KFC SuperCoach AFL 2022 Rookie Bible: The cheapies you must consider
The teams have dropped and some popular rookies have been left out. Find out which KFC SuperCoach cash cows you need to pick.
SuperCoach
Don't miss out on the headlines from SuperCoach. Followed categories will be added to My News.
It’s down to this.
KFC SuperCoach teams are almost locked in as Round 1 gets underway, with one major exception – rookies.
Crucial to every SuperCoach side, which cheapies we select will determine our 2022 fortunes and potentially allow some late moves with more expensive players.
Only a tiny number of rookies are locked out after the grand final rematch, so who should you be picking in your team?
WATCH EXPERTS DAN BATTEN, THE PHANTOM, AND AL PATON DEBATE THE BEST CHEAPIE PICKS IN THE PLAYER ABOVE
Dan Batten and The Phantom have been tracking the top juniors and mature-age recruits for months. Here is their verdict on the Round 1 locks, probables and possibles, and their predicted scoring averages for 2022.
CONFIRMED ROUND 1 LOCKS
DEFENCE
Patrick McCartin (Syd) $157,800 DEF/FWD
2021 SC Ave: 70 (VFL) 2022 PS score: 74
Predicted average: 60-65 Job security: High
The former No.1 pick has entered the KFC SuperCoach frame as he looks to re-ignite his stalled career at the Swans. McCartin, who was signed as a rookie during the supplemental selection period, has been clunking intercept marks in his new role down back, where he shone at VFL level last year. Taking out an injury-affected score of eight, the 25-year-old averaged 85.5 points across four matches – with a lengthy suspension in between – for Sydney’s reserves. He has valuable DEF/FWD eligibility and provides some value at his price tag, but he does carry an injury risk with his concussion history. McCartin posted 74 points from 14 disposals in the Community Series, taking seven marks and growing in confidence in his intercept role.
DB: BUY. Never thought I’d say this, but I am picking Paddy McCartin in SuperCoach. His intercept marking role down back is promising, and he is one of only a few defensive rookies available.
TP: BUY. Concussion history is a concern but he impressed in the new role and his job security seems secure, putting him near the front of the defensive rookie queue. In my team, on field.
Mitchell Hinge (Adel) $180,900 DEF
2021 SC ave (AFL) 31 2022 PS score: 79, 64 (71.5)
Predicted average: 60-65 Job security: High
Hinge has played just two proper matches in the last two seasons – a score of 31 from 44 per cent game time in 2021 and a ton with Brisbane in 2020 – with a spate of shoulder dislocations cruelling his first year at the Crows. However, the 23-year-old runner has been playing on a wing for the stronger Crows side during the pre-season and appears in line for a Round 1 berth. Underlined his SuperCoach credentials with 79 points against Brisbane in the Crows’ first pre-season clash, and another 64 in the Community Series before going off with injury.
DB: BUY. Has emerged as one of the leading options in defence despite his price tag – his injury concern is his only query. But the Crows have confirmed he will play.
TP: BUY. Set to resume training this week and is a Round 1 lock for the Crows if he’s right to go - and the signs are good. On-field option.
Josh Gibcus (Rich) $171,300
2021 SC Ave: 83 (NAB League) 2022 PS score: 65
Predicted average: 50-55 Job security: High
Gibcus is the intercept king of last year’s draft, leading the NAB League in intercept marks (3.2 per game) and intercept possessions (7.9). The retirement of David Astbury opens the door for a key defender, and has done everything right this pre-season. He appears set to debut in Round 1 regardless of whether co-captain Dylan Grimes recovers from a finger injury.
DB: BUY. He may be a touch expensive for a first-year key defender, but Gibcus’s job security appears strong, and his Community Series effort was a sign his scoring could be solid. A good back-up option if Hinge isn’t named.
TP: BUY. The price is a little off-putting for a first-year key defender but we aren’t blessed with options in defence. I’d pick McCartin ahead of him, though.
Sam De Koning (Geel) $123,900, DEF/FWD
2021 SC ave: 27 (AFL), 65 (VFL)
Predicted average: 45-55 Job security: Medium
A versatile 202cm tall, De Koning has settled in defence this pre-season as he vies for a spot in the Geelong side. The former first-round draftee has added considerable size to his frame and may be the beneficiary of Lachie Henderson’s retirement. De Koning started for the Cats in defence in their six-period practice match, in a sign he could force his way in early. De Koning was one of the surprise packets of the Community Series, all but locking in a Round 1 spot with 19 disposals, five marks and 92 points in defence.
DB: BUY... Looks to be our saviour in defence, and is a confirmed starter in for his second AFL game.
TP: BUY.Might not get 19 disposals every week but looks comfortable in Geelong’s back-six and his height and athleticism means he can impact contests regularly. Finally – touch wood – a bench lock in defence.
MIDFIELD
Jason Horne-Francis (NM) $207,300 MID
2021 SC Ave: 88 (SANFL) 2022 PS score: 83, 87 (85)
Predicted average: 80-85 Job security: Very high
24 disposals. 18 contested possessions. 11 clearances. 160 SuperCoach points. And 3.2. In a SANFL preliminary final – at 18! The highlights of this dominant display should ease any concerns for those who aren’t keen on starting a high-priced rookie. The No.1 draft pick should be locked and loaded for Round 1 after 29 games against grown men over the past two seasons. However, David Noble wasn’t making any promises, saying he will have to prove himself over the pre-season. Sure enough, JHF went and blitzed an intra-club and scored 83 points in the Roos’ practice-match drubbing to show just how insulting this was. Displayed his high-impact scoring with 87 points from just 16 disposals at 43 per cent efficiency against the Swans, booting 2.2 and winning 11 contested possessions.
DB: MUST-HAVE. Noble’s pre-practice match comments are looking sillier by the day. It’s hard to see a world where he isn’t playing every game this year. You have just got to pick him.
TP: MUST-HAVE.Will spend plenty of time forward, but as he proved again in the AAMI Series, IT DOESN’T MATTER. Lock. Next.
Nick Daicos (Coll) $193,800 MID
2021 SC Ave: 159 (NAB League) 2022 PS score: 100
Predicted average: 80-85 Job security: Very high
In his five NAB League games last year, Daicos posted KFC SuperCoach scores of 177, 166, 145, 169 and 138. He was ready for AFL footy last season – even the Magpies said he probably would’ve got a game. Daicos, who averaged 36 disposals and two goals, has the versatility and skill set to be used on each line, but new coach Craig McRae told News Corp recently the Magpies will “try to play him across halfback and through the midfield” early in his career. Playing in that precise role in Collingwood’s intra-club, Daicos tallied a game-high 24 disposals and even took some kick-ins. To top it off, he was the leading disposal winner for the Pies against the Giants in the Community Series, finishing with a KFC SuperCoach ton. .
DB: MUST-HAVE.Daicos is a cut above the rest from last year’s draft crop, along with Horne-Francis. Should get plenty of the Sherrin in that Pies backline — lock it up.
TP: MUST-HAVE. Worth the top-end rookie price tag, even alongside Horne-Francis. They both could get DPP at some stage, too.
Josh Ward (Haw) $180,300 MID
2021 SC Ave: 133 (NAB League) 2022 PS score: 124
Predicted average: 75-80 Job security: High
An ultra-consistent midfielder in the mould of his coach, Ward posted 124 points or above in four of his five NAB League games. And that’s the score he posted in an immense Community Series display, tallying 29 disposals, 19 contested possessions and six clearances. Ward can be used on the inside and outside and his immense work-ethic means it’ll be a matter of when, rather than if, he debuts in 2022. Sam Mitchell will look to blood more kids in the Hawks’ regenerating phase and Ward looks set to be first cab off the rank. There was also plenty of buzz around him after their pre-season intra-club match, where he started in the centre-bounce and was one of the standouts.
DB: BUY. JHF, Daicos and Ward - three high-priced midfield rookies you need to have. His monster showing was without Tom Mitchell and Jaeger O’Meara, but he is only just getting started.
TP: BUY. Big junior numbers, elite work rate and a team in need of a new look in the midfield. It might be the year to go expensive on the bench.
Dylan Stephens (Syd) $167,800 MID
2021 SC Ave: 30.8 (AFL), 101 (VFL) 2022 PS score: 63
Predicted average: 65-70 Job security: High
On the surface, Stephen’s average of 30.8 from six matches in his second season sets off alarm bells. But Stephens was hardly given a chance by John Longmire, spending just 49.4 per cent of his time on the park. It looks it it’ll be a different story in 2022, and that’s straight from the Horse’s mouth: “Dylan Stephens is one that really stands out. He has been training at a really high intensity and he’s put on some size, which we wanted him to do.” The top-five draft pick, who averaged 101 points and 28 disposals in the reserves last year, looms as a possible on-field cheapie option. Gathered 20 possessions and scored 83 points against North Melbourne, franking a strong pre-season.
DB: BUY. With the shortage of cheaper midfield rookies, Stephens is a possible bench or on-field option.
TP: BUY. Ticks more boxes than some draftees and provides plenty of value at that price in his third season. M8 for me.
Brady Hough (WCE) $117,300 MID
2021 SC Ave: 114 (WAFL), 117 (WAFLC) 2022 PS scores: 11, 47 (29)
Predicted average: 50-55 Job security: High
An athletic utility with good skills, Hough turned heads in his sole WAFL senior appearance for Peel Thunder last year, tallying 22 disposals, nine marks, a goal and 114 points. The 190cm product played a variety of different roles at WAFL Colts and state level, and was another young Eagle to show promise in their intra-club game off half-back. Hough showed promise out of defence in the Community Series, tallying 14 disposals, eight marks and 47 points, with teammate Jack Redden declaring post-match that Hough is ready to go.
DB: BUY. West Coast’s injury crisis has worked in his favour, and he should have a nice role across halfback.
TP: BUY. The space at Optus Stadium will suit the composed draftee and he’s another to consider for the bench, depending on which other rookies are named.
Connor MacDonald (Haw) $117,300 MID
2021 SC Ave: 148 (NAB League) 2022 PS score: 52
Predicted average: 55-60 Job security: Medium
MacDonald was a ball-winning machine for the Dandenong Stingrays, averaging 30 disposals, 14 contested possessions, seven inside 50s, five clearances and 148 KFC SuperCoach points per game in the NAB League last season. The midfielder’s professionalism should hold him in good stead as he vies for a debut, and we know the Hawks have an ageing midfield group. MacDonald was another to put his case forward in Hawthorn’s internal trial. MacDonald took another step towards a Round 1 berth, getting his hands on the footy, with assistant coach Stephen Gilham remarking on commentary that he is “ready to go.” MacDonald continued his promising pre-season with 16 disposals, a goal and 52 points against the Tigers in the Community Series.
DB: BUY. His junior numbers are impressive, and he has been shown enough as a bench pick during the practice games. It’s a toss-up between him and Soligo for me, and I’m leaning towards MacDonald.
TP: BUY. Looks the best of a very small group of $117k midfield rookies that in the Round 1 mix. Looms as a popular bench pick.
Jake Soligo (Carl) $117,300 MID
2021 SC Ave: 114 (NAB League) 2022 PS score: 31, 45 (38)
Predicted average: 50-55 Job security: Low
There were some comparisons made to Swan Errol Gulden around draft time, given Soligo’s foot skills, clean hands at ground level and footy IQ. And that should get the attention of all KFC SuperCoaches. The 18-year-old matched it with the bigger bodies in the VFL last year and averaged 23 disposals, 10 contested possessions and six tackles in the NAB League. After being sighted with the stronger Crows side in match simulation, Soligo shapes as a Round 1 bolter. Soligo had some nice moments on a wing in Adelaide’s pre-season hitout, but managed just 31 points. He performed slightly better in the Community Series, where he scored 45 points from nine touches and 66 per cent time-on-ground.
DB: CONSIDER. Being a confirmed starter for round 1 with Jordan Dawson in the side is a good sign. But are there better options with greater job security?
TP: CONSIDER. Could hold his place in the side for Round 1 if recruit Jordan Dawson isn’t right to go. Scoring is a concern, but at least he might be there.
Mitch Owens (St K) $117,300 MID
2021 SC Ave: 101 (NAB League) 2022 PS score: DNP, 39
Predicted average: 50-55 Job security: Low
Owens’ rapid development last year saw him shoot up significantly in his draft year – both in height and ability. The 190cm midfielder posted SuperCoach tons in his final three NAB League games – two of which exceeded 120. His overhead marking and size could add something different for the Saints up forward or through the middle in 2022. Showed promise in a quarter of game time in the AAMI Series, scoring 39 points from four disposals, including three clearances.
DB: PASS... Think it is a risk starting him over Stephens. But his cameo in the second practice match was promising.
TP: Will add another layer to the St Kilda side, but will he become a regular?
Jackson Mead (PA) $123,900 FWD
2021 SC Ave: 77 (SANFL) 2022 PS scores: 37, 24 (30.5)
Predicted average: 50-55 Job security: Low
Mead missed 12 weeks last year and even spent time in intensive care after suffering a lacerated spleen, and the uncapped midfielder has made up for lost time this pre-season. The 20-year-old is closing in on a debut, with assistant coach Nathan Bassett saying Mead has had an “outstanding pre-season” after a strong intra-club display. Entering his third year, Mead is hungry for opportunity and shapes as one of the leading cheap midfield-rookie contenders. However, he had just eight touches from 63 per cent game time in the AAMI Series and appears set to be squeezed out of that midfield group.
DB: PASS. I have cooled on Mead after his second practice game. Question marks over his scoring and job security.
TP: WATCH. This space. Had limited impact in the AAMI Series but could still be in the mix.
Alex Davies (GC) $202,400 MID
2021 SC Ave: 60 (1 games), 86 (VFL) 2022 PS scores: 96, 53 (74.5)
Predicted average: 65-70 Job security: Medium
Davies, a 191cm midfielder, is a contested-ball star, who hunts the body when he doesn’t get his hands on it first. On debut in the final round last season, Davies won 14 of his 17 possessions in a contest and applied six tackles, on his way to 62 KFC SuperCoach points. In his final four VFL matches before the season was called off, the 19-year-old Suns Academy graduate averaged 21 disposals, 14 contested possessions, seven clearances, seven tackles and 111 points. Touted as a Hugh Greenwood replacement, Davies slotted two goals on his way to 96 points in their surprise win over Port Adelaide, putting his hand up to SuperCoach sides. He had less impact in the second match, attending just the four centre bounces and winning 11 possessions – 10 of those contested – on the way to 53 points.
DB: PASS. Any danger of saving his debut until 2022, Dewey? Would have been a no-brainer at $123k — but $200k is perhaps a bit much with other better options around.
TP: CONSIDER. Spent plenty of time forward in the AAMI Series but, as a full-time mid, he could be explode. Still could be a nice point-of-difference anyway.
Angus Sheldrick $130,800 MID
2021 SC Ave: 152 (WAFLC), 108 (U18 Champs)
Predicted average: 50-55
Sheldrick’s SuperCoach potential was on full display in the WAFL Colts last season, where he averaged a mind-boggling 152 points from his nine matches, with a floor of 129 – now that’s consistency. The inside bull won an absurd 63 per cent of his possessions in a contest and averaged a goal per game, closing out the season with scores of 176, 144 and 164 during the finals. While he is being trialled in a less SuperCoach friendly role as a small forward in his first pre-season at the Swans, he has the tools to score well.
DB: A human battering-ram at 18, Sheldrick may well be a point-scoring machine by 23. Think he could play a similar role to what Power tough nut Sam Powell-Pepper did in his first year, with a 2022 debut on the cards.
TP: Sheldrick is one who can have an immediate impact but there are a number of other young midfielders pushing their case at the Swans.
RUCK
Jack Hayes (St K) $102,400 RUCK/FWD
2021 SC ave: 128 (SANFL) 2022 PS score: 33, 60
Predicted average: 50-55 Job security: Medium
Hayes is top of the list for KFC SuperCoaches out of these train-on players for two reasons. One, his scoring dominance in the SANFL across a three year period, which has seen the mobile big man record season averages of 128, 124 and 105. And second, he is a basement price RUC/FWD rookie – valuable as a swing and a cash generator. Hayes is in the box seat for a Round 1 debut after featuring in the second half in a ruck/forward role in the Saints’ pre-season match then playing a full game against the Bombers.
DB: BUY. Close to a lock with his DPP if he’s named for Round 1.
TP: BUY. Looming as the perfect F8 or R3.
Hugh Dixon (WCE) $102,400 FWD/RUC
2021 SC Ave: 88 (WAFL) 2021 PS score: 86, 45 (65.5)
Predicted average: 45-50 Job security: High
Key forward Dixon earned a spot on the Eagles’ list after an eye-catching performance in their practice match thumping – which coincidentally was against his former side, Fremantle. Dixon booted two goals and posted 86 points, finishing as West Coast’s fifth-highest scorer. With Jack Darling’s future still up in the air you would expect Dixon, who slotted 19 goals and averaged 13 disposals, three contested marks and 88 points in the WAFL last year, to be right in the mix for Round 1. Dixon finished with nine disposals, three marks and 45 points in the Community Series. A surprise Jack Darling return was a brief concern to Dixon’s hopes but but Darling is set to be sidelined for a month with injury.
DB: BUY. Key forwards aren’t our friends but I’m willing to make a compromise for one this cheap, especially with his RUC/FWD status. Pick him on your ruck bench and Jack Hayes in the forward line for a handy swing.
TP: BUY. Could be the Eagles No.1 forward soon enough. But, seriously, 86 points as a $102k cheapie? Put him on your bench, while Darling is still out, but don’t expect those scores every week, though.
