Victoria's Secret ‘Angels’ suffered in culture of misogyny

Victoria's Secret defined femininity for millions of women. Its catalogue and fashion shows were popular touchstones. For models, landing a spot as an "Angel" all but guaranteed international stardom.

Model Bella Hadid was reportedly the target of ex-Victoria's Secret heavyweight Ed Razek's inappropriate remarks.Credit: Evan Agostini

But inside the company, two powerful men presided over an entrenched culture of misogyny, bullying and harassment, according to interviews with more than 30 current and former executives, employees, contractors and models, as well as court filings and other documents.

Ed Razek, for decades one of the top executives at L Brands, the parent company of Victoria's Secret, was the subject of repeated complaints about inappropriate conduct. He tried to kiss models. He asked them to sit on his lap. He touched one's crotch ahead of the 2018 Victoria's Secret fashion show.

Executives said they had alerted Leslie Wexner, the billionaire founder and chief executive of L Brands, about his deputy's pattern of behaviour. Some women who complained faced retaliation. One model, Andi Muise, said Victoria's Secret had stopped hiring her for its fashion shows after she rebuffed Razek's advances.

A number of the brand's models agreed to pose nude, often without being paid, for a prominent Victoria's Secret photographer who later used some pictures in an expensive coffee-table book – an arrangement that made L Brands executives uncomfortable about women feeling pressured to take their clothes off.

The atmosphere was set at the top. Razek, the chief marketing officer, was perceived as Wexner's proxy, leaving many employees with the impression he was invincible, according to current and former employees. On multiple occasions, Wexner himself was heard demeaning women.

The Victoria's Secret Fashion Show was cancelled for 2019.Credit: Evan Agostini

"What was most alarming to me, as someone who was always raised as an independent woman, was just how ingrained this behaviour was," said Casey Crowe Taylor, a former public relations employee at Victoria's Secret who said she had witnessed Razek's conduct. "This abuse was just laughed off and accepted as normal. It was almost like brainwashing. And anyone who tried to do anything about it wasn't just ignored. They were punished."

The interviews with the models and employees add to a picture of Victoria's Secret as a troubled organisation, an image that was already coming into focus last year when Wexner's ties to sex criminal Jeffrey Epstein became public. Epstein, who managed Wexner's multibillion-dollar fortune, lured some young women by posing as a recruiter for Victoria's Secret models.

Miranda Kerr was one of several Australian models to walk in the Victoria's Secret show.Credit: Wireimage

L Brands, the publicly traded company that also owns Bath & Body Works, is on the brink of a high-stakes transition. The annual Victoria's Secret fashion show has been cancelled after nearly two decades on network TV. Razek, 71, stepped down from L Brands in August. And Wexner, 82, is exploring plans to retire and to sell the lingerie company, people familiar with the matter said.

As those plans progress, L Brands' treatment of women is likely to come under even closer scrutiny.

In response to detailed questions from The New York Times, Tammy Roberts Myers, a spokeswoman for L Brands, provided a statement on behalf of the board's independent directors. She said that the company "is intensely focused" on corporate governance, workplace and compliance practices and that it had "made significant strides."

"We regret any instance where we did not achieve this objective and are fully committed to continuous improvement and complete accountability," she said. The statement did not dispute any of The Times' reporting.

Razek said in an email: "The accusations in this reporting are categorically untrue, misconstrued or taken out of context. I've been fortunate to work with countless, world-class models and gifted professionals and take great pride in the mutual respect we have for each other." He declined to comment on a detailed list of allegations.

Thomas Davies, a spokesman for Wexner, declined to comment.

Gigi Hadid walks in the 2018 Victoria's Secret Fashion Show.Credit: AP

Fiery Explosions

Victoria's Secret, which Wexner bought for $US1 million in 1982 and turned into a lingerie powerhouse, is struggling.

