NewsBite

Advertisement

Opinion

Have a poor diet? It’s not you, it’s them

Sarah Berry
Lifestyle Health Editor

Cheetos and Doritos have been “reinvented”, according to parent company PepsiCo. In the United States, versions of the ultra-processed snacks called Simply NKD will soon be available without artificial colours.

Though all two dozen other ingredients remain in the snacks, artificial colours have become a hot-button topic in the US, thanks to RFK jnr’s MAHA (Make America Healthy Again) crew.

Ultra-processed foods are easy to eat and hard to avoid.Janie Barrett

The move, one must suppose, along with the white “purity” packaging, allows consumers to enjoy their artificial-colour-free chips guilt-free.

Of course, it’s just razzle-dazzle tokenism. Today it’s artificial colours, yesterday it was sugar, and the day before that it was fat.

Advertisement

Between 2000 and 2019, new ultra-processed food (UPF) products, with various functional, fortification and reformulation claims, grew from 2000 to about 40,000.

Along with the ultra-processing come ultra-profits.

“It is more profitable to produce a Dorito corn chip than a can of corn or the corn itself,” says Dr Phillip Baker, from the University of Sydney’s School of Public Health.

The ultra-processed food corporations continue to rake it in (global UPF market sales grew to US$1.9 trillion or $2.94 trillion in 2022), while paying lip service to consumer concerns about their foods.

Advertisement

But it’s our fault, right? We keep buying these edible substances despite health nags telling us they are making us overweight and sick.

Half of our energy intake in Australia comes from UPFs, mostly in the form of ready meals, packaged bread, cereals and soft drinks. Less than five per cent of us eat enough fruit and vegetables.

If only we exercised a little more willpower and made better choices in our lives, two-thirds of our country wouldn’t be obese or overweight. And we wouldn’t be weighing down the hospital system with cases of type 2 diabetes, hypertension, cardiovascular disease, chronic kidney disease, Crohn’s disease and depression.

Except we’re a convenient scapegoat.

If consumers are the problem then corporations can go on their merry way, creating products that are, from an evolutionary perspective, entirely foreign to our bodies and causing them harm.

Advertisement

Deflecting blame is just one strategy food companies use.

Today, three of the biggest food corporations (Coca-Cola, PepsiCo and Mondelez) spend $13.5 billion on advertising every year, four times the entire operating budget of the World Health Organisation.

And a surprising amount of thought and effort goes into designing foods that keep our confused bodies craving more as they seek nourishment from non-existent nutrients.

All the flavour profiles that our bodies instinctively associate with various nutrients are there. Only it’s a sensory illusion.

That UPFs are also often soft, are hyper-palatable, and never satiate us makes overeating easy, adds Deakin University’s Dr Priscila Machado.

Advertisement

“We designed food to be irresistible. Now we’re taking medicine to resist it,” futurist and author Mike Lee writes.

As the industry has grown, and our waists have grown alongside it, industry leaders envision capturing more than just market share. They want to capture our diets, our stomach, and mouth share too.

To illustrate this idea, the authors of the new three-part Lancet series on Ultra-Processed Foods and Human Health, give this example:

“In 1986, Roberto Goizueta, then president and chief executive officer of Coca-Cola, outlined his vision to investors:

Advertisement

“‘Right now in the [USA], people consume more soft drinks than any other liquid, including ordinary tap water. If we take full advantage of our opportunities … we will see the same wave catching on in market after market until, eventually, the number one beverage on earth will be ... soft drinks – our soft drinks.’”

The Lancet series highlights that interest groups funded by leading corporations also work relentlessly to block regulation and create conditions that allow them to expand.

In 2024, of the 326 lobbyists employed by the US food and beverage industry, 211 were former government employees; Australia’s Health Star Ratings system, developed in partnership with industry, gives many UPFs high ratings, suggesting that it has been co-opted as a marketing tool; while systematic reviews on soft drinks and obesity risk were five times more likely to show no association with obesity if industry-sponsored.

All this is to say, the problem is not you or us. It’s them.

“For a long time the problem has been framed as a matter of individual responsibility,” said Phillip Baker, an author in the Lancet series.

Advertisement

“We offer an alternative interpretation of the problem, describing the root causes as the rising power of the UPF industry to shape food systems in ways that generate ultra-processed diets.”

We can, of course, try our best to avoid UPFs in their shiny plastic packaging and with ingredients we wouldn’t use at home. But it misses the point that it is the food industry that has become bloated – obese, even – with greed.

The 43 global experts, including Australians, have ideas about how to fix the food environment we find ourselves in. They include marketing restrictions; sugar and UPF taxes; restricting the available foods in retail spaces; and improving school food policies.

In Brazil, for example, the limit of processed and ultra-processed foods on public school menus is 15 per cent. All other food has to come from small-to-medium enterprises.

Any change also involves recognising that most households struggle with time and resources to make healthy meals and that women, many of whom are working, tend to bear the burden of the care work in the home, including meal preparation.

Advertisement

Something has to be reformulated, though. And it is not the Doritos.

Make the most of your health, relationships, fitness and nutrition with our Live Well newsletter. Get it in your inbox every Monday.

Sarah BerrySarah Berry is a lifestyle and health writer at The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age.Connect via Twitter or email.

Most Viewed in Lifestyle

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Original URL: https://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/lifestyle/health-and-wellness/have-a-poor-diet-it-s-not-you-it-s-them-20251121-p5nhda.html