Bang for your buck: Stefanino Panino in Lygon Street nails the Italian sandwich
The first in a series of reviews exploring exceptional suburban, value-for-money eating.
Italian$
There’s a little sandwich joint at the Brunswick East end of Lygon Street that’s so good it usually sells out before lunchtime on Fridays and Saturdays. Known as Stefanino Panino, it’s operated by former schoolteacher Stef Condello and his mum, Diana, whose parents migrated from Italy in the 1950s, making Brunswick their home.
A deli fridge filled with cheese, salumi and ricotta dominates the space. There’s nowhere to sit and the only contributions to the decor are a framed Essendon Bombers jersey and a few small, framed paintings and photographs, which merely add to the charm of this family-run spot.
The venue owes its popularity to its one-page list of 10 heavy-hitting Italian-inspired panini – ciabatta rolls stuffed with simple, high-quality ingredients paired together beautifully.
Salumi are sliced so thinly they melt in the mouth, creamy cheeses such as stracciatella from That’s Amore are applied liberally, and other ingredients such as fresh and marinated vegetables or ’nduja, spreadable fermented Calabrian chilli sausage, add further savour.
Carlton North’s Natural Tucker Bakery supplies the ciabattas, whose open, airy crumb provides the perfect platform for the rich fillings. Most are used to make up Bologna rolls ($15), two-handers packed with mortadella, stracciatella, pickled peppers and green olives.
I prefer its richer counterpart, Il Manzo ($16), loaded with rare roast beef, provolone, mild pickled peppers, roast capsicum, red onion and a sharp blanket of Dijon mustard.
Come lunchtime, the joint is heaving with locals, so grab your panino before 12.30pm or risk missing out.
Gluten-free and vegan options are available, and panini can be custom-made with either three ($13), four ($15) or five ($17) fillings. They include salumi such as mortadella, hot or fennel salami or porchetta, which are sliced to order (and can be ordered by weight to take home).
Rounding out the menu are cannoli from Cannoleria by That’s Amore, which are filled on-site with fresh ricotta, filter coffee ($4), and bottled Italian fruit juices ($4).
Come lunchtime, the joint is heaving with locals, so grab your panino before 12.30pm or risk missing out. This is set to change in the future when they move locally with hopes to open a licensed dine-in spot that opens for dinner too – with more to come later.
The lowdown
Good for: A quick, grab-and-go takeaway lunch
Must-order dish: Il Manzo ($16)
Go-to drink: Golden Brown Coffee filter coffee ($4)
Cost: About $40 for two, including a drink
Continue this series
The June Melbourne hit list: Hot, new and just-reviewed places to check out, right nowUp next
Korean soul food meets Melbourne-style cafe at the better-than-great Ondo
A fine dining chef’s cafe menu shows Korean food means so much more than fried chicken and barbecued beef.
Is Lagotto one of Melbourne’s great under-appreciated restaurants?
With food better than it needs to be (including the best steak this critic has eaten in ages), it’s a mystery why this Fitzroy North Italian isn’t better known.
Previous
Melbourne’s new ace of base: Pinsabella brings ‘pinsa’ to town (just don’t call it pizza)
There’s a bright, crisp crunching sound that makes it clear: this rectangular-shaped cheese-oozy margherita isn’t a pizza.