Bailey Williams (WCE) $218,600, RUC/FWD
2021 SC ave: 40.2 (AFL), 77 (WAFL) 2022 PS scores: 50, 46 (48)
Predicted average: 50-55 Job security: Medium
Williams has been on pre-season watch-lists for the past two seasons as a cheap RUC/FWD, and he remains at a discount price. This is because he was used mostly as a forward in his six senior games, which resulted in paltry returns. He could have a more significant role in the Eagles side with Jack Darling’s future under a cloud, but will he have the same ruck share with Nic Natanui remaining at the helm? With Naitainui playing 58 per cent game time in the Community Series, Williams managed 46 points.
DB: Won’t be getting enough ruck time to justify selecting. Pass.
TP: PASS. Had some nice moments as a marking-forward early last year and in the WAFL, and that’s where the bulk of his scoring might need to come from. Not at the price for me.
Max Lynch (Haw) $207,700 RUC
2021 SC Ave: 52 (AFL); 97 (VFL) 2022 PS score: 38
Predicted average: 70-75 Job security: Low
Stuck behind Brodie Grundy at the Magpies, Lynch crossed to the Hawks in the trade period for greater opportunity. The 23-year-old ruckman held his own in his two games for Collingwood last year, and finished strongly in the reserves, averaging 113.3 points in his last four matches. While Jon Ceglar is out of the equation, the question mark remains whether he can leapfrog 2021 cash cow Ned Reeves in the ruck queue – especially at the price. Played limited minutes in Hawthorn’s second practice game, but still managed to win nine disposals, 11 hitouts and score 38 from 39 per cent gametime. Ben McEvoy’s Covid diagnosis means he will partner Reeves in round 1.
DB: PASS. Mitchell told the Herald Sun in the pre-season that it seems “unlikely” Ben McEvoy, Reeves and Lynch will play in the same side. I can’t see it being a long stay in the Hawks side.
TP: Might be just back-up at Hawthorn to start with.
FORWARD
Josh Rachele (Adel) $184,800 FWD/MID
2021 SC Ave: 129 (NAB League) 2022 PS score: 85, 85 (85)
Predicted average: 60-65 Job security: Very high
The Crows need class, skill and x-factor forward of centre, and Rachele fits the bill right away. Adelaide’s top pick in last year’s draft averaged 129 KFC SuperCoach points and booted 11 goals in four games, playing as a forward, in the NAB League last year and could be worth the top-end rookie price tag as a forward. Fears about his role in a struggling team were allayed by his sparkling 85-point display in his first outing as a Crow, booting three goals and having a significant impact. He then booted three goals, had three tackles and posted another 85 points against Port Adelaide.
Dan Batten’s verdict: MUST-HAVE. I did have my doubts, but now I am fully converted. Lock.
Phantom’s verdict: MUST-HAVE. Won’t need a lot of the ball to have an impact as he proved with back-to-back AAMI Series scores in the 80s. Hasn’t left my team for a while.
Will Brodie (Frem) $224,300, FWD/MID
2021 SC Ave: 41 (5 games), 121 (VFL)
2022 PS score: 120, 100 (110)
Predicted average: 80-85 Job security: Medium
In four VFL seasons at the Suns, Brodie averaged 121, 127, 124 and 100. But he managed just 25 senior appearances at the club after being drafted in 2016. And that’s despite ranking first at the Suns for hardball-gets, second for tackles and handballs, third for disposals, fourth for clearances and fifth for contested possessions in the final six games of 2019. But new coach Justin Longmuir likes Brodie’s strength and he impressed in a mid-forward role during recent match sim. And if that wasn’t enough, he racked up 120 points, 28 disposals and a game-high nine clearances against West Coast in Fremantle’s first practice match.
DB: BUY. There are some concerns about his job security with all of the Dockers’ midfielders fit in availabl, but it is hard to ignore those imposing pre-season performances. In my team.
TP: BUY. I’ve said all along if Brodie is named in Round 1, I’ll pick him.
Corey Durdin (Carl) $143,700 FWD
2021 SC Ave: 33 (2 games), 57 (VFL) 2022 PS scores: 57, 43 (50)
Predicted average: 50-55 Job security: Medium
Motlop has arrived but Durdin could be the one to fill the Eddie Betts void first this year, after playing in the final two games of his debut season, He dominated in the midfield as a junior, with his speed, skill and footy smarts, before playing as a forward at senior level in his draft year. He’s one who could have an impact with limited possession, once he finds his feet. Durdin slotted a goal and scoring 57 points against St Kilda in his first practice game. And he showed plenty of spark with two goals and five goals in under a half against Melbourne before succumbing to injury. But that appeared to be precautionary, as he is in for round 1.
DB: LOW-END BUY. His small forward role means he could throw up some stinkers but if you’re choosing between Durdin and Baldwin, the Blue looks to be a safer bet.
TP: CONSIDER. Durdin may find his feet quicker than anticipated after a two-goal first quarter against the Bulldogs. The 21-year-old played just 43 per cent game time but will be right to go in Round 1. An expensive bench option if you need.
Kaine Baldwin (Ess) $123,800 FWD
2021 SC Ave: DNP 2022 PS score: 49, 48 (48.5)
Predicted average: 50-55 Job security: Medium
Baldwin join the Bombers as an SSP signing in early 2021 after being overlooked in the draft. In terms of talent, the Glenelg junior was on par with fellow South Australians Riley Thilthorpe and Lachie Jones, but two knee reconstructions saw him overlooked. He’s on the way, however, to completing a full pre-season and could be one to surprise in 2022. Baldwin’s first game in a Bombers jumper was very promising, clunking a contested mark and booting a goal to go with 49 points. And an injury setback to tall forward Harrison Jones has handed Baldwin a debut, and it could be an extended run in the side.
DB: LOW-END BUY. Key forwards rookies don’t have a great KFC SuperCoach track record, but he is a bigger body. Shapes as a slow burn bench option with good short-term job security. But does he make enough cash?
TP: CONSIDER. An exciting talent, who is injury-free and impressing at Bombers training. Now a real Round 1 chance, who you could put on the bench.
Finn Maginness (Haw) $143,700, FWD/MID
2021 SC ave (AFL): 27.5, (VFL): 108 2022 PS score: 50
Predicted average: 55-60 Job security: Low
The endurance beast always features prominently in the 2km time trial, but is yet to stake his claim as a Hawthorn regular, playing three senior games across his first two seasons. Two of those games came last year, one of them as them starting in the subs vest, which means he is still available at a reasonable rookie price. Maginness averaged 15.2 disposals, 5.3 tackles and 64 KFC SuperCoach points in six VFL matches last year and is among a budding crop of Hawks midfielders hunting for spots. The 189cm Hawk played predominantly through the midfield in an encouraging first practice match. Played in defence at times during Hawthorn’s second practice game as well as the midfield (four CBAs), finishing with 15 disposals and 50 points.
DB: LOW-END BUY. Keep in mind up forward or in the midfield. Named at halfback on Sunday teams — mind you, the Hawks have plenty of defenders to come back.
TP: PASS. Did a lot right this pre-season and is a good chance for Round 1. But will he do enough at the price? Might be too much mid-price value to start Maginness and Josh Rachele on-field.
Nicholas Martin (Ess) $102,400 FWD
2021 SC ave: 80 (WAFL) 2022 PS score: 45, 50 (47.5)
Predicted average: 60-65 Job security: Low
Martin was gunning for one of Essendon’s two list vacancies, following a similar path to fellow WAFL mature-ager Alec Waterman, who was plucked after kicking a bag of goals in a practice match last pre-season. Martin, a creative 190cm forward/wingman, got the nod after showing some encouraging signs with his skills in Essendon’s practice match and scoring 45 points. This came after Martin kicked four goals in an Essendon intra-club. The 20-year-old averaged 14.6 disposals, 80 SuperCoach points and kicked 24 goals for grand finalists Subiaco in the WAFL last season. Strengthened his Round 1 claims in just a half with 16 disposals against St Kilda in the Community Series.
DB: BUY. Alec Waterman 2.0 – but better for KFC SuperCoach. I’ll be starting him if he is named.
TP: BUY. Basement price forward that is a good chance for Round 1 - yes, please.
Tristan Xerri (NM) $208,200 FWD
2021 SC ave 38.2 (AFL), (VFL): 127 2022 PS score: DNP, 96
Predicted average: 60-65 Job security: Medium
With Todd Goldstein holding the ruck reigns at North Melbourne, Xerri has managed just 12 matches in five seasons at the club, eight of those coming last year playing predominately as a forward. But there could be a changing of the guard judging by North Melbourne’s match simulation, where Xerri has took the bulk of the ruck time with 33-year-old Goldstein up forward. Xerri is an interesting proposition if this ruck split translates into the season proper, given he averaged formidable 21.5 disposals, 15.5 contested possessions, 2.5 contested marks and 127 KFC SuperCoach points in six VFL games last year. This included a 209-point monster, where he amassed 36 disposals and 31 contested possessions. He put the Xerri on top of an impressive pre-season with 17 disposals, 14 contested possessions, 29 hitouts and 96 points, taking the lion’s share of ruck contests against Sydney
DB: PASS... Xerri will either average 85, or 40 depending on his role – there’s no in between. With nothing concrete from the Roos on their ruck set-up, I’m willing to wait until Round 3 to assess his role. Not sure Goldy is finished just yet.
