NewsBite

Asylum seekers: Peter Dutton gets win in Supreme Court on Manus Island

The Supreme Court has thrown out an injunction bid aimed at preventing the closure of the Manus Island processing centre.

Immigration Minister Peter Dutton. Picture: AAP
Immigration Minister Peter Dutton. Picture: AAP

The PNG Supreme Court has thrown out an injunction application aimed at preventing the closure of the regional processing centre at Manus Island.

The office of Immigration Minister Peter Dutton has confirmed activists lost their case, which will leave 600 men who refuse to leave the centre without easy access to food, water and power.

The court ordered the closure of the detention centre at the end of October but the asylum seekers won’t leave due to safety concerns.

The Turnbull government is encouraging the detainees to move to alternate accommodation it has built on the island.

Lawyers on behalf of Iranian refugee Behrouz Boochani tried to have electricity, food, medical care and water at the decommissioned centre reinstated on human rights grounds.

But the application, which would also have blocked PNG officials from forcibly evicting men barricaded inside the complex, was quashed in Port Moresby on Wednesday.

Mr Boochani said the decision meant there was no justice for refugees, who were used to court decisions going against them.

“Depriving refugees from having access to basic and vital things is completely against humanity. This order shows how we are forgotten people and there is no justice for us,” he told AAP from Manus Island.

“While Australian and PNG judicial systems are not able to provide justice for us, I’m asking international courts to take action and protect us.” Refugees and asylum seekers had been pinning their hopes on the last-ditch attempt to keep the centre open.

A week since the Manus Island compound was shut down to comply with a 2016 court ruling, almost 600 men remain barricaded inside the mothballed centre. They are adamant it’s safer to remain than risk being attacked by locals at new accommodation sites near the main township of Lorengau.

An appeal may be lodged as early as Wednesday.

Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull has urged the men to move.

“There are alternative facilities available of a very high quality with food and all of the (other) facilities,” he told ABC radio on Tuesday. “The residents at Manus, the RPC, they are being asked to move and they should move.” PNG Immigration Minister Petrus Thomas has also insisted it is no longer possible to restore services to the detention centre, urging its inhabitants to leave.

Mr Thomas said it wasn’t simply a case of reconnecting the water or electricity at the facility, which was officially closed on Tuesday last week. “There is no service provider to deliver services and more significantly, as services are available at the new facilities, there is no need for services to be reconnected,” he said in a statement released on Sunday.

Amnesty International slammed the court ruling.

“The decision is an abhorrent attack on the right to life,” spokeswoman Kate Schuetze said.

Additional reporting: AAP

Read related topics:Peter Dutton

Add your comment to this story

To join the conversation, please Don't have an account? Register

Join the conversation, you are commenting as Logout

Original URL: https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/immigration/asylum-seekers-peter-dutton-gets-win-in-supreme-court-on-manus-island/news-story/1dc707c6c7b77f1aee4035f4fb782803