It will take time to absorb the horror and to begin to understand the wider consequences of the carnage Hamas unleashed on Israel this weekend, but five things are immediately clear.
1.
FIRST, while the scale of the attack has implications that will transform the strategic landscape, we must recognise the atrocity primarily for what it is – another attempt to annihilate the Jewish people.
The spectacle of paramilitaries going house to house shooting Jews, dragging their dead bodies through the streets, and brandishing them as spoils is as shocking as it is familiar. For Jews, this is their history played out one more agonising time. Another year, another place, another pogrom. Even the state of Israel, that magnificent homeland they have built for themselves in the desert, with its world-beating technology and its fearsome security forces, can’t fully protect them from the undying, putrid hate of anti-Semitism.
2.
SECOND, as moving as it has been to watch, the sympathy we have seen expressed for Israel around the world won’t last. It has been stirring to see the colours of the Israeli flag adorning public buildings across Europe and America, but I give it a week before normal service is resumed.
As Israel begins its campaign of righteous retaliation and starts trying to eliminate the terrorist threat once and for all, the regular crowd of left-wing politicians and their acolytes in the media will demand “restraint” (some were already doing so even as the slaughter of Israelis was unfolding) and denounce a response they will deem “disproportionate.”
Pray tell, what is a “proportionate” response to an enemy that indiscriminately mows down young partygoers at a concert, drags off terrified grandmothers to an unknown fate in some Gazan hellscape, and spits on the half-naked body of an innocent young woman they have just murdered?
3.
THIRD, as this war escalates, it is important to understand that the savagery is essential to Hamas’s goals. Their wanton bloodlust is designed to work twice over. They murder, rape and mutilate Israelis, knowing that in its response Israel will wreak havoc on Palestinians. Israel, unlike its enemies, will do what it can to avoid punishing the innocent. But innocents will suffer, because Hamas has positioned them precisely for this purpose.
The terrorists’ objective is truly indiscriminate destruction. For them a dead Jew is a bonus, but a dead Palestinian is a trophy they can parade before credulous Western media to convey some supposed moral equivalence between their depravity and the actions of a beleaguered state seeking to preserve its very existence.
4.
FOURTH, and while acknowledging it’s too soon to make definitive judgments, we must understand the strategic context that demands an accounting of the role the US has played in the genesis of this tragedy.
Catastrophic errors by successive administrations in Washington over 20 years are reaping a whirlwind. The defining reality over that time has been the spectacle of an America blundering into and then clumsily abandoning the region: the disaster of the Iraq war, the abysmal mess we left in Libya, the pitiful weakness shown in Syria, the humiliating retreat from Afghanistan, the incoherent and naive back-and-forth over whether Saudi Arabia is a friend or a pariah.
The single consistent beneficiary has been Iran, sponsor of Hamas, Hezbollah and other groups that murder innocents. Instead of compensating for our abandonment of the territory for Tehran’s mullahs to exploit, the US has doubled down on the power it ceded to them.
The appeasement of Iran by the Obama and Biden administrations has bolstered the conditions by which Tehran exerts its power — in Syria, Iraq, Lebanon and Gaza. Most recently last month, on the anniversary of the 9/11 attacks, the Biden team’s strategic geniuses executed the infamous cash-for-hostages swap.
It is nauseating to listen to officials from the administration and its media proxies insist that the $US6 billion consideration in that deal couldn’t be used to enable Iran to fund Hamas. How naive, how dishonest, do you have to be to pretend that, if I deposit $6 billion into one of your bank accounts, you can claim that you aren’t $6 billion better off to spend as you please?
No one wants war with Iran, but given the role Tehran played in organising this monstrous attack, Israel must now surely strike at the regime, and any conflict that may ensue owes at least in part to America’s indulging Tehran for too long.
5.
FINALLY, it’s impossible to resist the wider conclusion that the world has become much more dangerous in the past three years. This isn’t to endorse Donald Trump’s claims about his diplomatic successes — the former president’s curious affection for autocrats was never going to promote peace in the long term. But the Biden administration has turned Afghanistan from a US protectorate to a terrorist state, has seen a nuclear-armed adversary invade a European nation on the borders of the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation, and has now watched helplessly as our closest ally in the Middle East has been raped by terrorists backed by a state the administration has been busy appeasing.
The primary responsibility for the monstrosity in Israel lies with the terrorists. But American weakness will always embolden the worst people in the world.
The Wall Street Journal
More Coverage
Read related topics:Israel
Join the conversation
Police snipers and drone patrols: the new reality for US election workers
A top Republican election official said ‘you’d have to be a psychopath to enjoy this’ as the reality of the 2024 election in battleground states takes hold.
Read more
Mystery $45m wave of pro-Trump bets moves crypto market
Four Polymarket accounts have systematically placed frequent wagers on a Trump election victory.
Read more