TP: WAIT. Rocketed into the KFC SuperCoach conversation, and could be a shrewd selection if he really is the main man at the Kangaroos. He could gain ruck status by Round 6, too. But is Todd Goldstein really finished yet?
Charlie Curnow (Carl) $224,300 FWD
2021 SC Ave: 51 2022 PS scores: 47, DNP
Predicted average: 60-65 Job security: Very high
A fit Charlie Curnow, who averaged 74 and 77 in his last two injury-free years – his second and third in the competition – is almost a no-brainer. And the signs are good so far this summer, but the fact is the talented forward, who played in the final four rounds of 2021, has played just 15 games since 2019. Curnow was kept goalless in Carlton’s first practice match but moved well, scoring 47 points. He was rested for the Blues’ second contest.
DB: AVOID. Curnow is a different kettle of fish to Joe Daniher last year. I don’t think he can justify the high asking price, and there are better options if you want to pay up.
TP: PASS. Could surprise us, but there are now better value options in the price bracket.
Patrick Naish (WCE) $189,600
2021 SC ave: 34.8 (AFL), 125 (VFL)
Predicted average: 55-60 Job security: Medium
Naish travelled all across Australia in pursuit of another AFL chance, and an impressive Community Series outing earned him a list spot with the injury-ravaged Eagles. The delisted Tiger collected 14 disposals, 58 points and booted a goal in just 37 per cent gametime agains the Dockers. Naish’s 2021 average was hurt by back-to-back stints as the sub where he scored a combined six points. The skilful 23-year-old averaged 50 points in his remaining four games and a formidable 125 KFC SuperCoach points in the VFL last season. Naish also posted scores of 78 ad 67 in his first two senior matches in 2019 before being surprisingly dropped, leaving him on the bubble for the remainder of the season.
DB: PASS… Easy on the eye but his contested possession rate has been below 35% across most of his career. May come into the frame if some other rookies aren’t named for round 1.
SUSPENDED ROUND 1
Braydon Preuss $204,700 RUCK
2021 SC Ave: DNP
2022 PS score: 102
Preuss didn’t play a game due to injury in his first season at the Giants last year but the cheap R2 strategy could be back on. Remember, in the three games he played without Max Gawn at the Demons, Preuss posted scores of 84, 85 and 140. And in his two at North Melbourne without Todd Goldstein, he scored 111 and an injury-affected 39. Preuss impressed in a forward/ruck role – Matt Flynn taking more ruck contests - with 12 disposals, 14 hitouts, six tackles and 102 points, but a sling tackle will see him miss Round 1 with suspension.
DB: AVOID... as a starting pick. The suspension is a blessing in disguise. Starting Preuss at R2 and R3 had significant upside, but was fraught with risk given he was unable to assert himself as the No.1 ruck. Could be a trade boost option once he plays two games.
TP: PASS. For now. With Flynn starting the two pre-season games as the No. 1 ruckman, the Preuss at R2 play may have been too risky even before the suspension. But there’s still a case to start him at R3, given his potential cash generation, if you can afford it.
Darcy Wilmot $139,800 DEF
2021 SC Ave: 87 (NAB League)
2022 PS score: 48
With the retirement of Grant Birchall, there could be an opening for the talented Wilmot who not only offers line-breaking run and neat ball-use from defence, but also a strong defensive mindset. The youngest player drafted last year – who Dayne Zorko is tipping to play AFL footy in 2022 - wasn’t a big ball-winner as a junior but he wins it back off the opposition and makes it count. Wilmot gave the Lions drive and slick ball-use out of defence in their practice game, winning 12 touches and scoring 48, but an overzealous sling tackle means he will miss Round 1 with suspension.
DB: WATCH. It's a risk but with options dropping like flies, I’m warming to picking Wilmot on my bench with Keidean Coleman sidelined for two months with a hamstring injury. He may be straight in once his suspension ends.
TP: Hearing plenty of good things out of the Lions camp about Wilmot but he could still have a hard time finding an early spot.
NOT NAMED
Josh Sinn (PA) $157,800 DEF/MID
2021 SC Ave: 90 (NAB League) 2022 PS score: 55, 28
Predicted average: 60-65 Job security: Medium
The Power are well stocked for defenders, but Josh Sinn provides a point-of-difference with his ability to break the lines with his speed and raking left boot. The 188cm product has the potential, ready-made frame and running capacity to feature early, and he should have a friendly role across half-back or on the wing. It is worth remembering that Port Adelaide gave away a prized selection to move up the order and nab Sinn, and coach Ken Hinkley isn’t afraid to give the youngsters a crack. Sinn was arguably the story of Port Adelaide’s intra-club playing mostly on a wing, pushing his case for an early debut with his speed and manic defensive pressure. Complicating matters, he played just the second half against the Crows last weekend.
DB: WAIT. Be prepared to look elsewhere, but if he’s in Round 1 I may take the risk and back in his talent.
TP: WAIT. It all makes sense, and KFC SuperCoaches were hopeful. But then the 18-year-old sat the first half of the AAMI Series game on the bench. Pick him if Ken does, though.
Hugo Ralphsmith (RIch) $206,700, FWD/MID
2021 SC ave: 42.2 (AFL), 50 (VFL) 2022 PS score: 70
Predicted average: 65-70 Job security: Medium
Daniel Rioli looked to have his hands on the Bachar Houli role, but onlookers at Richmond’s intra-club noticed the run of Ralphsmith being used across half-back. The 20-year-old played primarily as a forward last year after making his debut, where he didn’t flatter the KFC SuperCoach scorers, but the 188cm Tiger’s scoring could spike if moved into defence. Ralphsmith was touted for his line-breaking and athleticism at under-18 level, averaging 88 points in the NAB League in 2019. Looks to have proved himself down back, winning 20 disposals and scoring 72 points against the Hawks.
DB: WAIT. Nice role off half-back but will he do enough to justify the elevated price with Short and Rioli also there? Verdict will change if other forward cheapies look to be missing.
TP: WAIT. One of the rookie stories of the pre-season so far and a consistent role in defence is appealing. But will his scoring spike enough to demand selection ahead of others in the price range?
Jordan Boyd (Carl) $123,900 DEF
2021 SC Ave: 67 (VFL) 2022 PS score: 39
Predicted average: 50-55 Job security: Low
Plucked by the Blues in last year’s mid-season draft after a promising start to the season where he averaged 16 disposals and 67 SuperCoach points for Footscray, Boyd showed promise in limited gametime in Carlton’s first practice game. The 23-year-old defender finished with 39 points in about a half of footy against the Saints, and finished with a similar result from 80 per cent gametime in the Community Series. Could be one to contend for a spot early in the season.
DB: PASS. We said consider him for your bench if he is picked for Round 1. But he wasn’t even in the squad of 26.
TP: WAIT. Even if he does play Round 1, does he play the following week? Didn’t do enough in the AAMI Series to convince me, but he’s still in the mix.
Brodie Kemp (Carl) $156,800 DEF
2021 SC Ave: 36 (2 games), 66 (VFL) 2022 PS score: 43, DNP
Predicted average: 45-50 Job security: Medium
Carlton fans waited a long time to see Kemp in the Navy Blue after he did his ACL in his draft year. After impressing at VFL level, the versatile, 193cm 20-year-old showed some great signs in defence in Round 23, tallying 14 disposals, seven spoils, four rebound-50s and 52 points in his second career game. He can run through the midfield, and play as a forward, but he’s been, again, working with the defenders over summer. Although, Kemp was used as a forward in Carlton’s intra-club.
DB: PASS. His forward role isn’t ideal at the price, and he wasn’t named for round 1.
TP: PASS.Was line to play the season opener, despite missing the AAMI Series game and might end up having better job security than some on this list. But what will his scoring be like after a move to half-forward?
Jackson Hately (Adel) $188,700 MID
2021 SC Ave: 99 (SANFL) 2022 PS scores: 20, 25 (22.5)
Predicted average: 55-60 Job security: Low
Hately managed just three senior appearances in his first year at the Crows after arriving with high hopes, following some impressive numbers in limited games for GWS. But the tall midfielder, who averaged 99 points in 10 SANFL games last year, hasn’t missed a beat over summer and could get his chance in 2022. It will be great buying if – and it’s still a reasonably-sized if – he does.
DB: It’s feels like an eternity ago since he was a popular bubble boy after averaging 90 points from his first two matches, but his pre-season form is worth monitoring.
TP: CONSIDER. An interesting one now that Rory Laird is injured. Could score well if given an early opportunity.
