NewsBite

Advertisement

‘Completely over the top and ridiculous’: The Sanderson sells the sizzle and the steak

The owners of Sydney’s newest luxe seafood and steakhouse are determined to pull out all the stops, with dishes such as eclair carbonara, spanner crab salad served tableside and choose-your-own Argentinean knives.

Terry Durack
Terry Durack

Wagyu scotch fillet is aged for at least six weeks in Japanese whisky.
1 / 12Wagyu scotch fillet is aged for at least six weeks in Japanese whisky.Edwina Pickles
The go-to dish, eclair carbonara oozing pecorino custard.
2 / 12The go-to dish, eclair carbonara oozing pecorino custard.Edwina Pickles
Fraser Island spanner crab salad for two is mixed tableside.
3 / 12Fraser Island spanner crab salad for two is mixed tableside.Edwina Pickles
Crisp, golden cubes of potato roesti with saltbush.
4 / 12Crisp, golden cubes of potato roesti with saltbush. Edwina Pickles
Murray cod is paired with lemony fennel and a tumble of crisp Jerusalem artichokes.
5 / 12Murray cod is paired with lemony fennel and a tumble of crisp Jerusalem artichokes.Edwina Pickles
Medjool sticky date pudding is finished with whisky butterscotch sauce.
6 / 12Medjool sticky date pudding is finished with whisky butterscotch sauce.Edwina Pickles
Blueberries and cream.
7 / 12Blueberries and cream.Edwina Pickles
Steak eaters are offered a roll of Argentinean knives so they can choose their weapon.
8 / 12Steak eaters are offered a roll of Argentinean knives so they can choose their weapon.Edwina Pickles
Velvet booths under the original timber windows in The Sanderson dining room.
9 / 12Velvet booths under the original timber windows in The Sanderson dining room.Edwina Pickles
Plush booths, rich blue walls and globe lights in The Sanderson dining room.
10 / 12Plush booths, rich blue walls and globe lights in The Sanderson dining room.Steven Woodburn
The Sanderson’s heritage windows dominate the dining room.
11 / 12The Sanderson’s heritage windows dominate the dining room.Steven Woodburn
Sven Almenning, head chef James Green, and Greg Sanderson at The Sanderson.
12 / 12Sven Almenning, head chef James Green, and Greg Sanderson at The Sanderson.Dominic Lorrimer

Good Food hat15/20

Contemporary$$$

There’s steak, and then there’s sizzle. And the Speakeasy Group’s Sven Almenning and Greg Sanderson have always done good sizzle, whether at their award-winning cocktail bar Eau de Vie, Viking-themed Mjolner, Parramatta’s Nick & Nora’s, or their Melbourne equivalents. Now they’ve launched The Sanderson, which comes with steak as well as sizzle.

You can feel the fizz of energy in the air as you arrive on the first floor of the 101-year-old Beneficial House and clock the dry-aged ducks and ribs of beef hanging behind reception. Past the kitchen, the large dining room crackles with energy, as gueridon trolleys moor tableside and trays of cocktails are ferried from the bar. A loud crowd settles into curvaceous velvet booths under the original timber windows, book-ended by colourful artworks by figurative American painter Todd White.

Ordering Fraser Island spanner crab salad may set off a chain reaction in the dining room.
Ordering Fraser Island spanner crab salad may set off a chain reaction in the dining room.Edwina Pickles
Advertisement

Don’t think you get to relax at the table, either. A tick-the-box list is your shortcut to being served oysters, caviar, martinis or a glass of Krug, in case you need sustenance while you peruse the menu proper.

Plus, you have three different sea and river salts from which to choose. And those ordering steak will be asked to select their weapon of choice from a roll of fierce-looking Argentinean knives.

Wait, someone is already pouring a drink into a small pewter cup in front of me. I miss entirely what it is (sweetish, lemony) as they recite a verse that sounds like a rhyming toast to good health. Or it could have been wealth, which you will also need to frolic in the shallows of The Sanderson.

