NewsBite

Advertisement

This thrilling modern Indian restaurant is an excellent addition to Lygon Street

Kahaani’s “unreasonably authentic” menu is different to the classic Australian-Indian dishes you might expect.

Dani Valent
Dani Valent

Kahaani features a traditional clay render on its dining room walls.
1 / 8Kahaani features a traditional clay render on its dining room walls.Bonnie Savage
Go-to dish: Ghar ka gosht (goat curry).
2 / 8Go-to dish: Ghar ka gosht (goat curry).Bonnie Savage
Bread pudding.
3 / 8Bread pudding.Bonnie Savage
Puri flatbread crisps with chana dhal.
4 / 8Puri flatbread crisps with chana dhal.Bonnie Savage
Kale chips battered in chickpea flour, with beetroot puree and drizzled with a trio of chutneys.
5 / 8Kale chips battered in chickpea flour, with beetroot puree and drizzled with a trio of chutneys.Bonnie Savage
Parda biryani, sealed with a sheet of pastry.
6 / 8Parda biryani, sealed with a sheet of pastry.Bonnie Savage
Inside the parda biryani.
7 / 8Inside the parda biryani.Bonnie Savage
Kahaani’s creative cocktails incorporate Indian flavours and concepts.
8 / 8Kahaani’s creative cocktails incorporate Indian flavours and concepts.Bonnie Savage

14.5/20

Indian$$

I met an old friend for coffee last week and we scrolled through our phones to share photos of our kids. Her sweet posse showed up on every screen. I had to thumb my way through dozens of food shots to find any humans. And to be honest, the dog appeared 10 times before any children. “I do love them,” I muttered. Even worse, I got distracted along the way. I came upon images of a recent dinner and stopped scrolling, captured by colours, absorbed in memories of flavours. “Ahem,” said my friend. “Kahaani,” I replied, jolted from my reverie, sharing the name of this excellent Indian restaurant.

That’s my tale. Kahaani – it means “story” in Hindi and Urdu – has its own. There’s the one about the goat curry that chef and co-owner Aseem Sood ate every Sunday as a child in Punjab, the onions in ghee slowly caramelising in a copper pot, the smell of black cardamom and bay leaves floating through the kitchen. He makes that same curry here, in small batches, braising it until meat falls from bones into a rich gravy.

Go-to dish: Ghar ka gosht (goat curry).
Go-to dish: Ghar ka gosht (goat curry).Bonnie Savage
Advertisement

Co-owner Kunal Bhardwaj tells the story of the clay render in the restaurant. He and Aseem slapped it on the walls themselves: it’s the same material used to build homes in Indian villages. It looks nice, a textured contrast to the exposed bricks, but it’s special because it connects this Melbourne dining room to its cultural origins. It’s also a feature of the tandoor oven in the kitchen.

Staff at Kahaani wear T-shirts proclaiming “Unreasonably authentic”. I puzzle over this. Authenticity is a tricky concept, especially in a nation such as India, which comprises hundreds of overlapping cultures, its people absorbing and reimagining food in an endlessly dynamic masala. But I think what they’re getting at is that Kahaani is different to the classic Australian-Indian restaurants that started proliferating in the 1980s.

With their long rote menus (chicken rogan josh, chicken tikka masala, chicken korma, butter chicken, chicken vindaloo and so on), they end up flattening enormous variety into a standardised experience. Additionally, by being inexpensive, these restaurants have backed themselves – and those that follow – into a tricky corner.

Kahaani is one of a number of local businesses undertaking the hard job of reframing Indian food as thrilling and complex, as redolent with story as it is with spices, and worth paying good money for. (Fellow travellers include Enter Via Laundry, Atta, Ish, Elchi, Cafe Southall, Daughter In Law and Toddy Shop.)

The one-page menu is organised around a map of India, encompassing smoked chicken curry ($34) from Himachal Pradesh in the far north to coconut prawns ($36) from Kerala, about 2500 kilometres to the south.

Advertisement
Parda biryani.
Parda biryani.Bonnie Savage

There are dishes that cut across time as well as place: biryani made its way around the subcontinent from the 16th century along with Mughal invaders. The Kahaani “parda” (veiled) version ($32) is sealed with a sheet of pastry that captures flavour and moisture. Biryani is richer and more succulent when made with meat on the bone, but the boneless, easy-to-eat chicken rendition here is still very tasty.

Interaction is a theme: cutting through the “parda” is a fun reveal. I also loved piling my own filling into pani puri, a crisp street snack ($18), and spooning minced lamb into pav (soft rolls) to make sloppy, succulent sliders ($23).

Kale chips battered in chickpea flour, with pickled beetroot puree and drizzled with a trio of chutneys.
Kale chips battered in chickpea flour, with pickled beetroot puree and drizzled with a trio of chutneys.Bonnie Savage

Creativity is threaded through the menu, which is authentically Indian, too. A common “chaat” (snack) of fried spinach leaves is reimagined with kale ($19). Can all my kale chips be this wonderful henceforth? Battered in chickpea flour, they’re a crunchy cacophony, drizzled with a sweet-and-tangy trio of chutneys: date and tamarind, mint and coriander, and cardamom yoghurt. Pickled beetroot puree adds even more sparkle.

Advertisement

The same fanciful joy is evident in Kunal Bhardwaj’s cocktail menu (all $24). The Shikanji is a gin-and-citrus concoction that riffs on nimbu pani, a spiced lemonade. In Hindu lore, Lord Vishnu and Goddess Lakshmi inhabit the gooseberry (amla) tree. The auspicious amla are infused into gin to make the seductive Amlata drink.

That this heartfelt, 18-month-old restaurant is on Lygon Street is entirely appropriate. This strip is currently in transition, still anchored by Italian restaurants but with an influx of subcontinental, Middle Eastern and Asian dining options. Kahaani is part of the new wave, spinning delicious stories and forging a fresh path for Indian food in Melbourne.

The low-down

Vibe: Sprightly contemporary Indian storytelling

Go-to dish: Ghar ka gosht (goat curry), $36)

Drinks: The wine list leans to low-intervention small producers with a changing roster by the glass. Excellent cocktails incorporate Indian flavours and concepts.

Cost: About $140 for two, excluding drinks

This review was originally published in Good Weekend magazine

Advertisement

Continue this series

Your April hit list: The hot, new and just-reviewed places to check out this month
Up next
Pair Sydney rock oysters with a two-sip martini made with Never Never’s Oyster Shell Gin.

The bar might be the best seat in the house at airy new South Melbourne restaurant Lucia

Pony up for a view of the glass-fronted seafood bar, where you can snack on the Med’s answer to prawn spring rolls and a very Australian take on tartare.

The two-level restaurant, and its $70 banquet, is a good option for groups.

Greek food is having a moment, but this 40-year-old city icon is an authentic stayer

Family restaurant Tsindos, and its secret eggplant dip, has been a Lonsdale Street stalwart for 40 years.

Previous
Brico restaurant and wine bar in Carlton North.

Is it a restaurant or a wine bar? It doesn’t matter when it’s as friendly and fun as this

The people slurping oysters at the counter reckon they’re in a bar, but the bistro chairs, fine cooking and ability to book a table say “restaurant” to me.

See all stories

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up
Dani ValentDani Valent is a food writer and restaurant reviewer.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Original URL: https://www.theage.com.au/goodfood/melbourne-eating-out/this-thrilling-modern-indian-restaurant-is-an-excellent-addition-to-lygon-street-20240306-p5fadx.html