Thomson Dow $198,800
2021 SC Ave: 40.6 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 55-60 Job security: Low
Yep, I saw you shudder at the surname. This Dow, a first-round pick like his brother Paddy, was one of Richmond’s highest centre-bounce attendees in their first practice match and showed some positive strides with his ball-winning and attack on the ball. While Trent Cotchin and Jack Graham were among those watching from the sidelines, Dow shapes as a big improver for the Tigers entering his third season. Dow’s scoring last year reflected his brothers in 2021, averaging just 40.6 points from his five matches, but the midfielder averaged also went at 88 points per game in the VFL.
DB: I liked what I saw during the first practice game, but he was dropped for the second game.
TP: A Dow in the first Thursday night game of the KFC SuperCoach season? Not again, thanks.
Ned Long (Haw) $102,400, FWD/MID
2021 SC ave: 144 (NAB League)2022 PS score: 24
Predicted average: 55-60 Job security: Low
Long has emerged as a contender to be unearthed in Round 1 after showing encouraging signs in Hawthorn’s intra-club, with the highlight being a goal from long-range. A goal-kicking midfielder at junior level, injury restricted the 195cm rookie to just three games NAB League games last year - and he eclipsed 120 points in all three. His hulking size and ability to hit the scoreboard help his chances of featuring early. Playing the second half against Richmond, Long was a presence up forward but failed to convert in front of goal, booting four behinds along with nine disposals.
DB: WATCH. An early debut isn’t beyond him, but Round 1 looks a stretch. When he does break in, take note.
TP: Would be a gift, but I’m not holding out much hope for Round 1.
Luke Pedlar $123,900 FWD/MID
2021 SC Ave: 20 (2 games), 57 (SANFL) 2022 PS score: 20
Predicted average: 45-50 Job security: Low
The first-round draft pick didn’t have a big impact in his first season at the Crows at any level. But there were glimpses in his 13-disposal debut against the Lions and the three-goal opener in the SANFL. And Pedlar, a tough ball-winner who can break away from congestion, has traits that are likely to translate to KFC SuperCoach scoring, should more chances come in a young Crows midfield. He played limited minutes in the second practice game, playing just 15 per cent time-on-ground and kicking a goal.
DB: PASS. A big KFC SuperCoach scorer at SANFL under-18 level, averaging 128 points. But his scoring and job security doesn’t look to be up to scratch just yet with limited mid time.
TP: One who could surprise in 2022, but it might be later in the year.
Francis Evans (Geel) $123,900, FWD
2021 SC ave: 27.5 (AFL), 75 (VFL) 2022 PS score: 52
Predicted average: 45-50 Job security: Low
Evans broke in for a surprise debut at the beginning of last season but was unsighted after Round 3, after being plucked from obscurity in the 2019 draft. The small forward will again be competing for a spot in the senior side, and his last three VFL games of 2021 were strong from a KFC SuperCoach perspective, posting scores of 103, 107 and 82.
DB: PASS. Recruit Tyson Stengle is probably the one who takes the small forward slot, but he could feature later on.
TP: Nah.
Sam Skinner (PA) $123,900 DEF/FWD
2021 SC Ave: 84 (SANFL) 2021 PS score: 24
Predicted average: 55-60 Job security: Low
Yes, the same Sam Skinner who averaged 44.5 points in two matches for the Lions in 2020. However, this time he comes into calculations as a swingman who thrived as an intercepting defender at SANFL level last year. Skinner finished the year averaging 103.2 points from his last seven matches in the role, with the highlight being an unbelievable 10 contested mark, 147-point display. His age profile, DEF/FWD status, mature-age scoring potential are extremely promising for SuperCoach, but it’s a difficult defence to crack into.
DB: PASS. Many KFC SuperCoach teams will have to look elsewhere, as he looks to be no chance of playing in Round 1.
TP: All eyes will be on Port’s line-up during the pre-season. Great bench pick if he gets a chance.
Nathan O’Driscoll (Frem) $123,900 DEF/MID
2021 SC Ave: 66 (WAFL) 2022 PS score: 89, DNP
Predicted average: 60-65 Job security: Low
The second-year midfielder returned to pre-season training in great shape and looks set to break in at some point in 2022. O’Driscoll attacks the ball and body ferociously, but is so clean, in similar fashion to Clayton Oliver. He won 62 per cent of his possession in a contest at WAFL League level in his draft year, but he found more footy in space during his first season with Fremantle’s reserves. O’Driscoll was the standout in Fremantle’s intra-club as an inside midfielder, putting him firmly in the frame for a Round 1 berth, before registering an imposing 89 points against West Coast in his opening practice match. But, somehow, it wasn’t enough for him to selected in Fremantle’s second game, putting his Round 1 chances in doubt.
DB: WAIT. Another big rookie blow from the Community Series. I’d probably take the risk with his DEF/MID status if he is there in Round 1, but that seems unlikely now.
TP: WAIT. Boasts a game perfect for KFC SuperCoach. If, on the off chance, he’s a surprise Round 1 starter, pick him.
Will Kelly (Coll) $123,900, DEF/FWD
2021 SC ave (AFL): 22, (VFL): 66 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 45-50 Job security: Medium
Kelly hasn’t been able to catch a break, fracturing his collarbone and arm among other injuries in the past two seasons. The swingman has impressed as a forward over across an injury-free pre-season and he could be in the mix for Collingwood’s season-opener.
DB: PASS. His DPP is a major plus – which is why his ownership has soared – but he was an emergency for Collingwood’s Community Series clash. Go for Sam De Koning instead.
TP: PASS. Don’t love his scoring potential at this point.
Patrick Walker $123,900 DEF/MID
2021 SC Ave: 79 2022 PS score: 55, DNP
Walker put himself in the mix with a solid 55-point effort against Melbourne, where he looked to be playing as an outside midfielder. The Tasmanian was taken by the Roos with the second pick in the 2020 rookie draft and had some promising games at VFL level last year, averaging 79 points, 19 disposals (at 80 per cent efficiency) and 5.3 marks as a defender. His DEF/MID status gives Walker added appeal as a cash cow.
DB: PASS. Loomed as a potential rookie POD, but wasn’t selected for their Community Series clash.
TP: PASS. Was on the rookie watchlist with DPP status, but not for Round 1.
MIDFIELD
Cooper Stephens $123,900 MID
2021 SC ave: N/A 2022 PS score: 62
Predicted average: 60-65 Job security: Low
Stephens’ start to his career has been plagued by injury, suffering an ACL injury in his draft year and struck down by an ankle blow last season. In fact, he hasn’t even played a VFL game due to his setbacks, coupled with Covid-19. But the former first round draftee has a ready-made frame and a debut looms large in 2022 off the back of a strong pre-season. There were notable midfield absentees, but Stephens ensured selectors wouldn’t forget about him with 15 touches, four tackles and 62 points against the Suns.
DB: WATCH. A 188cm inside midfielder at this price entering his third season has to be on the radar of KFC SuperCoaches. But can he break in early?
TP: CONSIDER.Has the strong inside game suited to KFC SuperCoach – it’s all about his body and coach Chris Scott now. Bench spot, if picked.
Ben Hobbs (Ess) $153,300 MID
2021 SC Ave: 127 (NAB League) 2022 PS score: 21
Predicted average: 70-75 Job security: Low
With the return of Dylan Shiel and Jye Caldwell, coupled with the rise of Darcy Parish, it’s going to be a hard midfield to break into this year. But Hobbs is ready if there’s an opening. Taking out the injury-affected Round 4 score, the strongly-built teenager averaged 29 disposals, 13 contested possessions, six clearances, five tackles and 148 KFC SuperCoach points in the NAB League last season. Put in a promising intra-club display, but this was after some prime movers had been put on ice for the second half. He showed he belongs at the level in his limited gametime against the Bulldogs, but was unused despite being selected in Essendon’s Community Series side.
DB: A KFC SuperCoach star of the future and his elite contested ball-winning means he is a chance of playing a key role later in the year, even with Essendon’s on-ball brigade looking settled.
TP: WAIT. One to watch throughout the year.
Robbie McComb (WB) $102,400 MID
2021 SC Ave: 106 (VFL) 2022 PS score: 28
Predicted average: 60-65 Job security: Low
McComb’s breakout VFL campaign saw him become the latest Western Bulldogs recruit off the Footscray mature-age production line. The 180cm midfielder averaged 106 KFC SuperCoach points, 25 disposals, five inside-50s and five tackles. At 26, McComb is ready to go and while breaking into that Bulldogs midfield is nearly impossible, there could be a spot for him as a pressure forward. And from all reports his first pre-season has been promising. Came on for the second half in the Community Series as well, where he showed he is up to the level with 12 disposals.
DB: Got to like his numbers, age and price. But it’s a long midfield queue.
TP: WATCH. Bevo loves a mature-ager from the VFL so an early-season debut is on the cards.
Josh Goater (NM) $117,300 MID
2021 SC Ave: 116 (NAB League) 2022 PS scores: 17, 9 (13)
Predicted average: 50-55 Job security: Low
An explosive 190cm draftee, Goater was deployed off halfback in North Melbourne’s practice match and had seven touches and 17 points. Not overwhelming numbers by any means. Goater finished his NAB League season as a prolific halfback for the Calder Cannons, where he posted scores of 134, 166 and 120. He had a brief appearance in North’s second practice game.