Speaking of rich, I’m loving the eclair carbonara ($14 each). The finger of choux pastry, topped with crisp, salty guanciale, oozes with peppery pecorino custard. But then it’s on with the show, courtesy of executive chef James Green, formerly of Manta and North Bondi Fish (also responsible for the newly installed Eau de Vie in the basement).

Fraser Island spanner crab salad for two is prepared and served tableside.
Fraser Island spanner crab salad for two is prepared and served tableside.Edwina Pickles
Advertisement

An order of Fraser Island spanner crab salad ($44 for two), brings the gueridon trolley, and a waiter who expertly tosses picked crab meat with macadamia, cucumber, eschalot, chives and a wonderfully hot, sour and salty lemon kosho, spooning it all back into the crab shell with avocado puree and roasted macadamia and garlic cream. It’s live, theatrical and charming enough to set up a catapult effect of every table next to me ordering it next, but it needs something better than the tough little Melba toast squares accompanying it.

Dry-aged Murray cod ($62) gets a brisk sear, nicely paired with lemony fennel and a tumble of crisp Jerusalem artichokes on their own silky puree. The crisp, golden cubes of potato roesti ($16) deserve special mention,for being so light and fluffy.

We’re not low-key, and we’re not trying to be. We want to pull out all the stops.
Sven Almenning

Three steaks are on offer, with the wagyu scotch fillet ($89) aged for at least six weeks in “The Tottori” Japanese whisky, before being grilled medium-rare on a Brazilian lava rock grill (the heritage listing doesn’t enable charcoal). It comes cooler than it should, with roasted garlic and a tumble of watercress. There are six sauces to choose from (an extra $6), and a rich, smooth, miso and roasted garlic butter is fetchingly served in a tunnel of marrow bone. They also want to drizzle their own olive oil, made by Rio Vista in South Australia, over the steak. One or the other, methinks, not both.

But that’s The Sanderson for you, never knowingly underplaying its hand. “We’re not low-key, and we’re not trying to be,” says Almenning. “We want to pull out all the stops.”

Advertisement
Medjool sticky date pudding with whisky butterscotch sauce.
Medjool sticky date pudding with whisky butterscotch sauce.Edwina Pickles

So when pastry chef Kelvin Chin flavours the Medjool sticky date pudding ($22) with Guinness and finishes it with a whisky butterscotch sauce, he’s just playing by the company rules.

It’s completely over the top and ridiculous, but it works, drawing us out of our passivity as diners and turning us into collaborators instead. Let’s face it, anyone can cook a steak. This is for those who prefer the sizzle.

The low-down

Drinks: Guinness on tap, single malts, signature cocktails, and a pricey, opinionated Franco-Australian wine list

Vibe: Grand old-school dining room with extra sizzle

Go-to dish: Eclair carbonara, black pepper, chive, $14

Continue this series

Sydney’s 10 most recently hatted restaurants to add to your wishlist
Up next
 Yoshii’s Omakase at Crown Sydney.

17 courses, 10 guests, more than two years to book: Is Yoshii’s Omakase worth the $350 price tag?

You’ll need superpowers with a budget to match just to make a booking. So does Crown Sydney’s three-hour Japanese chef’s dinner deliver?

Aromatic leaves provide the wrapper for the Skull Island prawn “taco”.

The Hartsyard team go full coastal at new Chippendale restaurant Longshore, but does it make waves?

Longshore has landed at the site that once housed Automata with a coastal vibe and a focus on seafood.

Previous
The main 50-seat dining room is lined with an Etruscan mural, giving it the air of a basement crypt.

Does the Hubert team’s decadent new grillhouse Le Foote live up to the hype?

Swillhouse Group’s ambitious new multi-level Mediterranean venue is a labyrinthine adventure straight out of a Fellini movie.

See all stories

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up
Terry DurackTerry Durack is the chief restaurant critic for The Sydney Morning Herald and Good Food.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Original URL: https://www.theage.com.au/goodfood/sydney-eating-out/completely-over-the-top-and-ridiculous-the-sanderson-sells-the-sizzle-and-the-steak-20230613-p5dg9u.html