Soo

A side of roasted and over-salted fioretto cauliflower ($16) is the only disappointment.

Oh, and the rice pudding ($22) is no longer served warm, but chilled and topped with rhubarb from Moonacres Farm at Robertson. It’s most probably a humdinger, but we roll the dice on a hot buckwheat crepe ($26) instead, sticky with a reduced apple sauce and brown-butter ice-cream. There are no regrets.

Advertisement
Share a salad, the mozzarella and a pasta or two and you can leave without haemorrhaging too much cash.

“Thanks so much for a wonderful dinner, Fred. The staff were engaged and efficient, and we simply loved the old-timey jazz soundtrack. The whole French farmhouse thing still feels a bit manufactured, between you and me, but the new chef’s commitment to seasonal produce is second to none, and that castelfranco salad is a cracker. We’ll have to splash out and order the lobster one of these days. See you again soon!”

The low-down

Vibe: Farmhouse chic for the eastern suburbs’ champagne set

Go-to dish: Sommerlad chicken with borlotti beans and cavolo nero ($49)

Drinks: Strong selection of French and Australian wines, smart cocktails and well-priced whiskies

Cost: About $200 for two, excluding drinks, lobster and one-kilogram steaks

This review was originally published in Good Weekend magazine

Continue this series

50 of Sydney’s best long lazy lunch spots that go beyond the sandwich
Up next
The clamorous dining room has a 20-seat private room and a stool-lined bar saved for walk-ins.

Love Tilly team’s buzzy new Palazzo Salato serves up proper pasta and candlelit glam

The latest venue from the Love Tilly Group is its biggest ever, bringing the best of old-school dining and new-gen talent.

The main 50-seat dining room is lined with an Etruscan mural, giving it the air of a basement crypt.

Does the Hubert team’s decadent new grillhouse Le Foote live up to the hype?

Swillhouse Group’s ambitious new multi-level Mediterranean venue is a labyrinthine adventure straight out of a Fellini movie.

Previous
Go-to dish: the Diner Burger is a spectacular, straight-up example of the craft.

The Surf Deck's burger is hard to beat on a summer afternoon

The perfect cheeseburger doesn't exist, but this beachside cocktail shack might be the perfect place to scoff one.

See all stories

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up
Callan BoysCallan Boys is editor of SMH Good Food Guide, restaurant critic for Good Weekend and Good Food writer.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Original URL: https://www.smh.com.au/goodfood/sydney-eating-out/supernaturally-crunchy-spuds-we-revisit-sydney-s-most-beautiful-open-kitchen-fred-s-20230614-p5dgm3.html