NewsBite

Nick Tabakoff

‘F... you’: Shorten’s foul-mouthed spray to PM staffer

Nick Tabakoff
Bill Shorten and Yaron Finkelstein were seen during a tense exchange at Flemington on Melbourne Cup day. Picture: Stuart McEvoy/Aaron Francis
Bill Shorten and Yaron Finkelstein were seen during a tense exchange at Flemington on Melbourne Cup day. Picture: Stuart McEvoy/Aaron Francis

It was a big week for Bill Shorten. On Thursday, he was forced to deal with the post-election fallout of the devastating Labor review that found his own unpopularity had been a significant factor in the election loss.

But two days earlier, right in front of Media Diary’s eyes, the tension of that looming Labor verdict seemed to be already showing.

READ MORE: Fran Kelly’s Q&A mea culpa | Gone Today, Georgie seeks new tomorrow | Chris Mitchell writes there’s no pleasing lazy left journos | Chalmers draws line under class-war pitch | Graham Richardson writes how the ALP must balance its blue-collar support with inner-city activists

All it took for Shorten to flush it out was the appearance of Scott Morrison’s political right-hand man in the media-heavy Tabcorp marquee in the VRC’s Birdcage on Melbourne Cup day.

Bill Shorten and his wife Chloe in the TAB Corp marquee at Flemington on Melbourne Cup day last week.
Bill Shorten and his wife Chloe in the TAB Corp marquee at Flemington on Melbourne Cup day last week.

Diary was having a quiet drink with Yaron Finkelstein, ScoMo’s principal private secretary and one of the key architects of his May election win, when who but Shorten materialised to join the conversation.

For Diary, in the box seat, it was then simply a case of grabbing the popcorn and watching the fireworks fly.

Finkelstein gave as good as he got with Shorten, in an extremely direct exchange that suggests the six months since the federal election have done little to dull the stinging disappointment for the ex-Labor leader of his election loss.

It went as follows:

Shorten: “You work for ScoMo? Yaron, isn’t it.”

Finkelstein: “Yeah.”

Shorten: “Yeah, f..k you. Just remember: the wheel always turns.”

Finkelstein: “Then let’s hope it’s a big wheel!”

Bill Shorten and Chloe in the TAB marquee in 2018.
Bill Shorten and Chloe in the TAB marquee in 2018.
Bill Shorten arrives with Chloe at Flemington in 2017.
Bill Shorten arrives with Chloe at Flemington in 2017.

It’s not the first time Shorten has used robust language on perceived enemies. Niki Savva’s book Plots and Prayers recalls that Shorten variously described ex-Ten reporter Jonathan Leaas a “c..t” and a “dickhead”.

Savva’s book reveals that Shorten at one point had asked a Ten executive, in relation to Lea, who was working at Ten at the time, “when he was going to get rid of that dickhead”.

Savva also recounts that after Shorten was told Lea had been assigned to cover him for the election campaign, “Shorten unwisely whispered in the ear of another journalist that Lea was a ‘c..t’.”

Lea, of course, was responsible for one of the campaign’s key “gotcha” moments, when Shorten was unable to answer his repeated questions about how much Labor’s climate change policies would cost.

Thankfully, a Cup day peacemaker was in the wings in the form of Shorten’s wife Chloe, who told Finkelstein, apologetically, with a big smile: “He can be very direct sometimes.”

Bill Shorten and Chloe in the birdcage in 2016.
Bill Shorten and Chloe in the birdcage in 2016.
Bill Shorten with Chloe enjoys a drink at the 2010 Melbourne Cup.
Bill Shorten with Chloe enjoys a drink at the 2010 Melbourne Cup.

Chloe’s intervention seemed to be an ice breaker, at least temporarily, between Shorten and Finkelstein, with the adversaries burying their differences to share tips on the Cup.

Both even claimed a betting win when Aussie horse Vow and Declare passed the winning post first.

Prime Minister Scott Morrison with Yaron Finkelstein on the night of the election going through the numbers. Picture: Adam Taylor
Prime Minister Scott Morrison with Yaron Finkelstein on the night of the election going through the numbers. Picture: Adam Taylor
Read related topics:Bill Shorten
Nick Tabakoff
Nick TabakoffAssociate Editor

Nick Tabakoff is an Associate Editor of The Australian. Tabakoff, a two-time Walkley Award winner, has served in a host of high-level journalism roles across three decades, ­including Editor-at-Large and Associate Editor of The Daily Telegraph and Sunday Telegraph, a previous stint at The Australian as Media Editor, as well as high-profile roles at the South China Morning Post, the Australian Financial Review, BRW and the Bulletin magazine.He has also worked in senior producing roles at the Nine Network and in radio.

Add your comment to this story

To join the conversation, please Don't have an account? Register

Join the conversation, you are commenting as Logout

Original URL: https://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/media/why-did-bill-shorten-lose-his-cool-at-the-melbourne-cup/news-story/1d0a91363fa077148677795d2d621764