Environment Minister Sussan Ley wins major climate change case
The full bench rules in favour of Environment Minister Sussan Ley but the school students behind the landmark climate change lawsuit vow to keep fighting.
The group of school students behind a landmark climate change lawsuit have vowed to keep fighting for protection from global warming after a “devastating” court ruling.
The federal court on Tuesday found Australia’s environment minister does not have a duty of care to protect children from the harm caused by climate change.
Sussan Ley secured the major victory after being taken to court by eight high school students.
The teenagers launched their class action in 2020, attempting to stop planning approval for an expansion of Whitehaven Coal’s Vickery mine in regional NSW.
They secured a partial victory in the federal court in July last year.
Justice Mordecai Bromberg dismissed their application to prevent Ms Ley from approving the mine expansion, but found she owed a duty of care to young Australians when assessing fossil fuel projects.
Justice Bromberg’s decision was hailed as a landmark ruling that could pave the way for future climate litigation in Australia.
Ms Ley appealed against the decision, arguing she didn’t have this duty of care. She was ultimately successful on Tuesday morning.
The full bench of the Federal Court unanimously overturned the earlier win by the students, with all three judges agreeing there was no duty of care.
The teenagers have promised to keep fighting for stronger action on climate change in Australia.
“Today’s ruling leaves us devastated, but it will not deter us in our flight for climate justice,” 17-year-old Anjali Sharma said.
“Climate change is already wreaking havoc on the lives of Australians. Two years ago, Australia was on fire; today, it’s underwater.
“Burning coal makes bushfires and floods more catastrophic and more deadly. Something needs to change. Our leaders need to step up and act.”
Izzy Raj-Seppings, 15, said there was still much to celebrate.
“The court’s recognition that extraction and burning of fossil fuels will cause future climate impacts is an important step in the fight for climate justice in the courtroom,” she said.
The students’ lawyer David Barnden said their legal team would carefully review Tuesday’s decision.
“Independent climate change experts established that Whitehaven’s Vickery coal mine will create a risk of personal injury and death to young Australians,” he said.
“The science has not changed. Irrespective of today’s decision, adults should do all they can to create a safe future for our children.”
Ms Ley has since approved the Vickery mine expansion, which is expected to produce an additional 100 million tonnes of carbon emissions.
Her office has been contacted for comment.
More to come.
‘Disability reform timeline hasn’t been agreed yet’: states
Foundational supports were meant to start with a phased rollout from July 1, but states are waiting until the federal government ticks off a five-year hospital funding agreement.
Toorak mansion our most expensive home
An grand Italianate estate in Melbourne’s Toorak has been crowned the nation’s most expensive home after changing hands for a price believed to be $150m.