Solicitors for developer Barry Bernoth say residents group’s appeal is ‘doomed to fail’
An appeal over the approval of a retirement facility and set of townhouses in Middle Ridge is heating up, with lawyers for the developer saying the case is ‘doomed to fail’.
Development
Don't miss out on the headlines from Development. Followed categories will be added to My News.
Lawyers for property developer Barry Bernoth say the case put forward by a group of Middle Ridge residents is “embarrassing” and “doomed to fail”.
The Large Street Trust, representing a group of Middle Ridge residents, has lodged an appeal against a Toowoomba Regional Council approval of a 51-unit retirement facility and a 43-unit townhouse development in Middle Ridge, next to the heritage-listed Gabbinbar Homestead property.
Toowoomba developer Barry Bernoth and retirement village operator Oak Tree Group are the two proponents of the development.
Documents lodged earlier with the Planning and Environment Court in Maroochydoore show the trust is appealing against the development, seeking a declaration the council’s approval is “invalid, and of no legal effect”.
Responding to the Large Street Trust’s statement of facts filed earlier this year, lawyers for Mr Bernoth claimed the trust’s own arguments meant “it was open to the assessment manager to conclude that the proposed development complies with the code”.
“The consequence of that compliance, as you will no doubt remember, is that the assessment manager was required to approve the development application.”
Mr Bernoth’s solicitors said it followed that the trust’s case, “as it is presently cast, is doomed to fail”.
“Accordingly, because the pleadings, which represent your client’s second opportunity at articulating its case, are embarrassing and fail to fundamentally understand the task undertaken by the assessment manager, our client invites you to withdraw its proceedings.”
The District Court ordered on January 22 that on or before February 26, the parties are to participate in a chaired without prejudice conference.
The matter has been listed for review on March 5.
City’s Olympic dream still alive as Janetzki makes call on key project
Toowoomba’s dream of hosting events at the Olympics is still alive — just — after new treasurer David Janetzki revealed a major project was part of the LNP’s 100-day review.
Booming small town’s major housing estate reaches key stage
A Toowoomba region township that has boomed since Covid-19 is set for even more housing following an application to council.
Mayor urges LNP to include Toowoomba in 100-day Olympics review
With the new LNP government reviewing every venue for the 2032 Olympics, Toowoomba mayor Geoff McDonald has urged the party to make good on a pre-election pledge around one site.
LNP’s potential first pumped hydro project earmarked
After the scrapping of the bloated Pioneer-Burdekin pumped hydro scheme, an ongoing purchase of a different project has suggested what the LNP will use to start replacing it:
Calls for city to be included in latest koala mapping
Environmental groups are pushing for the council to tighten protections and update koala habitat maps to prevent gaps and loopholes in the planning scheme from being exploited.
‘Snail’s pace’: Why signs were pulled down at future burger chain site
The removal of branded signage around the site of a future fast food restaurant in Toowoomba has fuelled speculation the dream is dead. Now the man responsible for building it has set the record straight: