UK Indian Rishi Sunak will be ‘judged on results, not colour’

For many UK South Asians, Rishi Sunak’s ascent provoked as much debate about his economic credo as about the colour of his skin.

The ascent of Rishi Sunak coincided with Diwali. Here devotees light candles in Amritsar on Thursday. Picture: AFP

In winning the race for British Conservative Party leader on Monday night, Rishi Sunak will become the first prime minister of colour to govern a country that once ruled India, much of Africa and a great deal beyond.

It happened at the start of ­Diwali. The Hindu festival of lights celebrates the triumph of good over evil – and for a few of the religiously minded, it was a congruence written in the stars.

India’s Hindu nationalist Prime Minister, Narendra Modi, congratulated his co-religionist on Twitter, while extending ­Diwali wishes to the “living bridge” of UK Indians as a whole.

The success of the UK-born Mr Sunak rippled across the ­Atlantic too. Ro Khanna, a Democratic Party member of congress representing a slice of Silicon Valley in California, said his own grandfather spent years fighting British rule in India.

“It is remarkable to see ­@RishiSunak, an Indian British of Hindu faith become PM on ­Diwali. Regardless of politics, this is a symbolic step in moving ­beyond a colonizer’s world,” he tweeted.

But for many UK South Asians, as with the country at large, the arrival of Britain’s first prime minister of colour provoked as much debate about his ­economic credo as about the colour of his skin.

At the country’s biggest Hindu temple in the London district of Neasden, many Diwali revellers basked in Mr Sunak’s ascent.

“It’s a great day for the Indian community … but more so it’s a time where we look back and think ‘how can we move forward from here?’” financial analyst Kirtan Patel said at the temple.

Anand Menon, politics professor at King’s College London, said Mr Sunak’s ethnicity was “a really, really big deal”. But he added on BBC television: “What reassures me most, actually, is how little comment there has been about it, in a sense that we seem to have normalised this.”

If it feels “normalised” now, a brown or black prime minister would have felt unimaginable in Britain only a few years ago.

When Mr Sunak was born in 1980, there had been no Asian or black MPs since World War II.

A handful were then elected for the Labour Party. But the Conservatives still had none when Mr Sunak graduated from the ­University of Oxford in 2001. In the late 1960s, many were in thrall to the firebrand Tory Enoch ­Powell, who warned of racial civil war if mass immigration from the old Empire continued.

Polls at the time found a majority of white Britons agreed. Today, according to Sunder Katwala of the demographics think tank British Future “most people in Britain now rightly say the ethnicity and faith of the prime minister should not matter”.

“They will judge Sunak on whether he can get a grip on the chaos in Westminster, sort out the public finances and restore integrity to politics,” he said. “But we should not underestimate this ­important social change.”

Mr Sunak’s reception among South Asians was previewed by that given to Conservative politicians such as Priti Patel, who was Britain’s first ethnic-Indian home secretary. Ms Patel’s flagship policy of sending would-be migrants on a one-way ticket to Rwanda was met with incredulity by many, given her own family’s escape from persecution under the Ugandan dictator Idi Amin.

As Mr Sunak’s elevation was announced, Ms Patel tweeted pictures from a Diwali visit to a Hindu temple, declaring: “It is a time for self-reflection, family, friends and service to others.”

“A period of self reflection would do you well,” was one of the more polite tweets in response.

The Tories have done better at cultivating ethnic-Indian – and female – politicians in their top ranks than Labour, and they often out-compete their white colleagues in appeals to the hardline right. Ms Patel’s short-lived successor Suella Braverman, whose family also came from India, was even more outspoken on ­migration. Her views helped to sink dwindling hopes for a UK-India free-trade deal by Diwali.

For many observers, the Tories still suffer a paucity of viewpoints, given the elite Oxford education afforded to Mr Sunak and Ms Truss – as well as to Boris Johnson and most other post-war prime ministers before them.

The appointment of Mr Sunak, coinciding with a new king in Charles III, “tells an important story about our society, where we have come from and where we are going”, Mr Katwala said. But he added: “I hope that Sunak will ­acknowledge that not everybody has enjoyed his advantages in life. Rishi Sunak reaching 10 Downing Street does not make Britain a perfect meritocracy.”

AFP