NewsBite

Advertisement

Icon review: Not much has changed in 63 years at old-school Italian restaurant Amiconi (aside from the tiramisu)

Dani Valent
Dani Valent

Inside the 63-year-old Amiconi Italian restaurant.
1 / 7Inside the 63-year-old Amiconi Italian restaurant.Justin McManus
Linguine with prawn and pistachio.
2 / 7Linguine with prawn and pistachio.Justin McManus
Garlic mushrooms.
3 / 7Garlic mushrooms.Justin McManus
The dining room’s cork-lined walls are decorated with mementos and photographs.
4 / 7The dining room’s cork-lined walls are decorated with mementos and photographs.Justin McManus
Veal scallopini alla arrabbiata.
5 / 7Veal scallopini alla arrabbiata.Justin McManus
Chicken livers are a menu mainstay.
6 / 7Chicken livers are a menu mainstay.Justin McManus
Tiramisu.
7 / 7Tiramisu.Justin McManus

Italian$$

Sometimes walls really do talk. At Amiconi, an Italian restaurant that’s been welcoming Melbourne for 63 years, the cork-lined walls tell stories in wedding portraits, caricatures, newspaper clippings, baby snaps, horse racing memorabilia and photographs of epic fishing trips.

What does it all say? This cosy room is lived in and – more importantly – loved in.

In 1960, Angela and Francesco Amiconi and their son Guy opened an espresso bar where Italians sipped coffee and played scopa. Card playing is a hungry business, so Angela would make osso buco, maybe bolognese, to keep patrons fuelled.

Advertisement
Amiconi is old-school: portions are generous, trends are unknown.

Guy and his wife Paula later turned Amiconi into more of a restaurant and – snap your fingers, it’s 2023 – here we are eating calamari and livers and linguine.

Co-owner Michael Cardamone bought the restaurant from the Amiconis in 1982 when he ditched accounting for food. After doing the books for restaurants, he thought there was more money in lunches than ledgers – ah, you have to love the 1980s!

Since 2007, Cardamone’s partners are Joe Musso, a chef here for 30 years, and Vince Alfonso, who’s cooked here for 25 years and also works as a waiter. The consistency, the absolute anchoring in community, and a bedrock belief in sincere hospitality are what make this restaurant.

Favourite dishes include baked mushrooms made this way since before man landed on the moon. Stuffed with parmesan, garlic and butter, they’re a fail-safe way to launch a meal into the stratosphere.

Advertisement

Just about everyone has the tender calamari, cut thin on a meat slicer that Guy Amiconi modded in the 1960s.

There are always chicken livers, expertly grilled and served with balsamic dressing.

Chicken livers are a menu mainstay.
Chicken livers are a menu mainstay.Justin McManus

The kitchen turns out 60 kilograms of lovingly handmade potato gnocchi each week: it’s served alla matriciana with bacon and shallots.

Of course, pasta is popular, too. There’s a marinara with mixed seafood, but I love the linguine tossed with chilli and garlic prawns, a little wine and fresh tomato, then tumbled with rocket and pistachios.

Advertisement

Veal can be a controversial meat, but anyone who consumes dairy should probably eat baby boy calves. The scallopini alla arrabbiata sees milk-fed veal pan-fried in a sizzle of brandy, finished with napoli, parmesan and chicken stock. It’s sweet and tender with a subtle nudge of chilli.

Veal scallopini alla arrabbiata.
Veal scallopini alla arrabbiata.Justin McManus

The wine list does the job, but you can also BYO. Amiconi is old-school: portions are generous, trends are unknown, stock and jus is made on-site.

They’re not immune to innovation, though. Tiramisu is built in a cylindrical mould, rich with house-made marsala-spiked zabaglione, layered with sponge fingers, coffee and mascarpone cream.

It’s a reworked classic, presented with the warmth and pride that ripples through the whole restaurant. Long live Amiconi.

Continue this series

Melbourne hit list July 2023: Hot, new and just-reviewed places to check out, right now
Up next
Cibi’s current cafe and shop, which will soon be separated to give more room to grocery products.

A fan of Japanese food and drink? Here are three venues to put on your must-visit list

Stand by for a soothing cafe hiding in plain sight, the return of a funk-fuelled and wood-fired regional pop-up, and a Melbourne treasure set to expand.

Go-to dish: Banh khot (coconut and turmeric mini pancakes).

Rue de Thanh is serving some of the most interesting and delicious Vietnamese food in Melbourne

This forward-thinking newcomer on the precarious end of Brunswick Street deserves to succeed. Let’s make it happen.

Previous
Con Christopoulos can often be found on the floor at his first Greek restaurant, Kafeneion.

‘So very Melbourne’: Why humble Greek restaurant Kafeneion is an instant classic

The fitout’s a bit timeworn and the home-style dishes aren’t meant for Instagram. But this winter pop-up is our critic’s new favourite restaurant.

See all stories

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up
Dani ValentDani Valent is a food writer and restaurant reviewer.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Original URL: https://www.theage.com.au/goodfood/melbourne-eating-out/icon-review-63-years-and-counting-amiconi-is-one-of-melbourne-s-oldest-italian-restaurants-20230626-p5djmu.html