NewsBite

Advertisement

Seafood stars north of the bridge at Petermen in St Leonards

Terry Durack
Terry Durack

The north shore scales up at Josh and Julie Niland's Petermen in St Leonards.
The north shore scales up at Josh and Julie Niland's Petermen in St Leonards. James Brickwood

Good Food hat15.5/20

Seafood$$$

Josh Niland wants the world to eat more fish. He's so serious about it, there isn't a skerrick of meat on the new Petermen menu. Instead, the fish IS the meat.

Niland's devious strategy of treating fish as if it were steak, chops, sausages and salumi was honed at his flagship Saint Peter, at Rose Bay's Charcoal Fish and at his Fish Butchery stores in Paddington and Waterloo.

For Petermen, he has created a range of large-format fish dishes that act as ensembles designed to make the protein a star.

Advertisement
Coral trout for two on chimichurri with O Couto peppers.
Coral trout for two on chimichurri with O Couto peppers.James Brickwood

The Mooloolaba chateaubriand ($120 for two, $240 for four) is the most obvious example, with South Coast yellowfin tuna treated like filet mignon. The rosy-pink rounds come with a tumble of shoestring fries, surrounded by satellite dishes – mushrooms, garlic warrigal greens, sauce bearnaise.

Think of it as a benign dictatorship. This is how the chef wants you to eat his fish, with the correct accompaniments, so that's how he serves them.

There's also a focus on vegetables – harissa eggplant, pickled vegetables from Duck Foot Farm, and lovely craggy empanadas ($13 each). Stuffed with wilted saltbush, they're served, probably gratuitously, with a fruity, oily, finely chopped Turkish ezme salad of roasted red peppers and herbs.

Saltbush empanadas.
Saltbush empanadas. James Brickwood
Advertisement

Co-owner Julie Niland has given the long window-lined space a contemporary Scandinavian feel, brightened by paintings from the irrepressible Ken Done, an artist obsessed with ocean life. Bare solid tables of sustainable rubberwood have a mid-century air, and the bar has handsome art deco elements – as well as Never Never's stunning Oyster Shell gin for appropriately saline martinis.

The oysters themselves are listed, unusually, by age. Pristine Merimbula three-year-olds ($7 each) are so briny and celebratory they force me to go all classic and order muscadet – a crisp, minerally, good-value 2019 Domaine St Martin ($70). Muscadet is also the go with stunning Goolwa pipis ($38) swimming in a surfy froth of their own juices.

Niland's temperature-controlled dry-ageing makes the most of oily varieties such as leaping bonito ($16), whose clean, raw flesh is precision-sliced and seasoned with bone soy. Glistening tiles of velvety yellowfin tuna ($20) come sauced with a sharp but sweet Ananda caper and black garlic vinaigrette, finished with caper leaves.

Jervis Bay mussels in achiote vinaigrette.
Jervis Bay mussels in achiote vinaigrette. James Brickwood

Head chef Joshua Osborne keeps flavours either crisp and clean or roguishly fruity and oily; with a rough-and-tumble of shelled Jervis Bay mussels bathed in a dirty-red achiote (annatto seed) vinaigrette ($16) that I love.

Advertisement

Most reports on the Saint Peter oeuvre concentrate on the exotica – fish-eye crisps, cod fat salted caramels. I'm more taken with how Niland has captured the essence of coral trout, dry-ageing then grilling it so the skin is as crunchy as crackling yet the flesh is relaxed and almost sweet.

It comes as an ensemble ($145 for two), on a bed of fruity chimichurri that is as finely chopped as mirepoix, with a line-up of Richard Mohan's O Couto peppers (one of which is – surprise! – hellishly hot) and a very cute crumbed croquette of collar meat.

Manjimup marron, curry butter and fried bread.
Manjimup marron, curry butter and fried bread. James Brickwood

Western Australia's marron weighs in at 350 grams ($80), its shell darkly crimson, its juicy, pull-apart lobster-like flesh oozing with curry butter.

After all that, Julie Niland's desserts offer a refined finish, with a classic take on apple tart ($18) that sees apple "scales" glazed with verjuice and topped with grilled vanilla bean ice-cream.

Advertisement

The systems aren't quite bedded down yet, with some waits for both tables and dishes. Small wonder. Petermen is a vastly ambitious operation, with as many arms as an octopus. There is also a kid's menu (the couple have four children; they know their market) with barbecue fish, salad and chippies. The cult Saint Peter Sunday brunch has also crossed the bridge, with double tuna cheeseburgers and sea urchin crumpets.

Verjuice apple tart with grilled vanilla ice-cream.
Verjuice apple tart with grilled vanilla ice-cream.James Brickwood

It's as brave as anything else the Nilands have done, but also more approachable and enjoyable. At this rate, the world will definitely be eating more fish.

The low-down

Drinks Small cocktail list including a few low and no-alcohol, and a list of fruity whites and light reds, many with an oceanic theme

Advertisement

Vibe Smart Scandi-minimalist fish bistro with hidden depths

Go-to dish 350g Manjimup marron, curry butter and fried bread, $80

Continue this series

Hush hour: 30 of the best Sydney restaurants for quiet conversations (and great food)
Up next
Buffalo mozzarella, broad beans, green tomatoes, fennel and lemon.

Can Arthur save the dego?

The dishes come two by two at Arthur, turning what looks like a scarily long tasting menu into a five-course meal.

Omurice with tempura, tomato sauce and melted cheese.

Home-style Japanese omelettes at Omu in Ultimo

When Mikiko Terasaki started serving omurice at her market stall, she became a social media sensation. Now she's serving up the Japanese staple in her permanent diner.

Previous
Lana is on the first floor of Hinchcliff House, an 1870s wool store transformed into a multi-level Italian dining experience.

Sydney's CBD strikes back at Lana

New fine-diner Lana over-delivers on just about everything.

See all stories
Terry DurackTerry Durack is the chief restaurant critic for The Sydney Morning Herald and Good Food.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Original URL: https://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/goodfood/sydney-eating-out/petermen-review-20230307-h2ab8i.html