NewsBite

WSJ Editorial Board

Stop playing defence: we need to adjust to the Putin-Pyongyang axis

WSJ Editorial Board
Putin, Kim bond over dogs, horses and driving

For the benefit of the liberal internationalists in the White House who still live in the 1990s, take a look at Vladimir Putin’s visit to North Korea this week. This is another illustration of the axis of authoritarians working together around the world against America and its allies.

Not very long ago North Korea was isolated, subject to United Nations sanctions and a global effort to enforce them. Donald Trump thought he could cajole the North into giving up his nuclear weapons in return for investment and commercial ties. Our sources say he has mused about trying again in a second term.

But today that’s even more of a fantasy. The U.N. sanctions are still in place but are evaded with ease with the help of Russia and China. Mr Putin’s visit symbolises this shift that has been going on for some time and has accelerated with the Ukraine war.

Mr Putin and North Korean dictator Kim Jong-un signed a new agreement this week to come to each other’s aid if one faces “aggression.” Both define aggression to include a war they start, like Russia’s in Ukraine.

The welcoming ceremony at Kim Il Sung Square in Pyongyang for Vladimir Putin. Picture: AFP.
The welcoming ceremony at Kim Il Sung Square in Pyongyang for Vladimir Putin. Picture: AFP.

The details of their co-operation aren’t public. But the U.S. has accused North Korea of “unlawfully” sending ballistic missiles and 11,000 containers of munitions for Russia to use against Ukraine. In return, Russia is propping up the North with money and other aid, as well as technology for advanced weaponry. Especially dangerous is Russian help for the North’s long-range-missile and satellite-launch programs. These could put U.S. space assets and the homeland at risk.

The “international community,” to use a favourite Barack Obama phrase, is as effective at stopping this as the League of Nations. The U.S. response is to issue statements of denunciation that include words like “unlawfully,” as if either the North or Russia care. Russia used its veto at the Security Council in March to disband a U.N. panel that monitored North Korea’s compliance with sanctions. The realistic conclusion is that Russia and China want North Korea as a nuclear-armed state to threaten South Korea, Japan and the U.S.

Donald Trump thought he could cajole the North into giving up his nuclear weapons. Picture: AFP.
Donald Trump thought he could cajole the North into giving up his nuclear weapons. Picture: AFP.

The dictators don’t agree on everything, and a skilful U.S. diplomacy would look for opportunities to exploit differences. But the first necessity is to shed illusions that this axis is going away. Beijing, Moscow, Tehran, Pyongyang, Havana, Caracas and others share a common interest in creating mayhem that stretches U.S. and Western defences.

Another illusion to drop is that these nations will give up their malign ambitions if the U.S. accommodates them and retreats to the Americas. This is the fantasy of some in the Trump wing of the GOP. The emergence of this hostile axis is a direct response to the perception of U.S. weakness and retreat. More weakness will court more aggression.

Vladimir Putin speaks during his welcoming reception in Pyongyang. Picture: KCNA/AFP.
Vladimir Putin speaks during his welcoming reception in Pyongyang. Picture: KCNA/AFP.
Kim Jong-un and Vladimir Putin after watching the welcome performance at the Pyongyang Gymnasium in Pyongyang. Picture; KCNA/AFP.
Kim Jong-un and Vladimir Putin after watching the welcome performance at the Pyongyang Gymnasium in Pyongyang. Picture; KCNA/AFP.

The U.S. and its allies will have to rearm, and far more urgently than President Biden and Mr. Trump seem willing to do. The West will also have to stop thinking that global institutions like the U.N. are serving U.S. interests. The U.N. is now useful mainly to Russia and China as veto blockades against the U.S., and to Iran and Hamas as a forum for hostility to Israel.

The International Criminal Court and the International Court of Justice are now as intent on prosecuting leaders of free countries as they are marauding dictators. The G-20 forum, meanwhile, is increasingly being used by left-wing governments to weaken U.S. economic interests.

Kim Jong-un (4th R) and Vladimir Putin (4th L) attending a meeting at the Kumsusan State Guesthouse in Pyongyang. Picture: KCNA/AFP.
Kim Jong-un (4th R) and Vladimir Putin (4th L) attending a meeting at the Kumsusan State Guesthouse in Pyongyang. Picture: KCNA/AFP.

The “collective security” of the West will have to come from alliances like NATO, the AUKUS accord and the Quad in the Indo-Pacific. The US will have to use its economic clout, open trade, and soft power to court the global South against the money and debt traps offered by China in particular.

Perhaps most important, the U.S. will have to stop solely playing defence and start looking to exploit vulnerabilities within the new axis. This means supporting sources of opposition within these countries, and pushing against their weakest links. This is what the Reagan Doctrine did against the Soviet Union in Afghanistan and Eastern Europe.

The Biden Administration has behaved as if the world still wants to play by post-Cold War rules. The result is growing disorder and the menacing ambitions of anti-American states. If Mr. Trump has a better response than saying there were no wars when he was President, the American people would love to hear it.

The Wall St Journal

Read related topics:China TiesVladimir Putin

Add your comment to this story

To join the conversation, please Don't have an account? Register

Join the conversation, you are commenting as Logout

Original URL: https://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/the-wall-street-journal/stop-playing-defence-we-need-to-adjust-to-the-putinpyongyang-axis/news-story/51304d8ced2553057de945ecdbf29535