The societal norms defining beauty and sexiness have been changing for years, with a greater value on a wide range of body types, skin colours and gender identities. Victoria's Secret hasn't kept pace. Some of its ad campaigns, for example, seem more like a stereotypical male fantasy – director Michael Bay filmed a TV spot in which scantily clad models strutted in front of helicopters, motorcycles and fiery explosions – than a realistic encapsulation of what women want.

Models Rosie Huntington-Whiteley, Lily Aldridge, Candice Swanepoel and company executive Ed Razek at a Victoria's Secret in New York in 2009.

With its sales declining, Victoria's Secret has been closing stores. Shares of L Brands have fallen more than 75 per cent from their 2015 peak.

Six current and former executives said in interviews that when they tried to steer the company away from what one called its "porny" image, they were rebuffed. Three said they had been driven out of the company.

Criticism of Victoria's Secret's anachronistic marketing went viral in 2018 when Razek expressed no interest in casting plus-size and "transsexual" models in the fashion show.

Then, last summer, Epstein was charged with sex trafficking, and the festering business problems at Victoria's Secret escalated into a public crisis.

Photographer Russell James (left, with Jani Friedman and Ed Razek) took nude photos of Victoria's Secret models for his books.Credit: WireImage

Wexner and Epstein had been tight. The retail tycoon gave the financier carte blanche to manage his billions, elevating Epstein's stature and affording him an opulent lifestyle. Wexner has said he and Epstein parted ways around 2007, the year after Florida prosecutors charged him with a sex crime.

On multiple occasions from 1995 through 2006, Epstein lied to aspiring models that he worked for Victoria's Secret and could help them land gigs. He invited them for auditions, which at least twice ended with Epstein assaulting them, according to the women and court filings.

"I had spent all of my savings getting Victoria's Secret lingerie to prepare for what I thought would be my audition," a woman identified as Jane Doe said in a statement read aloud last summer in a federal court hearing in the Epstein case. "But instead it seemed like a casting call for prostitution. I felt like I was in hell."

Three L Brands executives said Wexner was alerted in the mid-1990s about Epstein's attempts to recruit women. The executives said there was no sign that Wexner had acted on the complaints.

'Someplace Sexy to Take You'

"With the exception of Les, I've been with L Brands longer than anyone," Razek wrote to employees in August when he announced he was leaving the company he had joined in 1983.

Alyssa Miller, who had been an occasional Victoria's Secret model, described Razek as someone who exuded 'toxic masculinity'.

Razek was instrumental in selecting the brand's supermodels – known as "Angels" and bestowed with enormous, feathery wings – and in creating the company's macho TV ads.

But his biggest legacy was the annual fashion show, which became a global cultural phenomenon.

"That's really where he sunk his teeth into the business," said Cynthia Fedus-Fields, a former chief executive of the Victoria's Secret division responsible for its catalogue. By 2000, she said, Razek had grown so powerful that "he spoke for Les".

Sometimes Wexner spoke for himself.

In March, at a meeting at Victoria's Secret headquarters in Columbus, Ohio, an employee asked Wexner what he thought about the retail industry's embrace of different body types. He was dismissive.

"Nobody goes to a plastic surgeon and says, 'Make me fat,'" Wexner replied, according to two attendees.

Razek often reminded models that their careers were in his hands, according to models and current and former executives who heard his remarks.

Alyssa Miller, who had been an occasional Victoria's Secret model, described Razek as someone who exuded "toxic masculinity". She summed up his attitude as: "I am the holder of the power. I can make you or break you."

At castings, Razek sometimes asked models in their bras and underwear for their phone numbers, according to three people who witnessed his advances. He urged others to sit on his lap. Two models said he had asked them to have private dinners with him.

One was Muise. In 2007, after two years of wearing the coveted angel wings in the Victoria's Secret runway show, the 19-year-old was invited to dinner with Razek. She was excited to cultivate a professional relationship with one of the fashion industry's most powerful men, she said.

