Chris Mayne argues after controversial head knock as Pies lose

Collingwood’s Chris Mayne looked like he was out for the count after a brutal head knock, but what happened next is sure to spark debate.

Chris Mayne's situation sparked debate.

A murky moment during Brisbane’s incredible one-point win over Collingwood on Thursday night put the AFL’s concussion protocols in the spotlight as Pies star Chris Mayne was at odds with his club’s medical staff.

The Lions kicked a goal after the siren to win their first match of the year in a game that wasn’t without controversy.

Watch the 2021 Toyota AFL Premiership Season. Every match of every round Live on Kayo. New to Kayo? Try 14-Days Free Now >

Mayne was collected in the head by Charlie Cameron’s swinging arm when he went low to the ground in the third quarter and had no desire to head off the ground.

He lay on the turf for long enough to create genuine concern about his condition, and even Cameron knelt down to see if his opponent was OK.

Cameron showed concern for Mayne after the accidental hit.

The trainers’ message wasn’t getting through.

The Pies medicos rushed out and tried to get him off the field so they could conduct a head injury assessment. However, Mayne got back on his feet and wanted to keep playing, demanding to take the ensuing free kick.

He argued with the Collingwood medical staff and yelled at the umpire to give him the Sherrin, as the official held possession and looked to the trainer for guidance about whether Mayne was OK to carry on.

The 32-year-old stayed on the ground for another couple of minutes before eventually being escorted to the sideline. He appeared to have a heated exchange with Collingwood doctors before the club confirmed he had been taken to the rooms to be assessed.

Geelong icon Cameron Ling said in commentary for the ABC Mayne should not have been allowed to stay on when the doctor tried to pull him off.

“The doctor has to take over there,” Ling said. “That is one argument that should never ever be won by the player.”

Channel 7 commentator Brian Taylor added: “That is amazing, because he spent another couple of minutes on the ground after he was asked to come off.”

Chris Mayne had a heated exchange with club doctors arguing against a head injury assessment. After more than 2 mins he lost the battle and headed to the rooms. As he should
@abcsportpic.twitter.com/xoL5wtfJO6

— Roger Oldridge (@roger_oldridge) April 1, 2021

Mayne was seen in the huddle at the end of the third quarter and ran back to the bench before the bounce, but had been given the all-clear to continue.

Just before the season started the AFL rushed through a rule change that would allow clubs to use an injury substitute if a player was ruled out of a match with concussion or any other impairment.

Beau McCreery was Collingwood’s 23rd man and was seen warming up during the break at three-quarter time in case he was required to replace Mayne, but he went back to cooling his jets after his teammate was cleared.

Originally published as Chris Mayne argues after controversial head knock as Pies lose