Oliver Wiltshire had just sat on the couch after a day on the tools, working as a third-year apprentice carpenter when his phone rang.
It was Geelong’s recruiting manager Stephen Wells, letting the 21-year-old Bellarine Football League star know he might want to invite some friends over.
Oliver Wiltshire (centre) flanked by fellow Geelong draftees (left to right) Connor O’Sullivan, Shaun Mannagh, George Stevens and Emerson Jeka.Credit: Chris Hopkins
“‘Wellsy’ called me up and said, ‘you’re going to have a good night, maybe get the boys around, get the family around’,” Wiltshire said.
At pick 61, on Tuesday night, the second night of the AFL national draft, Wiltshire’s name was read out, joining VFL product Shaun Mannagh and Warrnambool’s George Stevens as fairytale additions to Geelong’s list.
Wiltshire, a former St Joseph’s College student, spent the past two seasons playing local footy for Barwon Heads, the Bellarine league being the second-best community league in the region after the Geelong Football League.
COVID had impacted his two under-18 seasons at the Geelong Falcons, wiping out all of 2020, and in 2021, a spluttering season was compounded by injuries.
Oliver Wiltshire (right) in action for the Geelong Falcons in the Talent League in 2021.Credit: AFL Photos
Wiltshire thought his AFL dream was over, but credits his eventual recruiting to Geelong to the addition of Cats great Matthew Scarlett as an assistant coach at Barwon Heads.
Despite being quietly spoken at the Cats, Scarlett had a reputation for commanding attention when he spoke. The club’s former chief executive Brian Cook dubbed Scarlett “The Senator”, noting he didn’t attend many meetings, but was the man all decisions needed to go through to succeed.
Also known for identifying talent, the Cats great, who helped Geelong recruit Tom Stewart – now a five-time All-Australian – out of South Barwon when he was coaching in the GFL, saw Wiltshire’s ability pretty early on in his 2023 campaign at the Seagulls.
“He pulled me aside for a chat earlier in the year and said, ‘do you have any aspirations to play AFL’, and I obviously said, ‘yeah, it’s every kid’s dream’,” Wiltshire said.
Matthew Scarlett was an influential figure at Geelong in his playing days, and remains so to this day. Credit: Paul Rovere
“Here I am today.
“He’s there every training, every game, and towards finals he didn’t take over, but he pumped the chest out, and he got in there. He was unreal to have [at the club], brings all the boys to the side for one-on-one chats.
“He’s rapt for me, I spoke to him pretty much a couple of weeks up to the draft. He’s so rapt for me, over the moon.”
A bag of 12 goals against Modewarre in April was the performance that put Wiltshire on the map, and he finished the season winning the club’s best and fairest after they exited in a preliminary final.
That was after he missed out on getting onto Werribee’s VFL list, spending a month training with the Tigers during pre-season, only to be cut.
“He’s made Werribee look a bit silly now,” joked Mannagh, Geelong’s third selection in the draft at pick 36, who remembers Wiltshire training with the Tigers.
“It’s a credit to him, the way he’s gone back to Barwon Heads and put on a great year. Stoked for him, and maybe next time Werribee might sign him.”
Mannagh’s selection was inspired itself. Aged 26, he was best afield in the VFL grand final when he kicked six goals in a losing side.
Shaun Mannagh was best on ground in the VFL grand final, and has now been drafted by Geelong.Credit: AFL Photos
He’s now daring to dream of following in the footsteps of the likes of Tom Atkins, who spent a number of years plying his trade in the state league, only to eventually become an AFL premiership player.
“I remember playing against Tommy when he was playing as Geelong captain in the VFL,” Mannagh said.
“One hundred per cent, I hope in 2024 for some success straight away.”
He said even though he was a mature-aged recruit, he was like any player on the Cats list aiming to play in the club’s season opener.
The Cats began their draft at pick 11, recruiting 198-centiemetre key defender Connor O’Sullivan, then added 206-centimetre ruckman Mitch Edwards (pick 32) from Peel in Western Australia, Mannagh (pick 36), Stevens (pick 58), Wiltshire (pick 61) and Swan Districts’ 20-year-old Lawson Humphries (pick 63).
On Wednesday, Emerson Jeka found a new home at Geelong after four seasons and seven games at Hawthorn. He’d spent the year at Box Hill, but had signed to play for Essendon’s VFL team in 2024, only to get a call five minutes before he was rookie drafted on Wednesday.
“I was really committed to Essendon … I didn’t actually think I’d end up here,” he said.
“I was prepared to play at Essendon and hopefully get on their list in February or mid-season, so I’d definitely not given up, but it was a bit of a shock.
“Injuries this year haven’t helped, but I’m really fortunate Geelong gave me an opportunity.”
Keep up to date with the best AFL coverage in the country. Sign up for the Real Footy newsletter.