The biggest myth about the trending ‘Cortisol Cocktail’
Think of a problem, any problem, you’d like to eliminate. Chances are, someone on social media has a “quick fix”, a solution that will become clear if you watch their lengthy, ad-filled videos, and succeed if you use their discount codes (which are supplied in the caption for your convenience, of course).
Lowering your cortisol levels, according to content creators, is the most recent magic bullet for everything from hair loss to back pain, though overwhelmingly it appears to be a Trojan horse for the comeback of noughties bikini body culture. The latest weapon in “wellness” TikTok’s fight against stubborn belly fat and “cortisol face”? The “Cortisol Cocktail”.
Content creators have been touting quick ways to lower cortisol levels, with the latest being the “Cortisol Cocktail”. Experts say the premise of the problem, and the solutions, are misleading.Credit: TikTok/@natural.dr.stephanie/@madiditler/@itsbrookeelle
What is the ‘Cortisol Cocktail’ and does it work?
Recipes vary, but content creators purport a mixture of coconut water (for electrolytes), sea salt (for sodium), fruit juice (usually orange juice for vitamin C), and some sort of extra (be it magnesium powder, or sparkling water for potassium), can help regulate your cortisol levels, supposedly by replenishing nutrients lost when stress causes “adrenal fatigue”.
It sounds sweet from the surface, but the deeper you dig, the more sour it becomes.
Putting aside the fact that there is no scientific evidence to support the existence of adrenal fatigue (the separate rare condition called adrenal insufficiency is typically caused by an autoimmune disorder and needs to be diagnosed by a doctor), solutions claiming to lower cortisol levels, including the “Cortisol Cocktail”, are flawed from the get-go.
The very premise they lie on is a myth: Cortisol isn’t the culprit, it’s merely the conveyor belt. High cortisol levels at night, for example, can make it harder for you to fall asleep. But the unusual increase would be in response to a stressor, say, dinner an hour or two earlier with your difficult in-laws. Deal with the stressor, not the natural response to the stressor.
“Changing your cortisol [levels] artificially doesn’t work, and [it’s] not the reason for the weight gain or the cause of the stress,” says University of Melbourne Professor of Endocrinology Ada Cheung, who is also an endocrinologist. “The external cause of the stress is what we should be targeting, not the cortisol levels.”
What is cortisol, and should I be worried about it?
“In general, people don’t need to worry about their cortisol levels at all,” Cheung says.
“We don’t need to worry about regulating cortisol ... It’s regulated by the adrenal glands. And they do an excellent job for the large majority of people.”
Fight, flight, freeze, fawn. Those instinctual responses to perceived threats or stress are triggered by the release of hormones including cortisol and adrenaline, and that’s why cortisol in particular is also known as the stress hormone.
The stress hormone, however, is in desperate need of a rebrand.
Stress is part of everyday life, and when it’s triggered – if you’re running late and need to run for the train, for example – cortisol is produced by the adrenal glands. That, in turn, increases the amount of glucose in the bloodstream, which is what the body can use for quick energy.
“If we didn’t have cortisol, we wouldn’t be alive. It’s essential to life,” says Associate Professor Theresa Larkin of the University of Wollongong’s Graduate School of Medicine.
Cortisol is crucial to regulating the body’s metabolism, circadian rhythm (body clock), immune function, blood pressure, and heart rate, among other functions. Simply put, Larkin, who holds a PhD in biomedical science, says it’s our “inbuilt alarm clock”, which more or less “tells other organs whether now is the right time for them to be functioning.”
Part of what makes testing cortisol levels not straightforward is the fact that they naturally fluctuate throughout the day – they’re at their highest in the morning and lowest in the evening, helping you stay alert once you wake up and let you fall asleep when you need to rest.
“[Cortisol is] there for it to increase our alertness and our response for the short term ... up to a couple of hours ideally, and then it drops back off again,” says Larkin.
Can I lower my cortisol levels?