DB: Upside is there with his junior numbers, so he is one to watch out for during the season.
TP: Can he hold his spot, if he does get an early chance? I’m not sure.
Matty Roberts (Syd) $117,300 MID
2021 SC Ave: 2021 (SANFL U18s), 63 (SANFL) 2022 PS score: 3
Predicted average: 55-60 Job security: Low
Roberts was a draft slider after questions marks over his athleticism, but try these numbers on for size. Roberts averaged a Herculean 201 points, 32 disposals, 23.3 kicks, 14.3 contested possessions, 6.3 clearances and kicked five goals in his three SANFL U18s matches. The hardnosed midfielder/forward then showcased his versatility against men at SANFL level for South Adelaide, averaged 63 points, 11 touches and a tick under a goal per game alongside Jason Horne-Francis. Had a brief stint in Sydney’s practice match, winning two disposals from 13 per cent game time.
DB: The junior numbers are massive and he was able to play a role at senior level as well. But we haven’t heard much talk about him this pre-season.
TP: Purely on numbers, he’s the No. 1 KFC SuperCoach rookie. Fingers crossed he gets an early chance.
Finlay Macrae (Coll) $206,800 MID
2021 SC Ave: 38 (9 games), 97 (VFL) 2022 PS score: 44
Predicted average: 60-65 Job security: Medium
It was a frustrating first KFC SuperCoach season for Macrae, who battled for regular opportunity in Collingwood’s best 22. But he showed in spurts his elite ball-winning ability, highlighted by his 20-disposal performance in just 61 per cent game time against the Hawks in Round 21. Remind you of anyone? A consistent midfield role – one floated by Pies GM Nick Maxwell in January - for Macrae could bring a serious KFC SuperCoach spike, quickly.
DB: PASS. Was one of those who had Macrae for most of last year, and while he was frustrating at times, there were signs of gradual improvement. But other top-end priced midfield rookies are well ahead.
TP: PASS. For now. It doesn’t look like he will worth picking over the draftees.
RUCK
Charlie Comben (NM) $123,900 RUC/FWD
2021 SC ave 35 (AFL), 108 (VFL) 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 50-55 Job security: Low
Comben has been cruelled by injury in previous seasons but has had a clean run since breaking his collarbone just days after making his debut late last year. The 199cm forward/ruck was among the standouts in North Melbourne’s intra-club contest with his overhead marking in attack, and he looms as a possible key forward option for the Roos along with spearhead Nick Larkey.. The 20-year-old received a senior debut after scoring 108 points from 11 touches, four contestred marks and two goals in his sole VFL game in 2021. Comben wasn’t named for either of the Roos’ practice games due to a bad bout of gastro.
DB: WAIT. Dixon and Hayes look to be better options, but he is worth considering with as a swing if either aren’t in.
TP: WAIT. With an injury-free run, the dual-position ruck-forward could surprise a few in 2022. St Kilda has officially signed Jack Hayes but Comben is another to keep in mind.
Sam Hayes (PA) $123,900 RUC
2021 SC Ave: 100 (SANFL) 2022 PS scores: 36, 36 (36)
Predicted average: 65-70 Job security: Low
Hayes finished the SANFL season strongly last year, recording eight scores of 99 or more in his last 11 matches, including four 120-plus totals. Entering his fourth season, the ruckman is ready in the wings to make his debut and the departure of Peter Ladhams helps his cause. One of the better cheap ruck bench options, but Scott Lycett still holds the ruck mantle at the Power.
DB: CONSIDER. Seems unlikely the Power will play both Hayes and Lycett. We have a couple of cheap RUC/FWDs, but he has good scoring potential if you’re willing to wait until he gets a run.
TP: WAIT. Hayes is likely to make money at some stage in 2022, but Port has all but confirmed that won’t be in Round 1.
Jed McEntee (PA) $123,900 FWD/MID
2021 SC ave 84 (SANFL), 3 (AFL) 2022 PS score: DNP, 58
Predicted average: 50-55 Job security: Medium
McEntee has bolted into Round 1 calculations after an encouraging performance in the Community Series, finishing with 13 disposals, a goal and 58 points. The 21-year-old, snapped up by the Power in the mid-seasond draft last year, shapes as a possible replacement for the injured Orazio Fantasia up forward. In the SANFL last year, McEntee averaged 16.8 disposals, 5.5 tackles and 84 points. He made a very brief debut last year as the medi-sub, scoring the three points.
DB: BUY. A cheaper bench option that can give us flexibility as a FWD/MID. McEntee could get a solid run in the seniors with Fantasia still needing to build fitness following his knee injury.
TP: CONSIDER. The price is good, as is the dual-position status, in a shallow rookie pool. And could get a few early games with Fantasia out, and Gray in doubt. Bench spot.
DOWNGRADE OPTIONS - DO NOT START
*Some may be possible loophole options
BRISBANE
Mitch Cox (Brisbane) $102,400 DEF/MID
2021 SC ave (VFL): 93 2022 PS scores: DNP
Predicted average: 55-60
On the radar of several clubs last year at draft time last year, Cox earned a spot on Brisbane’s list a week out from Round 1. The explosive 24-year-old utility had a breakout campaign with Frankston in 2021, tallying 21.9 disposals, 6.4 score involvements and 93 points per game. Cox is capable of playing all over the ground, which could help his case of being elevated to Brisbane’s list.
DB: Has potential as a scorer, posting totals of 146 and 152 last year, but breaking into that Lions side may be tough. But with DPP looming, he could offer flexibility as a floating donut who could be called on eventually.
Ely Smith $123,900 FWD/MID
2021 SC Ave: 69 (VFL) 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 55-60
The 21-year-old spent much of the summer in KFC SuperCoach teams last year before the first of two syndesmosis injuries ruined his chances of an early-season debut. Smith, who was drafted as an inside bull before impressing as running midfielder early in 2021, played just four matches for the year – all in the VFL and none consecutive. But he’s fit and played on-ball in Brisbane’s recent match-sim – albeit in the B team.
DB: No sight of Smith during the pre-season. Starting to get on Will Gould levels of obscurity.
TP: All over him last year before injury, but it appears a few have gone past him. And then there’s Cam Rayner’s return.
CARLTON
Jesse Motlop $117,300 FWD
2021 SC Ave: 53 (WAFL), 71 (U18 Champs) 2022 PS scores: 47, DNP
Predicted average: 45-50
Small-forwards are never high on the watchlist for KFC SuperCoaches, but, after booting nine goals in eight WAFL matches last year, Motlop looks ready to into a Blues line-up in need of a sublimely skilled goal-kicker. He might not post big numbers if does play, but – at this point – there aren’t many other forward bench options around at the price. The son of Power and Roos goalkicker Daniel slotted two goals in Carlton’s intra-club, with footy boss Greg Williams declaring after the eye-catching display that Motlop is a chance for an early-season debut.
DB: Showed he can be a consistent goalkicker last year against men in the WAFL. Don’t expect big scores, but he could find a place in the Blues line-up later in the year.
TP: An early bench spot candidate, depending on what other rookie forwards pop up.
COLLINGWOOD
Charlie Dean $102,400 DEF
2021 SC Ave: 85 (VFL)
Predicted average: 55-60
A mature-age intercept defender, who won the Fothergill-Round-Mitchell Medal as the VFL’s best young player? Now that’s KFC SuperCoach gold as it was with Docker Luke Ryan in 2017. The ready-made Dean averaged eight intercepts and 85 KFC SuperCoach points per game for Williamstown and is a rookie lock if he can squeeze in for Round 1. Injuries to defenders Jordan Roughead (returning Round 5) and Jeremy Howe pointed to a debut, until Collingwood’s backline curse struck Dean as well.
DB: AVOID. Was a lock until an untimely ankle injury, which will see sideline him for 6-8 weeks. Look elsewhere.
TP: His own injury has gotten in the way. Cross him off your list.
Reef McInnes $123,900 MID
2021 SC Ave: 61 (VFL) 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 55-60
Maxwell also confirmed Collingwood wants to expose McInnes in the midfield in 2022. The big-bodied 194cm on-baller didn’t feature at senior level in his debut season but showed some great signs in the VFL. McInness, who lacks some polish by foot, tallied 19 disposals, 11 tackles and 106 points in Round 3 before finishing the year with 17 disposals, 10 contested possessions and nine clearances in his final game.
DB: Has the makings of a strong KFC SuperCoach scorer, but where will he play once he receives a debut?
TP: How many kids can the Pies rotate through the midfield? Not in my side yet but he does boast a KFC SuperCoach-friendly game style.
