Monash University Accident Research Centre study reveals ‘good and bad performers’

Your car may be putting you at a much higher risk of death or serious injury, according to new findings from the Monash University Accident Research Centre.

Motorists who own the least safe cars are eight times more likely to be killed or seriously injured in accidents than drivers in highly rated vehicles.

The startling finding comes as the annual Used Car Safety Ratings were released, identifying 55 five-star cars from 389 models.

From the five-star line-up, 13 were awarded “Safer Pick’’ status in the study by the Monash University Accident Research Centre.

Centre director Professor Stuart Newstead said the results revealed a large difference in safety performance between the best and worst-rated vehicles.

“The driver of the worst scoring vehicle is over eight times more likely to be killed or seriously injured than the driver in the best scoring vehicle,” Professor Newstead said.

“Whilst newer vehicles were generally safer than older vehicles, within each age group and class of vehicle rated there were good and bad performers.’’

A total of 59 vehicles, mostly older models, were rated just one star because of the lack of modern safety features such as anti-lock brakes, electronic stability control, airbags and autonomous emergency braking.

More Audi models scored the highest rating than any other manufacturer, with its late-model A3, A4, A5 and Q5 variants all considered “safer picks”.

The results revealed a large difference in safety performance between the best and worst-rated vehicles. Picture: iStock

The report also confirmed that in 2020, about two-thirds of road deaths occurred in vehicles aged 10 years or older.

Roads and Road Safety Minister Melissa Horne said this year’s ratings were a handy guide for people buying a used car.

“The risk of death or serious injury is significantly lower for people driving a car with modern safety features, and these ratings make it easier for people to find a safe car in their budget,” Ms Horne said.

The Transport Accident Commission’s latest Road Safety Monitor survey revealed Victorians were prioritising safety more than ever. About 70 per cent of respondents considered safety as the most important factor when buying a vehicle.

TAC chief executive Joe Calafiore said no one was immune to making mistakes while behind the wheel.

“Modern vehicle safety features like Auto Emergency Braking, Lane Keep Assist and Electronic Stability Control could save your life,” Mr Calafiore said.