NewsBite

LIVE
Live

Live blog: Commission of Inquiry updates, reactions

It is a momentous day in Tasmanian politics as the Commission of Inquiry into the Tasmanian Government’s responses to Child Sexual Abuse in Institutional Settings final report and recommendations are publicly released. Follow on live here.

Commission of Inquiry being tabled in parliament, Premier Jeremy Rockliff. Picture: Chris Kidd
Commission of Inquiry being tabled in parliament, Premier Jeremy Rockliff. Picture: Chris Kidd

Tuesday is a momentous and difficult day in Tasmanian politics, as the Commission of Inquiry into the Tasmanian Government’s responses to Child Sexual Abuse in Institutional Settings final report and recommendations are released to the public.

Senior Mercury reporters Sue Bailey, David Killick and Amber Wilson are reporting from Parliament House and elsewhere. Follow our live blog below for up-to-date information.

Live Updates

'Failed by the system': Rockliff, White respond to final report

The tabling of the Commission of Inquiry’s final report is a dark day in the state’s history but the government is steadfastly committed to ensuring a better future for Tasmania’s children, Premier Jeremy Rockliff has told parliament.

Shortly after tabling the report in the House of Assembly on Tuesday, Mr Rockliff repeated his apology to those who had suffered sexual abuse while in state care or state institutions.

He thanked those who gave evidence and reaffirmed government’s promise to implement every one of the Commission’s 191 recommendations.

“Victim-survivors have been abused by the very people who were supposed to care for them, and they were failed by the system that is meant to protect them,” he said.

“It is time for change; time to reflect on some of the most painful moments in our state’s history; and time to build a culture in our institutions that will ensure it is not repeated.”

Commission of Inquiry being tabled in parliament, Premier Jeremy Rockliff. Picture: Chris Kidd
Commission of Inquiry being tabled in parliament, Premier Jeremy Rockliff. Picture: Chris Kidd


During his address, which was watched by victim-survivors in a packed public gallery, Mr Rockliff announced that Pontville, in the state’s South, was the preferred site for the state’s new youth detention centre.

“We acknowledge the Commission’s call to close the Ashley Youth Detention Centre as soon as possible,” he said.

“We all want the same thing. If there was any capacity to close it now, we would. I would not hesitate.”

Mr Rockliff said the government had not redacted any part of the report.

“Today I confirm the only omissions made to the Commission’s Final Report are those requested by the Commission,” he said.

And the Premier said the government was “steadfast in our commitment to keep Tasmanian children and young people safe”.

“We are deeply aware of the significant responsibility we have to the Tasmanian community and to those who have experienced trauma and abuse, who are seeking justice, healing and lasting change that will prevent the recurrence of such profoundly distressing events,” he told parliament.

"Responding to the recommendations of the Commission will require widespread and fundamental change across Tasmanian Government agencies and systems.
“We will leave no stone unturned to ensure our children and young people are safe and protected now and into the future.”

Labor leader Rebecca White said the tabling was a “watershed moment" for the state.

Commission of Inquiry being tabled in parliament, Labor leader Rebecca White. Picture: Chris Kidd
Commission of Inquiry being tabled in parliament, Labor leader Rebecca White. Picture: Chris Kidd


“It is hard to imagine a greater betrayal than entrusting your child to a hospital or school where care and protection should be the highest priority only to have your child preyed upon by a monster, their innocence stolen, their trust and the trust of their families betrayed their childhoods lost to a lifetime of trauma, hurt, anger and pain," she said.

"And all of this has been made so much worse because in some cases the people who could have protected them should have protected them instead chose to look the other way."

She pledged Labor would support the government to enact the recommendations in the report.

“That is the very least our children and young people can expect – and we fully support the Commission of Inquiry’s recommendations and will work with the government to achieve their full implementation,” she said.

“Our children are our future – and it is up to us to protect them and keep them safe… and ensure this never happens again.”

Commission of Inquiry final report: The key recommendations

The long-running inquiry into child sexual abuse in Tasmanian government institutions has found grave failings in multiple government agencies.

The final report of the Commission of Inquiry into the Tasmanian Government’s responses to Child Sexual Abuse in Institutional Settings has been tabled in state parliament by Premier Jeremy Rockliff.