Harvey Harrison $117,300 MID
2021 SC ave (SANFL U18): 106 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 45-50
Harrison has been a surprise packet in his first pre-season at Collingwood, with the South Australian draftee putting in a promising return in the club’s trial match. The speedster, who recorded the fastest 20m sprint time of any potential draftee in 2021, won eight disposals and kicked two goals, with the club website noting that he is in a “great position to have a strong 2022”. In his final junior game last season, Harrison registered a whopping 34 disposals, 16 contested possessions, 10 clearances and 163 KFC SuperCoach points.
DB: More encouraging form could see a spot open up for him in the forward line with those wheels. Looks to be better mid options around his price, though.
TP: Some big numbers over here in the SANFL, but it might be one to look at later in the season.
ESSENDON
Tex Wanganeen $102,400 FWD
2021 SC Ave: N/A 2022 PS score: 47, DNP
Predicted average: 50-55
A quarter was all it took for Wanganeen to rubber stump a rookie spot alongside Martin in the Bombers’ first practice match. With football talent in his blood, the son of Gavin Wanganeen dazzled with two eye-catching goals to spark his side, finishing with 47 KFC SuperCoach points. A largely unknown quantity from a fantasy perspective, Wanganeen has zero junior games recorded by Champion Data, with his last two seasons being cruelled by injury and Covid-19.
DB: Has some forward magic that the Bombers are crying out for. May not score as well Martin, but hard to ignore at the price if he’s in. But that probably won’t be Round 1.
TP: Big last quarter in the practice match, but scoring could be volatile if he gets a chance.
Garrett McDonagh $117,300 DEF
2021 SC Ave: 84 (VFL) 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 60-65
You don’t pick 25-year-olds from the VFL to develop them. And Bombers list boss Adrian Dodoro confirmed just that post-draft, declaring the long-kicking defender “could possible play very early on in the piece”. McDonagh, a terrific runner who is a great ball user by foot, averaged 21 disposals, five intercepts, and five rebound-50s in the VFL last season.
DB: Doesn’t look like the superboot will be getting a run in Round 1.
TP: Pick him if Ben Rutten does.
FREMANTLE
Neil Erasmus $166,800 MID
2021 SC Ave: 164 (WAFL Colts) 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 60-65
Injury interrupted his draft year but in the four WAFL Colts games he did play, Erasmus posted KFC SuperCoach scores of 204, 141, 161 and 149. As a midfielder, he averaged 28 disposals, 16 contested possessions, eight marks, seven intercepts and two score assists. A game earlier, in the Colts grand final of 2020, Erasmus booted four goals on his way to 161 points as a bottom-ager, playing as a forward. And Erasmus, who is a different-sized midfielder to what the Dockers have, is a chance of being blooded early after a strong pre-season. He put in an eye-catching intra-club performance where he won plenty of the ball as a midfielder.
DB: PASS. A bit of Jack Steele about this youngster, who can take overhead marks and have an impact up forward. Looms as Nat Fyfe’s replacement in time, and he is another midfielder to watch throughout the year.
TP: Nat Fyfe pushing forward, Adam Cerra out – could there be room for Erasmus early this year? His form on the track looks to have put him in a good spot.
Matthew Johnson $117,300 MID
2021 SC Ave: 119 (WAFL Colts), 108 (Under 18 champs) 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 60-65
With senior experience and class on the outside, Johnson is another Dockers draftee a chance to have an impact in his debut season. It might not be early, given the 192cm teenager was sidelined by a fractured foot in late January, but the on-baller, who has been a great KFC SuperCoach at every level, could feature on a wing or at half-forward, as he did in the WAFL
DB: A potential top-10 pick, Johnson could be an attractive option later in the season, after some impressive numbers during the WAFL Reserves finals in 2021.
TP: Versatility is likely to help him, but looks to be one we might see later in the year.
Tyler Keitel FWD
2021 SC ave: 105 (WAFL)
* train-on player who wasn’t signed through SPP
Like Hayes, Keitel has years of KFC SuperCoach pedigree at state league level – no mean feat for a 196cm key forward. Keitel has averaged 105, 107, and 104 across the past three WAFL seasons and was the competition’s leading goalkicker last year, booting 70 goals in 2021. The 26-year-old had been training with West Coast, but is now crossed to Fremantle as he hunts a list spot.
DB: Key forwards are generally a pass in KFC SuperCoach, but his scoring, age and price could be inviting if he is picked up in the mid-season draft.
GEELONG
Mitchell Knevitt $117,300 MID
2021 SC Ave: 122 (NAB League) 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 60-65
Spots in the Cats midfield are hard to come by – just ask Charlie Constable – but Knevitt’s has the profile of a potential SuperCoach beast. A hulking 193cm inside midfielder with a superb speed-endurance mix, Knevitt averaged 122 points across nine matches in the NAB League, culminating in totals of 151, 136 and 165 to finish the season. Keep an eye on his progress.
DB: Big fan of Knevitt during his draft year, and I will be tempted to throw him in my side if there’s even a mention of him this pre-season. In saying that, other young midfielders are probably ahead of him.
TP: Has plenty of KFC SuperCoach weapons but might take a little longer to come on.
James Willis $123,900 MID
2021 SC ave: 120 (SANFL U18)
Predicted average: 50-55
Willis posted some monster scores in the SANFL U18s last year, amassing scores of 180, 165 and 203 in his last five matches. It saw him average 120 KFC SuperCoach points per game with his inside ball-winning, forward craft and defensive attributes standing out. News Corp’s pre-season intel suggests Willis is the most likely Cats draftee to debut, with the Cat tipped to be used in an attacking role to start his career.
DB: Job security is likely to be the principle concern in that Cats side if he gets a run.
TP: Chris Scott loves a first-year role player, and Willis could play as a pressure forward, depsite posting big midfield numbers as a junior. Monitor through the year.
GOLD COAST
Elijah Hollands $123.900 FWD/MID
2021 SC Ave: 72 (VFL) 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 65-70
The pick 7 from the 2020 draft hasn’t played a senior game but he’s on track to feature early in 2022 after an impressive finish to his debut season at VFL level. After working his way back from an ACL tear, Hollands, an explosive 188cm midfielder who can play forward, tallied 27 disposals, 11 contested possessions, five clearances and 112 KFC SuperCoach points in his third and final game for the year. There were whispers about a possible injury during the pre-season before he was left out of the Suns’ first practice game, playing for the reserves instead. And he didn’t feature in their second match either…
DB: AVOID. A pre-season lock now looks to be a long shot. Put a line through him.
TP: I’d said lock it up. That was before he played in neither practice game. Hmmm.
Charlie Constable $213,400 MID
2021 SC Ave: 48 (3 games), 120 (VFL) 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 80-85
The Suns also have big-bodied midfielder Constable to help fill the Greenwood void after the former Cat was given a lifeline in the national draft. Numbers have never been a problem for Constable, opportunity – and maybe what he does without the ball – has. He averaged 23 disposals and 84 points in the first six games of his career in 2019, but Constable has played just six AFL games since. The 22-year-old finished his time at the Cats with scores of 175, 132 and 146 before the VFL season was called off in 2021. But he was unsighted for the Suns in both practice matches after being hampered by an adductor injury.
DB: A possible in-season downgrade if he has a centre-bounce role.
TP: Has posted impressive KFC SuperCoach numbers, at all levels, when given consistent opportunity.
Bodhi Uwland $102,400 DEF/MID
2021 SC Ave: 141 (NAB League), 63 (VFL) 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 50-55
Uwland is ready to go after mixing it with the bigger bodies at VFL and QAFL level in 2021. Added to the Suns list via the club’s pre-draft concessions, the Academy gun averaged 63 points in six VFL matches, with his 19-disposal, 10-intercept, 112-point performance against Sydney the highlight. And the teenager also posted KFC SuperCoach scores of 151 and 120 in his two NAB League appearances.
DB: CONSIDER. Only as a loophole, as he looks a fair way out.
TP: Ready to go, and would be a great dual-position bench option if there’s a spot for him in Round 1.
James Tsitas $102,400 MID
2021 SC Ave: 122 (SANFL) 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 75-80
The 26-year-old claimed the Suns’ final list spot in February after impressing over summer and winning the Magarey Medal in the SANFL - an award he shared with Bryce Gibbs - last year. Including finals, Tsitas averaged 29 disposals, 11 contested possessions, six tackles and 122 points in 2021 and posted KFC SuperCoach tons in 17 of his 21 games. In his 12 matches of the year, as the Eagles stormed to back-to-back flags, the ball magnet averaged a huge 131 points per game.
DB: AVOID. His numbers and age profile were enticing, but he was a no-show in both of Gold Coast’s practice games. It means he is close to no chance for Round 1.
TP: He might not be the on-field option KFC SuperCoaches were hoping for when he signed. But he’ll be in our sides at some point.
GWS
Finn Callaghan $198,300 MID
2021 SC Ave: 111 (NAB League)
Predicted average: 60-65
The rapid development of his inside game saw Callaghan bolt into the top three of last year’s draft. But we could see his speed, damaging left-foot and agility used on the outside early on in his career, given the Giants’ current midfield mix. Callaghan scored 105, 140, 132 and 138 in the his final four NAB League games but sits down the rookie pecking order, given his high price-tag - at this stage, anyway.