Trying to reduce your cortisol levels to lose weight, for example, or get rid of your puffy “cortisol face” (there is “no credible evidence” supporting its existence, Cheung says), would be akin to taking the batteries out of your smoke alarm instead of blowing out your candles before bed; the fire hazard is still there, but you’re left without the crucial warning to wake you up in time for evacuation.
“Don’t rely on Instagram or TikTok. Get medical advice from your doctor.”
Professor Ada Cheung
Heightened levels of cortisol are usually the symptom of the problem, rather than the problem itself. Even Cushing’s syndrome, which affects about 55 in every million people and occurs when your body makes too much cortisol over a long period of time, is typically the result of a pituitary tumour or steroid medications (as was the case for Amy Schumer).
Cortisol dysregulation – where cortisol levels are consistently abnormal – is generally overrepresented on social media “compared to the actual prevalence in the population,” says geneticist and biostatistician Divya Mehta, who is a professor at Queensland University of Technology’s School of Biomedical Sciences.
“It’s very, very rare, but it does happen,” Mehta says. “So this needs to be then diagnosed by the doctor rather than each person trying to self-diagnose.”
Right, but would drinking the ‘Cortisol Cocktail’ be bad for me?
Larkin says the “Cortisol Cocktail” is “not something that’s going to be a quick fix for cortisol dysregulation”.
“We are so much better off getting all of those vitamins and minerals from whole foods because [this] ‘Cortisol Cocktail’ has quite a high amount of sugar ... that’s not good in terms of cortisol,” Larkin says.
One of cortisol’s main functions, Larkin emphasises, is the regulation of glucose, so “adding in all of this glucose here, it can actually cause a dysregulation of cortisol or add to the problem of any dysregulated cortisol”.
Mehta notes how each individual component should, in theory, be beneficial – low magnesium and heightened stress levels have a bidirectional relationship, vitamin C is good for immune function, and sodium may improve “cardiovascular stress responses” – but if putting these ingredients together works in practice, well, “we don’t really know if that’s the case”.
Cheung’s view is less charitable, noting how “people are often preying on vulnerable people who are looking for a quick fix, and they’re selling them supplements and cocktails that don’t work.”
The “Cortisol Cocktail” could work, Larkin says, when “someone’s sitting with someone else and sipping on this ‘Cortisol Cocktail’ and debriefing and having a chat and enjoying the sun and de-stressing”.
A “Cortisol Cocktail”, however, is not necessary to the act of a relaxing socialisation session with friends, which Larkin says is actually what is “definitely positive for our overall cortisol levels and for our overall mental and physical health and well-being”. And that leads us back to our wider issue.
How to best manage your cortisol levels
“Cortisol is a really tightly regulated hormone,” Cheung says. “I think what people are trying to say is lower your stress levels ... cortisol doesn’t equal stress.”
Eating well and sleeping well can lower our stress levels, Cheung says, and it may contribute to weight loss, which is often lauded by content creators as a benefit to lowering cortisol levels. “But targeting the cortisol level itself is the wrong concept,” she says.
There is no quick fix for stress management. Starting small and building habits, be it carving out time for a quiet cup of tea away from the work laptop or going for an afternoon walk, is more likely to make a difference in the long term.
Larkin says one of the best things to do is help your circadian rhythm, and your cortisol levels, by getting morning sun and reducing light exposure as evening turns to night, including ditching your phone when you go to bed.
“We should be moving and exercising while it’s light, eating while it’s light … aligning to the day-night cycle is the number one best thing,” Larkin says. Exercise, Larkin and Mehta agree, is also beneficial in reducing overall stress.
Cheung, meanwhile, says if sleep, exercise, good nutrition, mindfulness, meditation and social support don’t work, it’s time to look for external stressors, like demanding jobs or challenging family dynamics.
“And if that’s not working, then seek some professional help,” she says. “Don’t rely on Instagram or TikTok. Get medical advice from your doctor.”
For the story behind the headlines, listen to The Morning Edition, with a new episode live every weekday from 5am. You can find The Morning Edition on Apple, Spotify, and everywhere you listen to your podcasts.