UPDATED: STATE Government MP Nic Street has defended the controversial Bruny Island Neck makeover, declaring the work has remedied a “death trap”.
The area’s new bitumen road and 24-space carpark have sparked concern over the impact on tourism and traffic management.
Mr Street, whose electorate of Franklin takes in Bruny, says the recently completed work was the product of extensive consultation.
“The facts are the current situation was a death trap in waiting and we weren’t going to sit around waiting for a serious accident to happen before taking action,” he said.
“The question is, did those who now want to criticise raise their concerns back then? If not, why not?”
Mr Street hit out at green group criticism of the changes, saying the site’s penguin colony had been a major consideration.
“It’s yet another example of Green and conservation groups shifting the goal posts and having a crack at the Government purely to suit their constant negative political agenda,” he said.
“I accept that not everyone will be happy with the changes, but on any fair-minded assessment they are both balanced and necessary.”
EARLIER: A MAKEOVER of the popular Bruny Island Neck has sparked concern a world-renowned Tasmanian view has been lost and traffic will be unmanageable.
The long-awaited new lookout will open on Friday following completion of a new 24-space carpark and the sealing of the Neck road.
The Department of State Growth has collaborated with the Parks and Wildlife Service to deliver the new infrastructure in time for another expected summer boom.
Government MP Nic Street said: “With its stunning views, the Neck is one of the most popular locations on Bruny Island and the ongoing upgrades will ensure the island keeps up with tourism demand while increasing road safety for locals, tourists and wildlife.”
Work began in July and includes fencing and tunnels under the new road to protect little penguins from traffic.
MORE: $500,000 PLAN TO UPGRADE BRUNY ISLAND LOOKOUT
MORE: RESIDENTS, TOURISM OPERATORS ANGRY AT UPGRADE WORK
Locals are welcoming the sealed road connecting North and South Bruny, but environmentalists say the sweeping ocean views have been trashed.
“The view looking east is fine,” the Tasmanian Conservation Trust’s Peter McGlone said.
“The view looking west is pretty atrocious.”
Mr McGlone said a shuttle bus service should have been considered.
“Similar to Cradle Mountain, it sounds like a really sensible idea where you don’t have the hustle and bustle of trying to park your car and you don’t destroy the experience for everyone as well,” he said.
Work on the site began in July, while a new boardwalk and viewing platforms will be completed next year.
Bruny Island Network convener Bob Graham, an environmental planner of 40 years, said the carpark should have been relocated further to the north of its current site.
“The new carpark has resulted in a significant visual intrusion into the iconic views from the Truganini Lookout,” Mr Graham said.
“The intrusion has been made worse by the fact that the carpark is located further to the south, there is a greater colour contrast with the surroundings and vegetation around the new facility has not grown back.”
MORE: BIRDLIFE TASMANIA WARNS OF PENGUIN COLONY DAMAGE
Bruny Island Community Association’s Fran Davis said locals were glad to see the old dirt road gone, but admitted the view from the lookout could be different.
“The dirt road was in keeping with the wild look of that area of Bruny but the road was essential,” Ms Davis said.
“Because there’s going to be more cars, it’s obviously going to be more visible.”
Ms Davis said the 60km/h speed limit alongside the carpark should be reduced to 40km/h to ensure visitors and large tourist vehicles were safe.
“I don’t believe the carpark is big enough for last year’s tourism season, let alone this year,” she said.
Award-winning Bruny Island tourism operator Rob Pennicott also welcomed the new work.
“Something had to be done drastically,” he said.
“It was unsafe, it was substandard.
“It’s a great improvement on previous years and the main thing is they’re looking after the penguins.”
But Mr Pennicott also warned about traffic management issues during the summer peak.
“For most of summer the carpark is going to be really full and it’s going to be spilling out way past the carpark,” he said.
“There’s going to have to be some way of monitoring that.”
Tourism Industry Council chief Luke Martin said safety and wildlife protection had to take priority over other considerations.
“It’s a spectacular part of the state, people can still enjoy it,” he said.
“I’m sure it’s not going to be too detrimental.”
Protecting birdlife was a major priority during the redevelopment, with construction taking place outside the penguin and shearwater breeding seasons, and burrows regularly inspected.
BirdLife Tasmania convener Eric Woehler said he was satisfied with the measures taken.
Add your comment to this story
To join the conversation, please log in. Don't have an account? Register
Join the conversation, you are commenting as Logout
First look at new fine diner reveals delight in every bite
Meals at this new Marion Bay eatery are a combo of Tasmanian produce, French culinary techniques and Scottish heritage. And yes it’s fancy, but with a relaxed vibe, writes Alix Davis
JJs star reveals six of his favourite Tassie shacks
With many of Tassie’s best shacks available for rent, you don’t need to own one to enjoy a bush or beach getaway. Retiring JackJumpers skipper Clint Steindl shares his favourite escapes.