NewsBite

Advertisement

Condiments put to the taste test from tomato sauce to mayo

Callan Boys
Callan Boys

Which condiments will take your sausage sizzle to the next level?
Which condiments will take your sausage sizzle to the next level?James Brickwood

Make your next sausage sizzle soar with our guide to backyard barbie condiments.

Tip: Mayonnaise will turn the outside of a toasted sandwich crisp and golden if butter isn't at hand.

Tomato and barbecue sauce composite for Good Food condiment taste test. March 2019.
Tomato and barbecue sauce composite for Good Food condiment taste test. March 2019.Supplied

Tomato sauce

Advertisement

Heinz Organic Tomato Ketchup, 500ml, $4.30

Score: 1.5/5

Good on Heinz for its organic certification, but the multinational needs to tone down the acidity in this ketchup. A lot. Only suitable for making bad meat pies marginally better.

MasterFoods Aussie Farmers Tomato Sauce, 500ml, $3.15

Score: 2.5/5

Advertisement

Aussie farmers get a fair shake of the sauce bottle with this snag-enhancer made from 97 per cent local ingredients. (Its standard sits at 30 per cent.) Not too salty, not too sweet , not too exciting.

Rosella Tomato Sauce,580ml, $2.65

Score: 4/5

Also made from at least 98 per cent Australian ingredients, this pantry classic bursts with big red flavour. Your go-to for a hot chip sanger slathered in butter.

Barbecue sauce

Advertisement

Bull's-Eye Original BBQ Sauce, 300ml, $3.99

Score: 1.5/5

Heavy with "smoke flavouring", maltodextrin and molasses, this is the one-dimensional taste of a steakhouse chain where staff line dance to Achy Breaky Heart.

ETA Original Barbecue Sauce, 375ml, $2.75

Score: 0.5/5

Advertisement

You don't need to read the bottle to know the main ingredient of ETA's iconic sauce is sugar. This should be stocked in the same aisle as jelly babies and Chomps.

Stubb's Original Legendary Bar-B-Q Sauce, 510ml, $5.99

Score: 3.5/5

Stubb was a real-life Texan pitmaster who died in 1995, and although the supermarket version of his tomato-forward sauce could be thicker, I dig its friendly punch of black pepper.

Mustard and mayonnaise  composite for Good Food condiment taste test. March 2019.
Mustard and mayonnaise composite for Good Food condiment taste test. March 2019.Supplied
Advertisement

Mayonnaise

Hellmann's Real Mayonnaise, 400g, $6.20

Score: 3.5/5

By appointment to Her Majesty The Queen, oh la la. This creamy rapeseed oil-based mayo is potato salad-worthy but needs a dash more vinegar to make it sing.

Praise Traditional Creamy Mayonnaise, 365g, $3.40

Advertisement

Score: 1/5

A sugary Aussie stalwart since 1964, there's no shortage of three-digit numbers and vegetable gums in this mayo. This tastes like it was made ina lab and we deserve better.

S&W Whole Egg Mayonnaise, 440g, $6

Score: 2/5

There's a gentle pine aroma to this, which may be to do with the added rosemary extract. It also has a cloying finish, which is almost definitely related to the presence of corn syrup.

Advertisement

Dijon mustard

Chef's Choice Premium French Dijon Mustard, 200g, $3.29

Score: 0.5/5

Smells like a butcher's armpit; tastes like mustard seeds steeped in soap. A product of France, sure, but so is the guillotine, Kronenbourg and performance art. Avoid.

Maille Dijon Originale, 215g, $4

Advertisement

Score: 4/5

Robust, versatile, balanced and bright, Maille is the home kitchen's most valuable player when it comes to sharpening a stew and supercharging roast chook. So very, very good for the price.

Coles Dijon Mustard, 200g, $2

Score: 2.5/5

With added sugar and a third fewer mustard seeds than the others, this tastes spookily close to the yellow stuff McDonald's squirts on cheeseburgers. Certainly, there are way more offensive things in life.

Callan BoysCallan Boys is editor of SMH Good Food Guide, restaurant critic for Good Weekend and Good Food writer.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Original URL: https://www.watoday.com.au/goodfood/condiments-put-to-the-taste-test-from-tomato-sauce-to-mayo-20200225-h1m20m.html