It has recommended the immediate closure of the Ashley Youth Detention Centre, the outsourcing of out-of-home care to non-government agencies, a new Commission for Children and Young People and a ban on strip searches for young people in custody.

Other key recommendations include:

  • The Department for Education, Children and Young People should introduce and fund a mandatory child sexual abuse prevention curriculum as part of the mandatory respectful behaviours curriculum from early learning programs to Year 12.
  • The Department for Education, Children and Young People should ensure all children in care, including those on guardianship orders until age 18, have a case manager [and] set a maximum case load for Child Safety Officers.
  • The Department for Education, Children and Young People should introduce body scanner technology at Ashley Youth Detention Centre and include such technology in any facility designed to replace the Centre.

Read more on this story here.

How the child sexual abuse commission of inquiry came to be

It wasn’t long ago that children were told they should be seen, and not heard.

And that’s precisely what happened for a very long time – children simply were never heard.

The kids at Ashley Youth Detention Centre weren’t heard.

Nor were the victims of serial paedophile, Launceston General Hospital children’s nurse James Geoffrey Griffin.

Tasmanian and Launceston General Hospital James (Jim) Geoffrey Griffin. SOURCE: SUPPLIED
Tasmanian and Launceston General Hospital James (Jim) Geoffrey Griffin. SOURCE: SUPPLIED


Kids in Tasmania’s out-of-home care system weren’t heard either, and nor were so many children enrolled in state schools.

The Commission of Inquiry into the Tasmanian Government’s Responses to Child Sexual Abuse in Institutional Settings came about following years of abuse, negligence, and failure to act.

It has come about in an era where, globally, attitudes are finally changing about child sexual abuse, and the responsibility we all share in ending it.

The inquiry has come following a decade in which the most powerful people in the world, from Catholic priests to Hollywood superstars and BBC heroes, have finally started to be held accountable for their crimes.

But while watershed moments were happening across the world – things moved slowly in Tasmania, like they always have.

It’s an island, inoculated from the swift changes of modernity that sweep other parts of the globe and the mainland states.

The Bass Strait has long kept the state “protected” from oversight, transparency and accountability.

Archaic, old ways of doing things – and a penal colony hangover – still haunt Tasmania to this day.

Yet, change was on the horizon for Tasmania after the Catholic and Anglican churches were forced to begin compensating child sexual abuse victims on mainland Australia.

The federal child sexual abuse royal commission also made inroads. Tasmania was not immune from its microscope.

Then, a groundswell began on a more local level – led by fearless warriors like Grace Tame, who managed to get laws changed that have long protected paedophiles, and not their victims.

Other brave souls, survivors like Steve Fisher, also took action to finally get a voice for the voiceless – and set up organisations that could help others who’d also been silenced for so long.

The situation at Ashley Youth Detention Centre became untenable. The Tasmanian government could no longer ignore the dozens of headlines about child rape, solitary confinement and staff bashings of children.

Alysha, a former Ashley worker, also came forward as a key whistleblower on the terrible sexual harassment she suffered there – and the abuse of children she witnessed there – bringing the government to its knees.

Meanwhile, hundreds of former detainees announced they were planning to sue the government for failure to protect them – as part of Tasmania’s first-ever class action.

The pressure on the government mounted to excruciating levels with a podcast self-funded by Sydney journalist, Camille Bianchi.

The Nurse showed the disgraceful ways Griffin, a Launceston General Hospital nurse who molested children on paediatric ward 4K for 18 years, was mishandled by a broken system.

Bianchi’s fearless storytelling finally gave a number of Griffin’s many victims a voice – and the effects were mammoth.

Suddenly, Tasmania’s serious failures to protect kids was under the national spotlight.

Even the Mercury newspaper has played a part, bringing to light the government’s habit of moving paedophile teachers from school-to-school, and even promoting them, whenever allegations began to pile up around them.

The Mercury also revealed a teacher remained employed with the state education system 30 years after he was let go for sexually abusing a Grade 9 student and getting her pregnant.

As a result of that story, the man was jailed for four years.

Ultimately, then-Premier Peter Gutwein had little choice in November 2020 but to announce an official, independent inquiry would be held into this culture of repeated failures.

It was time for Tasmania to play catch-up. It was time to finally end the blame-shifting, and instead start the listening.

