NewsBite

Advertisement

Beaches council clears path for 40 per cent rate rise at fiery meeting

By Nick Newling
Updated

There was only one storm louder than the southerly buster that broke Sydney’s heatwave on Tuesday, and it came from inside the Northern Beaches Council chambers. As a motion to raise rates by up to 40 per cent was debated and narrowly approved, Mayor Sue Heins struggled to maintain decorum among the 200 protesters who filled the public gallery.

Following a short rally outside the chambers, objectors filled the auditorium and repeatedly interjected, shaking maracas and waving placards, leading Heins to demand silence within the first two minutes of the four-hour-long hearing and call for the meeting to be paused three times.

Protesters rally against the Northern Beaches Council’s proposed 40 per cent rate rise.

Protesters rally against the Northern Beaches Council’s proposed 40 per cent rate rise.Credit: James Brickwood

Those protesting against the motion were critical of the rise, executives’ salaries and the $173,000 resident survey they believe was misinterpreted by the council to justify the increase. According to council papers, 51 per cent of surveyed residents opted for a pegged rate increase of 10.7 per cent. Only 11 per cent voted for the 39.6 per cent rise that was successfully moved at the meeting.

Speaking before the meeting, two residents and pensioners, Christine Hennessy and Anne Ford, said they couldn’t see the reasoning behind such a significant rate rise that they think many in the community cannot afford.

“I’ve lived here my whole life,” Hennessy said. “We’ve been in our house for 44 years. And yes, of course, the house values increased, but to warrant 39.6 per cent or whatever it is rate rise, I can’t see it.”

Ford said that the cost-of-living crisis was squeezing household budgets and a rate rise could potentially push ratepayers over the edge. “I’d like to go to my energy company and say, ‘Can you decrease what I pay by 39.6 per cent?’ Or go to Woolworths or Coles or Aldi or IGA and say, ‘Oh, can we put the price of groceries down, please?’ ”

Protesters gather outside the Northern Beaches Council meeting.

Protesters gather outside the Northern Beaches Council meeting. Credit: James Brickwood

“People are struggling at the moment. The older people on the beaches who’ve been here for a long while on a pension, where will they find 39.6 per cent to suddenly pay into rates? And what do they get from it?”

Inside the meeting, James Brown, the Liberal candidate for the seat of Mackellar in the upcoming federal election, spoke against the motion. Brown introduced himself as a “resident” but was repeatedly interrupted by a member of the gallery demanding the candidate identify his political affiliation.

Advertisement

Heins asked for Brown to be heard in silence, requesting that the politician get “his point across ... without irritating as many people as possible”. The request was met with shouting from the crowd and an apology from Heins. Brown did not directly address his candidacy but did say his “occupation is known; there’s a building down the road with my face on it”.

Loading

Federal and state teal independents Zali Steggall, Sophie Scamps, and Jacqui Scruby all released individual statements yesterday criticising the rise. State Liberal MPs Matt Cross and James Griffin released a joint statement on Monday calling the council “out of touch” and blaming the “teals and Greens” for losing “control of the budget”.

Tensions further escalated when councillor Miranda Korzy, the only Greens member to vote for the motion, described the campaign against the proposal as a “neoliberal attack”, which was misinterpreted by one member of the audience as a characterisation of protesters as “neo-Nazi[s]”, leading to a commotion that caused the meeting to be paused.

Once proceedings resumed, and Heins warned the audience that overexcited objectors would be removed, another member of the gallery shouted at council chief executive Scott Phillips to address repeated criticisms of his remuneration. When asked to leave the chambers, the woman refused, and the meeting was once again paused until she left.

The motion was passed by a single vote, with the support of all but one of Heins’ Your Northern Beaches Independent Team councillors, alongside Korzy and independent councillor Candy Bingham. YNBIT councillor Joeline Hackman voted against the motion but supported a smaller rate rise on environmental and infrastructure needs.

The proposal will now be submitted to IPART, which is expected to deliver a resolution in May in advance of budget deliberations in June.

Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.

Most Viewed in National

Loading

Original URL: https://www.smh.com.au/national/nsw/beaches-council-clears-path-for-40pc-rate-rise-at-fiery-meeting-20250128-p5l7s1.html