For stocks and bonds, 2024 is in some ways shaping up like 2023.
As was the case in 2023, bond yields have risen sharply since the start of the year and are starting to affect stock markets in developed markets after they hit record highs in recent weeks.
Of course stocks outperformed during periods of rising interest rates in the past few decades. Interest rates rose as economic growth and corporate earnings accelerated and sustained downward pressure on inflation allowed central banks to cut interest rates to lower and lower levels each economic cycle and use unconventional monetary policy stimulus like quantitative easing.
The US 10-year bond yield fell from 16 per cent in 1981 to 31 basis points in 2020 as inflation was restrained by the globalisation of goods and labour markets combined with plentiful supplies of resources like crude oil. But deglobalisation, decarbonisation and geopolitical risks may make it harder to get inflation under control and limit the potential for interest rate cuts from here.
As US economic activity and inflation data exceeded expectations and rate cuts were expected to be delayed this year, the 2-year Treasury yield hit 5 per cent for the first time in five months this week.
The benchmark 10-year yield soared to 4.69 per cent from 3.88 per cent at the start of the year.
Similar moves up in US bond yields in the first few months of 2023 contributed to the US regional banking crisis. At that time there were expectations of several interest rate cuts in 2023.
Much as has been the case in 2024, those expectations of interest rate cuts in 2023 faded rapidly as the US Federal Open Market Committee continued to hike rates through July, and its members turned less dovish on the outlook for rates in their September “dot plot” of interest rate projections.
But as the 10-year bond yield soared from 3.25 per cent after the regional banking crisis to almost 5 per cent in early October, FOMC officials including chair Jerome Powell began to indicate that rising bond yields and tightening financial conditions could lessen the need for further rate hikes.
“Financial conditions have tightened significantly in recent months, and longer-term bond yields have been an important driving factor in this tightening,” Powell said at the time.
“We remain attentive to these developments because persistent changes in financial conditions can have implications for the path of monetary policy.”
By December, Powell said the timing of interest rate cuts was discussed by the committee.
Not only did the Fed decide against a December rate hike that its members had projected, officials also slashed their interest rate projections for 2024 and 2025. But cuts this year are now in doubt.
After three months of higher than expected inflation, Powell appeared to abandon his prediction last month that the Fed was “not far" from getting the confidence in falling inflation needed to cut interest rates.
“The recent data have clearly not given us greater confidence and instead indicate that it is likely to take longer than expected to achieve that confidence,” Powell said Tuesday at a panel discussion alongside Bank of Canada Governor Tiff Macklem at the Wilson Centre in Washington.
“Given the strength of the labour market and progress on inflation so far, it is appropriate to allow restrictive policy further time to work and let the data and the evolving outlook guide us.”
It didn’t cause much of an additional selloff in stocks and bonds because investors have already dialled back their rate cut hopes after strong inflation and economic data in recent months.
Moreover the stockmarket remains focussed on the economic outlook and the consensus estimate of an acceleration in annual earnings per share growth to 15 per cent per annum by year end.
But investor surveys and positioning measures suggest they are already positioned for that. And unlike October 2023 when he was worried about rising long-term bond yields causing tight financial conditions, Powell’s comments this week could indicate that he needs tighter financial conditions.
A US 10-year bond yield near 5 per cent could challenge the US sharemarket’s valuation given that it would erase the already skinny earnings yield of the S&P 500.
“The risk is that as the 2-year US Treasury yield consolidates at around 5 per cent, the ‘high for long’ narrative of last August-October, which at the time had triggered fears of eventual hard landing and had hit risk assets, is repeated going forward,” said London-based Nikolaos Panigirtzoglou, head of global derivatives strategy at JP Morgan.
Investors started April with “even more elevated” exposures to risk assets compared to last August.
He says the current market narrative and patterns are increasingly resembling those of the Northern Hemisphere summer of 2023, when soaring bond yields sparked a 10 per cent fall in the S&P 500, prompting the Fed to ride to the rescue with its “dovish pivot” away from rate hikes.
“As inflation surprises to the upside and Fed or other central bank rate cuts are priced out by rate markets, investors are starting to look at reducing overweights or adding hedges in risk markets such as equities and credit,” Mr Panigirtzoglou said.
“Last summer, the increase in 2-year US Treasury yields from a low of 3.8 per cent at the beginning of May to 4.9 per cent by the beginning of August was largely ignored by equity and credit markets.
“However, once 2-year US Treasury yields started consolidating at such high levels of 5 per cent or above, equity and credit markets started suffering from the beginning of August onwards.
“Between the beginning of August and the end of October, equity markets saw a correction of around 10 per cent.”