DB: A wing role awaits Callaghan early in his career, which probably rules him out at the price. Expect Callaghan to feature heavily in KFC SuperCoach conversations in the near future.
TP: Too many others around the price this year - but remember the name.
HAWTHORN
Seamus Mitchell $123,900 FWD
2021 SC Ave: 36 (VFL) 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 45-50
Mitchell drew comparisons to Zac Williams in his draft year for his speed, which was on show in Hawthorn’s opening practice game. The lightning quick forward booted a soccer goal off the deck after dashing towards the ball in a solid display up forward – where he played in the stronger Hawks line-up across the six periods. Mitchell was restricted to two VFL matches in his first season due to knee and ankle injuries last year but should break in at some stage this year.
DB: One who could present as an option, but a young small forward in a rebuilding team doesn’t bode too well for SuperCoach.
TP: Not to start with.
Sam Butler $117,300 FWD/MID
2021 SC Ave: 98 (NAB League) 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 50-55
We saw small forward Tyler Brockman receive early opportunities last year and Butler, the brother of St Kilda goalsneak Dan, could be a similar case. The forward/midfielder has elite all-round athletic traits, which can see him push for selection early doors. He averaged a promising 98 points per game at NAB League level splitting his time between the forward 50 and the midfield, but will most likely start his career in attack.
DB: Has the athletic profile to break in, and Hawthorn will look to young small forwards at some stage. May be one for later in the season.
TP: One to keep an eye on, but I’m not expecting much early.
MELBOURNE
Jacob van Rooyen $126,300 DEF/FWD
2021 SC Ave: 132 (WAFLC), 90 (U18 Champs) 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 45-50
Looking for cheapies at the Demons is like trying to find a needle in a haystack, but van Rooyen shapes as the best of them. The key-position swingman thrived at both ends last year, averaging a whopping 132 points and kicked 38 goals across nine WAFL Colts matches before impressing down back at national level, but he has been training as a forward since joining the Dees. Don’t expect those kind of numbers from him at the top level, but he has the strength and power to put his hand up this year.
DB: Tough for any key position to force their way into that stacked line-up. His DPP status makes him interesting if he does enter the frame, though.
TP: If a spot opens up, van Rooyen is ready to play and could prove very handy in KFC SuperCoach. A big ‘if’, though.
RICHMOND
Tyler Sonsie $117,300 MID
2021 SC Ave: 104 (NAB League), 64 (VFL)
Predicted average: 55-60
Sonsie was another surprise slider on draft night, mostly due to being cruelled by injury, but his exceptional VFL debut last year makes him a player of interest in SuperCoach. The classy midfielder finished with 24 disposals, two goals and 64 points for Box Hill, showing he has the talent to perform against men. He showed promise in Richmond’s intra-club and was one of the Tigers’ best in the VFL last weekend, suggesting he may be closer to a debut than first thought.
DB: Might be a better chance later in the season if he has a clean run with injury.
TP: Not yet.
ST KILDA
Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera $162,300 DEF/MID
2021 SC Ave: 83 (SANFLR), 61 (SANFL) 2022 PS scores: DNP, 28
Predicted average: 50-55
Picked up by a side that lacks polished distributors, Wanganeen-Milera should see action this year as the best kick of the 2021 draft class. The skilful wingman averaged 83 SuperCoach points and 15 touches across 13 games for Glenelg, with his kicking weapon boding well for his scoring. And he has cash cow in his blood, as the son of former St Kilda KFC SuperCoach cheapie Terry Milera. Scored 28 points from 33 per cent time on ground in the second practice match after coming in the final term.
DB: He will probably score a bit better than his father with that laser-like kick. May be a better chance for a debut later in the year.
TP: The Saints need his kicking and Wanganeen-Milera more than held his own at senior level in the SANFL last year, despite his size. After an interrupted pre-season, he looms as a downgrade option.
SYDNEY
Will Gould $123,900 DEF
2021 SC Ave: 83 (VFL) Predicted average: 60-65
Another pre-season of Gould-hype begins. Is the mythical defender on the cusp of a long-awaited debut? If the talk out of Sydney is to be believed, Gould has been catching the eye on the track – but we’ve been fooled before. The loss of Jordan Dawson means there is a spot up for grabs in defence, and his VFL numbers last season were promising, averaging 83 points with two 120-plus totals. But of course, he didn’t play in either practice match.
DB: AVOID. He has sucked us in yet again. Now it’s time to offload — again.
TP: HORSE. PLEASE.
WEST COAST
Greg Clark $117,300 MID
2021 SC Ave: 121 (WAFL) 2021 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 75-80
Mature age pick-ups are KFC SuperCoach gold and Clark registered some mouth-watering numbers in the WAFL last season for Subiaco. The 24-year-old averaged 27.5 disposals, 7.3 tackles 4.9 clearances and 121 points – this is including an injury affected score of 1. Clark, a 193cm goalkicking midfielder, generated scores of 135, 140 and 181 in the WAFL finals series – the last of those coming in Subiaco’s grand final win, where he finished with 25 disposals, 14 tackles, six clearances and two goals. However, we will have to wait until later in the season to pick him after the mature-ager was struck down by an AC joint injury that will sideline him for the early rounds of the season.
DB: Somebody say KFC (SuperCoach mid-season downgrade)?
TP: When he’s out there, you pick him. Simple.
Campbell Chesser $148,800 DEF/MID
2021 SC Ave: 98 (NAB League) 2022 PS score: 2
Predicted average: 60-65
Better known for his oversized West Coast jumper that he received on draft night than his footballing ability, Chesser is an explosive defender/midfielder who is capable of seeing senior action this year. Chesser battled through injuries in 2021, averaging 18.3 disposals and 98 KFC SuperCoach points, but he was in the Eagles’ sights on draft night as he brings what the Eagles lack: outside speed. However, Chesser suffered bone and ligament damage to his foot in the opening minutes of the Eagles’ practice game, which will him until mid-season.
DB: Was in my team before his cruel blow. Cross him off your list — for now.
TP: The Eagles also need some line-breaking run on the outside – and Chesser is the man. But we’ll have to wait until mid-season.
Tom Joyce (West Coast) $123,900 MID
2021 SC ave: 108 (VFL) 2022 PS scores: 56
Predicted average: 60-65
Joyce has won a late spot on the Eagles list and the former Lion, who was delisted at the end of 2021, averaged 28.7 disposals, 6.3 clearances and 108 KFC SuperCoach points from his seven VFL matches last year. Injury and a lack of state-league footy hurt his chances of contending at the Lions, but he could be a ready-made midfield option if he gets the chancs. That might come as soon as Round 1 after he scored 56 points in the AAMI Series.
DB: As soon as he entered the game as a potential M11 option, he was sighted in a moonboot after an ankle injury. The Eagles injury curse strikes again.
WESTERN BULLDOGS
Arthur Jones $117,300 DEF/MID
2021 SC Ave: 71 (U18 Champs) 2022 PS score: 36, DNP
Predicted average: 50-55
Jones has come on in leaps and bounds since bolting onto the draft scene late last year with an impressive national carnival for Western Australia. Playing on a wing in the Bulldogs’ practice game, Jones proved he has some tricks with his elite agility and speed, tallying 10 disposals, three marks and 36 points in a half of gametime. Initially viewed as a development player, Jones showed he is capable of playing senior footy this year – and the fact he was even in the Bulldogs’ talent-rich squad for the match speaks is telling.
DB: Would be very helpful with his DEF/MID status. Round 1 may be a stretch, but he could be worth picking if his job security increases.
TP: Great to see him feature in the practice match, but I don’t think I’ll pick him, even if he’s a surprise Round 1 debutant.
Charlie Parker $102,400 FWD/MID
2021 SC Ave: 68 (SANFL) 2022 PS score: DNP
Predicted average: 55-60
Parker joined McComb at the Bulldogs via the rookie draft, with the former cricketer rising from the SANFL reserves to the AFL in a matter of months. The 24-year-old, who averaging 14 disposals and 68 points in his nine SANFL games for Sturt last year, has turned heads with his endurance during his first pre-season at the kennel. His dual position status, price and age profile suggests he is one to watch.
DB: A DPP bench placeholder early in the pre-season, but other $102k rookies will be there in Round 1 so pick them instead.
TP: They drafted Parker for his run and long kicking and he’s a chance to feature on a wing at some point.
More Coverage
Originally published as KFC SuperCoach AFL 2022 Rookie Bible: The cheapies you must consider
Join the conversation
Five moves that won me $50,000 in SuperCoach
The 20-year-old winner of SuperCoach AFL 2024 reveals the tactics that led him to the game’s top prize, beating out more than 180,000 players across the country.
Read more
SuperCoach wrap: Norm-worthy stars and grand final flops
Who stood up on the biggest SuperCoach stage and who disappointed when it counted most? Check out round 24’s heroes and villains – and some hot tips for 2025.
Read more