Mick McGuane takes an in-depth look at the semi-final between Brisbane Lions and GWS Giants
Brisbane star Lachie Neale can’t be left alone and Brisbane should drop a key off-season recruit after a disappointing first final. Plus, who goes to Charlie Cameron? Mick McGuane looks at the key factors in the do-or-die semi-final.
Lions
Don't miss out on the headlines from Lions. Followed categories will be added to My News.
This shapes as a battle of the beasts.
The Lions and Giants rank first and second respectively for scoring from stoppages and there is little doubt this game will be won and lost through the midfield.
The pleasing thing for the Giants on the weekend was their turnover game — which has traditionally been a weakness — was exceptional against the Western Bulldogs. Meanwhile, the Lions’ showed their ability to win clearances and contested ball against Richmond, particularly early, and created ample scoring opportunities. They just need to convert them.
CLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE TO THE SACKED PODCAST
BRISBANE LIONS
THE KEY
Conversion. It sounds obvious, but they can’t be as wasteful as they were in front of goal against Richmond on Saturday night. Either through their own technique or the failure to use better options, they squandered far too many opportunities to hit the scoreboard. At quarter-time the Lions led the inside-50 count 23-6 but had just a 12-point lead after kicking 4.6. You can’t do that and expect to win finals.
THE CHALLENGE
The Lions have got to get their key forwards into the game against a very good intercept team in the Giants. Eric Hipwood, Daniel McStay and Oscar McInerney all pose threats in the air but have combined for only three goals from their past three games. Against Richmond on Saturday night, the trio combined for just 20 disposals and 10 marks. That’s not nearly enough.
THE THEME
It’s linked to the Lions’ challenge. Hipwood, McStay and McInerney need to lift. If they can’t mark it, they need to bring the ball to ground for the likes of Allen Christiensen, Cam Rayner and Charlie Cameron. If not, the Giants are the second-best intercept marking team in the competition and will rebound it out of there in no time.
IF I WAS BRISBANE …
If Mitch Robinson (hamstring) is ruled out it leaves a big hole on one wing. I’d be looking at Ryan Bastinac as my first-choice replacement, despite him not having played an AFL game since Round 3. If not Bastinac, maybe Tom Cutler, although he lacks some competitiveness at times. I’d also drop Marcus Adams for Ryan Lester, who did a good job in defence on Harry Himmelberg in Round 16. That just leaves Harris Andrews and Darcy Gardiner to look after Jeremy Cameron and Jeremy Finalyson.
MORE FOOTY:
McGuane: How Eagles can end Cats’ season
Mark Robinson: Richmond and Dustin Martin were frightening in win over Brisbane
A Richmond-Collingwood grand final shapes as a promoter’s dream and the hottest ticket in town
GWS GIANTS
THE KEY
Keep the forward pressure up. Everyone in the football industry has been asking where it is, and the Giants looked a different team with the forward pressure they applied against the Western Bulldogs. They had nine forward-50 tackles to five. That’s why they conceded only 37 inside-50s against a team that was going into this finals series on top of their game offensively. Maintain the rage.
THE CHALLENGE
Who can handle Charlie Cameron? He kicked two goals in Round 16, but he looked dangerous and lively. When he plays deep, Heath Shaw might take him. But would the Giants like that match-up? Because if the ball goes in quickly and goes to ground, Shaw will be beaten for pace. Zac Williams has the pace, but GWS would rather not have him deep in defence.
THE THEME
Avoid Harris Andrews. There was a bit of selflessness from Richmond’s Tom Lynch on Saturday night, taking Andrews — one of the league’s best spoilers — away from the contest when he could. If Andrews goes to Jeremy Finalyson, the Giant might have to do the same to help Jeremy Cameron get off the leash against Darcy Gardiner.
IF I WAS GWS ….
You’ve got to shut down Lachie Neale and Hugh McCluggage. I would be sending Matt de Boer to do the job on Neale to limit his impact around the stoppages and ability to win clean first possession. We know he’s going to win the footy, but you can limit the impact. Without Mitch Robinson on one wing, McCluggage on the other wing becomes an important factor for the Lions. I’d send Sam Reid to him after he successfully shut out Western Bulldogs wingman Lachie Hunter in the same role on the weekend.
MY PREDICTION: Brisbane by 7 points
MATCH ODDS
Brisbane $1.65, GWS $2.25
FLAG ODDS
Brisbane $11, GWS $13
INJURIES
LIONS
Mitch Robinson (hamstring) TBC
Tom Joyce (shin) test
GIANTS
Stephen Coniglio (knee) test
Zac Langdon (ankle) test
Brett Deledio (calf) retired
Matt Flynn (knee) season
Jonathon Patton (knee) season
Callan Ward (knee) season
Originally published as Mick McGuane takes an in-depth look at the semi-final between Brisbane Lions and GWS Giants