NewsBite

Advertisement

Opinion

It’s interest rates, not regulators, that will burst our housing bubble

Elizabeth Knight
Business columnist

Timing is everything. Had Australia’s prudential banking regulator announced plans to curb riskier lending on Monday, it might have caused pause for thought among the wave of investors standing on suburban lawns bidding up house prices on Saturday mornings.

But on Wednesday afternoon the Australian Bureau of Statistics released a larger than expected inflation number. The consequence of this to aspiring borrowers will be far more meaningful.

With those inflation figures, the chance of another interest rate cut this year was obliterated and the odds of an interest rate cut next year moved to slim. Indeed, the odds of rates moving up next year are firming.

And nothing dampens the desire to take out loans, particularly riskier loans, like a higher interest rate or the prospect of one. Rate rises are kryptonite for investors who rely on making a profit from rising house prices.

The spectre of rising interest rates will dampen property speculators.Sitthixay Ditthavong
Advertisement

In many respects, the spectre of interest rates rising has made the abundantly cautious move from the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) redundant.

If the object of APRA’s new move was to cool down the frothy housing market, the Reserve Bank will probably beat it to the punch.

There is clear evidence that after the RBA started lowering rates early this year investors have flocked into the market and have been a significant contributing factor to booming house prices.

They have been active in the cheaper end of the market, front-running renewed interest from the first home buyer cohort who are availing themselves of the government’s 5 per cent deposit scheme.

In the September quarter, the value of new investor loans grew by 17.6 per cent compared with the June quarter. It’s these kinds of numbers that can unnerve a prudential regulator.

Advertisement

That said, there is nothing wrong with APRA getting ahead of the curve and firing a shot across the bow of the banking industry.

Previous macroprudential measures, like a 3 per cent serviceability buffer for borrowers, have been highly effective in ensuring that the system has avoided being riddled with bad or delinquent home loans.

The Australian financial system is one of the most robust in the world because regulation has served it well.

As it stands, the curbs announced by APRA on Thursday limit the proportion of loans made by banks to people whose total debts would be at least six times their income.

Advertisement

From February 1, the new limits will mean no more than 20 per cent of banks’ new mortgage lending will be available to customers borrowing six times their income or more.

While this applies across the board to owner-occupiers and investors, it is investor loans that are the true target of the regulator, given a larger portion of these riskier loans are being given to this cohort of the market.

But currently only 4 per cent of new owner-occupier home loans fall into this category and about 10 per cent of new investor loans.

For example, the country’s second-largest home lender, Westpac, originated 7.6 per cent of loans at or above six times debt-to-income, which was consistent with its numbers over the previous few years.

Thus, APRA gives new meaning to the term “abundance” in abundance of caution.

Advertisement

APRA probably regards this as an insurance policy against the potential for banks to develop any additional to higher risk lending.

It is clearly concerned about the degree of household debt. In its system risk outlook delivered last week, APRA pointed to the gross debt of Australian households sitting at about 1.8 times their incomes, which makes the system vulnerable to shocks.

Whether APRA’s debt-to-income restrictions will cause collateral damage to those first home owners who the government’s deposit scheme is supporting remains to be seen.

The banks have not provided information on how many of these customers would be captured under APRA’s new curbs.

Advertisement

They could be advantaged if the hot housing bubble deflates, thanks to the possibility that the RBA’s interest rate cutting cycle has come to an end.

The Business Briefing newsletter delivers major stories, exclusive coverage and expert opinion. Sign up to get it every weekday morning.

Elizabeth KnightElizabeth Knight comments on companies, markets and the economy.Connect via Twitter or email.

Most Viewed in Business

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Original URL: https://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/business/banking-and-finance/it-s-interest-rates-not-regulators-that-will-burst-our-housing-bubble-20251127-p5niwy.html