Everything I learnt by giving up my card and using only cash for a week
In the age of payWave and internet banking, I rarely carry cash. Other than coins collected from beneath couch cushions or notes shaken loose from birthday cards, I can never be relied on to have physical money.
On Monday, Treasurer Jim Chalmers revealed a national plan to force retailers selling essential items such as groceries and fuel to accept banknotes and coins, making it clear cash is sticking around.
Even before this announcement, I had found myself wondering: when online shopping is as easy as a click or two, and surcharges on card payments are rife, could exclusively using cash help me save money?
I set off on a week-long experiment to find out.
Using cash for a week taught me about my spending habits. Credit: iStock
First impressions
Starting my challenge on a Thursday, I had to track down an ATM and recall my pin, having grown accustomed to tap-and-go payment. Before making a withdrawal for $300, the cash section of my wallet was empty, aside from a small amount of foreign currency from a recent holiday.
Most Australians find their wallets just as bare as mine. RBA data from 2022 shows cash makes up just 13 per cent of transactions. It’s used sparingly by younger generations, but more frequently by older Australians.
A costly weekend, which included Friday night dinner with my girlfriend and buying a new tennis racquet, turned my $300 into nothing come Monday morning. On a late Sunday night trip to the supermarket for chocolate, I had to scrounge for coins.
While I would have spent the same amount if I hadn’t been doing the experiment, it was shocking to notice how quickly I burned through the notes.
Cash? Not so convenient
I had a few close calls using cash. When buying my racquet, I had to slightly bend the rules, using a gift card I had in my wallet, along with cash, to get over the line. This was the closest I’d been to an awkward moment at the checkout.
I found myself often doing mental arithmetic at the supermarket, calculating the cost of groceries to ensure I wouldn’t come up short at the register. I half-filled my car with petrol, expertly squeezing the trigger on the pump, so the gauge would land precisely on the dollar.
Cash also made splitting bills and shared purchases a little awkward. My brother bought a slab of beer to stock our fridge, which we’d decided to go halves on. When I offered him $27.50 in cash, he told me to get stuffed.
Luckily – and a little surprisingly – I didn’t visit any venues or shops that were cashless. Other than a few slightly taken aback bartenders and cafe staff, it was smooth sailing. The most frustrating moments of the experiment were when I’d get rebuffed at an ATM that wanted to charge me a transaction fee, which felt like defeating the point of trying to save money.
And, of course, cash can take you only so far: paying for subscriptions, bills, rent or debt repayments with an envelope of notes just doesn’t fly in 2024.
The ‘physical pain’ of cash
Dr Paul Harrison, a senior lecturer and an expert in consumer behaviour at Deakin University, says research shows using cash instead of cards can increase what experts refer to as the “pain of paying”, which can work against the joy people find in spending money.
During the week, when making smaller purchases such as buying a coffee, whipping out some coins or a small note from my wallet felt like using “free” money.
But when making larger purchases, such as the dinner bill, handing over a couple of $50 notes made me cringe. I couldn’t help but quickly break down how many hours I’d worked to earn it.
Harrison says using tap-and-go, Apple Pay or payWave – and removing the physical aspect of buying something – means we can spend money without feeling like we are. The ease of these payment methods allows us to buy things without deeply engaging in the process.
Research also indicates the speed at which we can pay electronically results in us spending more, especially on discretionary purchases.
Tap-and-go is the status quo. Credit: Shutterstock
“Psychologically, if we can get people to move through things without kind of feeling the effect of it, they’re more likely to complete that transaction,” says Harrison. “If people are using cards, they’re more likely to spend more money.”
By day four, I’d decided to try to apply this principle to my cash use. By withdrawing small amounts at a time and forcing myself to use an ATM more regularly, I could cut back on spending. After my initial $300 withdrawal, I decided to withdraw only $50 at a time for the rest of the week, to force myself to restrict my spending.
On Monday, knowing I’d have to swing by an ATM if I wanted to replenish my empty wallet, I passed on treating myself to lunch, opting instead for a DIY cheese toastie.
The secret savings
Steve Worthington, a professor in Swinburne University of Technology’s business school and cash proponent, says I would have avoided surcharges during my experiment.
“I’m sick of going into somewhere and it says, ‘OK, it’s $5 for a coffee’ and then when you pay, you realise you pay $5.05,” says Worthington. I estimate I only saved about $1 for the week, but Labor MP Jerome Laxale has estimated it costs Australians $4 billion a year.
Will I continue with cash?
The challenges in always trying to have enough cash on hand, and the attitude from my friends means I’m looking forward to going back to using phone banking and tap-and-go.
However, a renewed effort from the government shows cash is here to stay, which will be welcome news for those who still prefer or rely on it. I just hope I’m not stuck behind them fumbling with coins at the checkout.
Make the most of your health, relationships, fitness and nutrition with our Live Well newsletter. Get it in your inbox every Monday.