Razek picked her up in a chauffeured car. On the way to the restaurant, he tried to kiss her, she said. Muise rebuffed him; Razek persisted.

For months, he sent her intimate emails, which The Times reviewed. At one point he suggested they move in together in his house in Turks and Caicos. Another time, he urged Muise to help him find a home in the Dominican Republic for them to share.

"I need someplace sexy to take you!" he wrote.

Muise maintained a polite tone in her emails, trying to protect her career. When Razek asked her to come to his New York home for dinner, Muise said the prospect of dining alone with Razek made her uneasy; she skipped the dinner.

She soon learned that for the first time in four years, Victoria's Secret had not picked her for its 2008 fashion show.

'Forget the Panties'

In 2018, at a fitting ahead of the fashion show, supermodel Bella Hadid was being measured for underwear that would meet broadcast standards. Razek sat on a couch, watching.

"Forget the panties," he declared, according to three people who were there and a fourth who was told about it. The bigger question, he said, was whether the TV network would let Hadid walk "down the runway with those perfect titties". (One witness remembered Razek using the word "breasts", not "titties".)

At the same fitting, Razek placed his hand on another model's underwear-clad crotch, three people said.

An employee complained to the human resources department about Razek's behaviour, according to three people. The employee presented HR with a document last summer listing more than a dozen allegations about Razek, including his demeaning comments and inappropriate touching of women, according to a copy of the document reviewed by The Times.

It wasn't the first HR complaint about him.

At a photo shoot in June 2015, the company put out a buffet lunch for staff. Crowe Taylor, the public relations employee, went to get seconds. Razek intercepted her, she said. He blocked her path and looked her up and down. Then, with dozens of people watching and Crowe Taylor holding her empty plate, he tore into her, berating her about her weight and telling her to lay off the pasta and bread.

Crowe Taylor, who was 5-foot-10 and 140 pounds, fled to a bathroom and burst into tears. She said that she had complained to HR but that as far as she could tell, nothing happened. She quit weeks later.

In October, shortly after Razek had left the company, Monica Mitro, a top public-relations executive at Victoria's Secret, lodged a harassment complaint against him with a former member of the L Brands board of directors, according to five people familiar with the matter. She told colleagues that she had gone to the former director because she didn't trust the HR department.

The next day, the head of HR told Mitro that she was being placed on administrative leave, the people said. She recently reached a financial settlement with the company, they said.

'A Voyeuristic Journey'

Russell James was one of Victoria's Secret's go-to photographers. The company at times paid him tens of thousands of dollars a day, according to draft contracts reviewed by The Times.

At the end of sessions with models, James sometimes asked if they would be photographed nude, according to models and L Brands executives. James was popular; he had a knack for making women feel comfortable. He also had a close relationship with Razek. The women often consented.

The nude photo shoots weren't covered under the models' contracts with Victoria's Secret, which meant they weren't paid for the extra work.

In the industry, "everyone is using their influence to get something," said Miller, the model. "With Russell, it was getting girls to pose for his books or portrait series nude."

In 2014, James published a glossy collectors' book, Angels, which featured some of the nude photos. The women agreed to have their photos included in the book, according to Martin Singer, a lawyer for James.

Two versions of the books currently sell on James' website for $US1800 ($2688) and $3600 ($5376). Victoria's Secret hosted a launch event for Angels during New York Fashion Week in 2014. Attendees included supermodels and the company's chief executive at the time, Sharen Turney.

"This ample volume offers an unprecedented and personal view into James' most intimate portrait sittings," the book's jacket says, noting that James met many of the women during his 15 years working for Victoria's Secret. "Readers will be taken on a voyeuristic journey into a world of subtle provocation."

At one point, a poster-size version of one of the book's photos was displayed in a Victoria's Secret store in Las Vegas. The model's agent complained to Victoria's Secret that his client's photo was being used in the store without her consent. James also complained about it and asked for it to be removed, according to Singer. The company took down the photo.

The New York Times