Navalny was close to being freed in swap before he was killed, ally says

Moscow: Russian opposition politician Alexei Navalny was “killed” because he was close to being freed in a prisoner swap and President Vladimir Putin could not tolerate the thought of him being released, a close ally alleged on Monday.

Navalny, 47, died at an Arctic penal colony on February 16. The Kremlin, which casts Navalny and his supporters as US-backed extremists, has denied state involvement in his death. Navalny’s death certificate, according to supporters, said he died of natural causes.

Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny gestures in a court room in Moscow.Credit: AP

The Kremlin did not immediately respond to a request for comment and Navalny ally Maria Pevchikh, who is based outside Russia, did not present documentary evidence for her assertion.

Speaking on YouTube, Pevchikh said talks about exchanging Navalny and two unnamed US nationals for Vadim Krasikov, a Russian FSB security service hit man in jail in Germany, were in their final stages at the time of his death.

“Alexei Navalny could be sitting in this seat right now, right today. That’s not a figure of speech, it could and should have happened,” said Pevchikh, who chairs the board of Navalny’s anti-corruption foundation and is based outside Russia.

“Navalny should have been out in the next few days because we got a decision about his exchange. In early February, Putin was offered to exchange the killer, FSB officer Vadim Krasikov, who’s serving time for a murder in Berlin, for two American citizens and Alexei Navalny.”

Yulia, Navalny’s wife, said on the X social media network that Pevchikh’s intervention had shown why Putin had killed her husband.

“And we will definitely find out who exactly and how exactly executed this crime,” she wrote.

One Western official told Reuters that no formal offer had been made on a swap that would involve Navalny, but said early discussions between Russia, the United States and Germany had been underway.

Two Russian sources told Reuters that talks on swapping Navalny had been held and that an exchange had been agreed in principle. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov was cited by the Financial Times as saying he was not aware of any agreement to exchange Navalny.

Vadim Krasikov was jailed for life in Germany after being convicted of killing an exiled Chechen-Georgian dissident in Berlin in 2019. Putin signalled in an interview with US journalist Tucker Carlson this month that he wanted to get Krasikov, whom he cast as a patriot, back.

The German government declined to comment on Monday.

Pevchikh, who has been designated a “foreign agent” by Russia where the authorities accuse her of involvement in an extremist organisation, said she had received confirmation that negotiations for the swap were in their final stages on the evening of February 15.

Navalny, she alleged, had been killed a day later because Putin could not tolerate the thought of him being free. She did not explain why Putin had not simply refused to swap Navalny if he was opposed to such an exchange.

She said that businessman Roman Abramovich had been the one to float the idea to Putin of exchanging Navalny. There was no immediate comment from Abramovich.

Pevchikh did not name the two US nationals purportedly in contention to be swapped along with Navalny. But the United States has said it is trying to return Evan Gershkovich, a reporter for the Wall Street Journal and Paul Whelan, a former U.S. marine.

Russia accuses both men of espionage, something they deny.

One Russian source with knowledge of the discussions told Reuters that the prisoner exchange had been meant to take place in the middle of February and that both Navalny and his wife had agreed to it.

The source also said Abramovich had been involved in the talks.

“Initially, the plan envisaged an exchange only involving Gershkovich, and Abramovich had discussed it with Putin. The only person Putin was ready to swap him for was Krasikov. But the Germans were categorically against it, because it was an American problem. When Navalny appeared within this plan, the Germans finally agreed,” the source said.

“Everything was finally confirmed when (German Chancellor Olaf) Scholz went to the States (he held White House talks on February 9). The details of when and where all this would happen were already being discussed.”

A source close to the Kremlin said Russia and the West had agreed in principle to make an exchange involving Navalny and Gershkovich, but that the precise details of such a deal had yet to be worked out.

Both Russian sources suggested Gershkovich’s chances of being swapped had now been set back.

“They will be looking for options again, but we’re now back to the time of Gershkovich’s arrest. There’s nothing on the table,” said the first Russian source.

Putin, who has yet to comment on Navalny’s death, said this month that talks between Russian and US intelligence agencies were going on related to Gershkovich, but made no mention of Navalny, whose name he does not usually mention publicly.

The late opposition politician’s body was handed over to his mother in the Arctic city of Salekhard on Saturday.

The arrangements for his burial, expected to take place in Moscow, have yet to be announced. Navalny’s spokeswoman said on Monday that his team was looking for a venue where a public farewell ceremony could take place by the end of this week.

Reuters

Get a note directly from our foreign correspondents on what’s making headlines around the world. Sign up for the weekly What in the World newsletter here.