NewsBite

Joe Kelly

Trump is testing the limits of his power as US president

Joe Kelly
Donald Trump stands in the presidential box as he tours the John F. Kennedy Centre for the Performing Arts in Washington on Monday. He has appointed himself head of the board. Picture: AFP
Donald Trump stands in the presidential box as he tours the John F. Kennedy Centre for the Performing Arts in Washington on Monday. He has appointed himself head of the board. Picture: AFP

Donald Trump has plunged into the political battle he always wanted by challenging the power of the judicial branch of the United States government.

Trump now appears locked in an arm-wrestle with the legal system over the basis of his mass deportation plan. But the key question is whether his administration recognises the arm-wrestle is legitimate at all, with experts warning of a potential constitutional crisis if the President implements his political agenda in defiance of the courts.

This scenario appears to be edging closer - the latest flashpoint being the administration’s use of a rarely used 1798 law, known as the Alien Enemies Act, to deport Venezuelan gang members.

Only invoked during conflicts – in 1812, World War I and World War II – it has never previously been used as the legal foundation to deport dangerous non-citizens during peacetime.

On Saturday, the top federal judge in Washington told the administration that any in-progress international flights deporting non-citizens under the 1798 law needed to be “returned to the United States’’.

Yet, this did not happen. Instead, 261 non citizens were deported by plane to El Salvador, swiftly raising questions about whether the administration had defied the court.

The administration says it did not.

But its key defence was to say the District Court lacked jurisdiction and that a 14-day temporary ban on deportations under the law was an illegitimate infringement on presidential power.

An alleged member of the Venezuelan criminal organisation Tren de Aragua being shaved upon his arrival at the Terrorism Confinement Centre in the city of Tecoluca, El Salvador. The United States has sent over 200 alleged members of a Venezuelan gang to be imprisoned in El Salvador. Picture: El Salvador's Presidency press office / AFP
An alleged member of the Venezuelan criminal organisation Tren de Aragua being shaved upon his arrival at the Terrorism Confinement Centre in the city of Tecoluca, El Salvador. The United States has sent over 200 alleged members of a Venezuelan gang to be imprisoned in El Salvador. Picture: El Salvador's Presidency press office / AFP

Senior adviser to the President, Stephen Miller, said that a district court had “no ability to in any way restrain the President’s authority under the Alien Enemies Act.” The administration’s “Border Tsar” Tom Homan also told Fox News that “I don’t care what the judges think. I don’t care.”

It may ultimately fall to the US Supreme Court to determine the merits of the administration’s application of the Alien Enemies Act to transnational criminals and its claim that a district court has no jurisdiction to block foreign policy and immigration actions taken by the US President.

But this is a fight relished by the Trump administration for practical and political reasons.

In practical terms it wants to expand executive power at the expense of the judiciary and, in political terms, it can blame the courts for any failure or delays in the implementation of its political agenda.

A Donald Trump supporter confronts activists outside of a New York court as they protest the arrest and detention of Mahmoud Khalil, a green card holder and recent Columbia graduate who played a role in pro-Palestinian protests at the university. Picture: Getty Images via AFP
A Donald Trump supporter confronts activists outside of a New York court as they protest the arrest and detention of Mahmoud Khalil, a green card holder and recent Columbia graduate who played a role in pro-Palestinian protests at the university. Picture: Getty Images via AFP

Patrick Eddington, a senior fellow at the classical liberal Cato Institute in Washington, warned the expansion of executive power came with major risks and argued the nation was witnessing an “assault on the entire constitutional order in America”.

He said that, when the founding fathers wrote the US constitution, they “believed that institutional rivalry between the three branches would be an adequate check on potential executive branch overreach”.

George Washington’s warning in his farewell address about the “baneful effects of the spirit of party” had gone unheeded. “Over the course of the last 250 years that ‘baneful spirit of party’ has now effectively subverted institutional safeguards,” Eddington said.

He suggested the impeachment and removal of a president for unconstitutional acts would now prove to be “simply impossible” if they were “supported in the House and Senate GOP via a cult of personality’’.

“And because all federal law enforcement agencies are under the control of the executive, it’s not at all clear that even officials below Trump who carried out his unlawful orders would face arrest for their acts.”

US judge questions Trump's deportation of Venezuelans
White House: Deportation Flights Took Off before Judge’s Written Order
White House: judge has no authority to block deportations
Read related topics:Donald Trump

Add your comment to this story

To join the conversation, please Don't have an account? Register

Join the conversation, you are commenting as Logout

Original URL: https://www.theaustralian.com.au/world/trump-is-testing-the-limits-of-his-power-as-us-president/news-story/43133fb894d1de8f8f6cfcee1a36a2ca