'If I could close Ashley tomorrow, I would': Rockliff

The Tasmanian Government remains committed to the closure of Ashley Youth Detention Centre, with Premier Jeremy Rockliff telling Parliament of his desire "to close it tomorrow".

Question time in the Tasmanian parliament, Premier Jeremy Rockliff. Picture: Chris Kidd
Question time in the Tasmanian parliament, Premier Jeremy Rockliff. Picture: Chris Kidd


In Question Time on Tuesday, Opposition Leader Rebecca White told the Premier that two of the Commission of Inquiry's commissioners had, in their closing remarks, expressed concern about the timetable for closing the controversial facility.

Ms White asked the Premier for an update on when the government would finally close the centre.

"We understand the calls for closing the Ashley Youth Detention Centre sooner, and we all want the same thing," the Premier responded. 

"If I could, I would close it tomorrow. 

"But we need to ensure that while Ashley remains open that young people are safe and well in custody.

"We have looked more broadly than the initial announcement to close Ashley, to now have reform of the whole youth justice system which includes raising the minimum age of detention to 14 years.

"We want to progress our plan to close Ashley, and at the same time transition to new contemporary, therapeutic facilities and models of care. 

"This will ensure that we have fewer young people in detention, and more young people catered for through a range of facilities and services that meet their needs."

The Premier said the Government had budgeted $50m to support the establishment of post-Ashley facilities, including a detention and remand centre in the state's South, one assisted bail facility in each of the North and South of the State, and two supported residential facilities located at either end of the state.

Reporting by Duncan Abey.

‘Brave, extraordinary man’: Abuse survivor praised ahead of report

Steve Fisher, the founder of Beyond Abuse, believes it’s vital that the State Government be given time to implement the recommendations of the Commission of Inquiry report being tabled in State Parliament this morning.

Former Labor Premier David Bartlett has paid tribute to Mr Fisher on social media.

“I think he is an extraordinary man who we all owe a debt of gratitude," Mr Bartlett said.

“I wish I had done more to support him 20 years ago.

“He has been brave, tireless and selfless in his efforts for justice.”

It is 20 years since Mr Fisher won a court battle to become the first Tasmanian to identify himself as a victim-survivor of child sexual abuse.

Friday 12th May 2023. At the Supreme Court of Tasmania. CEO of Beyond Abuse Steve Fisher. Picture: Linda Higginson
Friday 12th May 2023. At the Supreme Court of Tasmania. CEO of Beyond Abuse Steve Fisher. Picture: Linda Higginson


As a teenager, he was abused by Anglican priest Garth Hawkins who was jailed for abusing Mr Fisher and six other boys between 1974 and 1984.

Mr Fisher told the Mercury on Tuesday morning he was feeling “anxious” about the tabling of the report and expecting more victim survivors to seek help from Beyond Abuse.

“It’s a massive report and we must give the government time to come up with a game plan and to digest it and to implement the 191 recommendations,” he said.

“We’re funded by the government to provide more peer support this year and already we’ve seen a 50 per cent increase since the commission from people wanting help."

For the social worker the abuse has had a “horrendous” impact on his life.

He founded Beyond Abuse 20 years ago to help others and trained as a social worker completing his studies in 2006.

“Many times I’ve thought ‘I can’t do this anymore’ but then I think of the other people who are in a worse state than me,” he said.

When he returned from a stint working on Nauru he was assaulted by a client and no longer is able to work as a social worker or peer counsellor.

“I was assaulted by a client and it brought up the past," he said.

“I was bashed and had flashbacks so the doctor said not to do any more peer support.

“I couldn’t make decisions like I used to.

“That was horrendous because I loved doing what I was doing but now I have a great team at Beyond Abuse.”

Mr Fisher also has trouble in relationships but his been with his wife Wanny for eight years.

“I’ve had two failed marriages, I would have loved children and we’re checking to see if that’s possible. Wanny’s clock is ticking," he said.

“I think in the past I was too scared to have children and I never really knew why.

“It’s incredible I’ve been with Wanny for so long and I’d like to make a little one of her because she’s such a beautiful soul.”

Original URL: https://www.themercury.com.au/news/tasmania/live-blog-commission-of-inquiry-updates-reactions/live-coverage/17ea7c68ef154282cc01da16ef7b2168