Standing ovation for rock star psychologist
Ask the protesters, they’ll tell you that Jordan Peterson’s ideas are dangerous.
Did that explain the police, the private security, the men with wands, the women shining torches into handbags, and the walk-through X-ray machines at the Opera House on Saturday?
No, they were there to protect Peterson, whose aim was to give a lecture, and those who wanted to hear it.
The precautions held up the show by almost an hour. Peterson later joked he had just started to think his enemies had given up, and faded away.
“That may change at this Q&A next Monday,” the Canadian professor said, referring to his long-awaited appearance on the ABC’s flagship panel show on Monday, February 25.
More seriously, he added: “The people who have enmity for me? They’re done. They’re out of ammunition. I read a ‘hit piece’ these days, and I feel, oh, you’ve just copied that hit piece from two months ago.”
Peterson spoke for more than an hour at the Opera House, reducing himself to tears at one point. Like any rock star psychologist — that may be a pool of one — he received a standing ovation.
He was then whisked across town to speak for a second hour at a private, more intimate event hosted by former deputy prime minister John Anderson.
It was at this event that Peterson revealed he agreed with some of what his opponents had to say: for example, he does think we all live in “an oppressive patriarchy”.
But what, he said, was the point in dividing men and women on the issue? “Race, gender, sexual orientation, they don’t matter that much,” he said. “They don’t matter anywhere near as much as the diversity of ideas.”
His aim, he said, was to lead people away from identity politics towards a future in which everyone was working together, in the main because he could without hesitation find a way to make anyone in the audience “an oppressor.”
“Maybe it’s because you’re male,” he said, to a person of colour. “Maybe it’s because you’re middle class,” he said to a woman.
Peterson was asked about the lack of faith in old institutions, and he put it straight back on the audience. “If you don’t trust your institutions, well, they’re your institutions,” he said. “Look in the mirror — the effectiveness of those institutions is down to you.”
If you don’t like the way your bank, your church, your cricket team is behaving, in other words, do something about.
If not you, then who?
Back at the Opera House, the crowd was split 55-45 on gender. There were guys who looked like they’d come straight from Harvard Law School; women who looked too young to be wearing so many pearls; silver foxes in six-button blazers; and pierced boys and girls with ripped jeans.
One protester carried a sign complaining about Peterson being “racist, homophobic”.
His warm-up guy, US political commentator Dave Rubin, took hold of that issue, telling the crowd he didn’t have the heart to tell him that “Peterson’s warm-up guy is married to a dude”.
Rubin later silenced attendees by asking: “Does anyone in this room have it worse than their grandparents?”
“I almost never get a yes to that question,” he said, “because if you’re living in a free society in 2019, you are not oppressed.”