NewsBite

Advertisement

We are fortunate abortion is no longer a hot topic, but NSW must ensure access

By The Herald's View

It is one of the most arresting campaign videos put out by US Vice-President Kamala Harris’ presidential campaign team.

Hadley Duvall, a 22-year-old woman from Kentucky, speaks about being raped by her stepfather and falling pregnant, aged 12.

“Girls and women all over the country have lost the right to choose,” she says.

When the US heads to the polls in November, Democrats are hoping that women in conservative states remember it was former president and 2024 presidential nominee Donald Trump’s tenure which led to the country’s key abortion rights decision, Roe v Wade, being overturned.

Fourteen politically conservative US states have since been able to ban abortion since, most with no exemption for rape or incest.

Doctors who provide an abortion in these states can risk prosecution, and, in some jurisdictions, being personally sued by the woman’s family.

Loading

The result has been nervousness from clinicians, even when procedures should, technically, not be captured by the state bans. There have been reports of women who have miscarried risking their safety by travelling interstate for medical procedures such as D&Cs.

It is a situation Trump seems happy with – he said in April that the rules were now “where everybody wanted it from a legal standpoint” – even though his own wife said this week that women should have “individual freedom” over their bodies.

Pew Centre polling suggests a majority of Americans support legal abortion, including majorities of most Christian denominations. Its 2024 polling found legal abortion is supported by 41 per cent of Republican voters.

Advertisement

In NSW, we are fortunate that access to reproductive healthcare is no longer a political hot topic.

Abortion was decriminalised under a Liberal government in 2019, to be treated as a healthcare matter and not a potential crime requiring a legal exemption.

But, as Kate Aubusson writes in today’s Sun-Herald, the decriminalisation of abortion in this state has been complex. And just because a woman cannot be prosecuted for terminating a pregnancy, it does not mean she can do so safely.

Vulnerable women are being made to search well into their second trimester for access to abortion services.

The issue is that, while abortion is legal, it is still overwhelmingly accessed through private clinics. Despite a directive from NSW Health that all public hospitals must offer clear referral pathways for timely pregnancy terminations, only one hospital in the state – John Hunter in Newcastle – has a formal, funded surgical abortion service, predominantly for women in their first trimester.

Doctors at Westmead Hospital, in the city’s west, are concerned women are ticking over 15 weeks gestation while they sit on waitlists for private clinics they can’t afford.

They are providing surgical abortion services for those they can, but with no dedicated referral pathway or clinic, and packed surgical lists, some are going without. The alternative, a second trimester medical abortion, can be traumatic for both the woman and clinicians involved.

They have provided Western Sydney Local Health District with a business case for a dedicated clinic for these women, to provide what could be a hub for public services for the entire state.

University of Sydney Professor Kirsten Black notes that if well-funded and accessible, first trimester services will help to prevent the issue of second trimester terminations – in Sweden, she notes, women present early to free, public abortion services.

Decriminalisation was a good first step, but the job is not done. Our public hospitals must heed the directive from NSW Health and ensure safe access to abortion services is prioritised.

Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.

Most Viewed in National

Loading

Original URL: https://www.smh.com.au/national/nsw/we-are-fortunate-abortion-is-no-longer-a-hot-topic-but-nsw-must-ensure-access-20241005-p5kg2b.html