Virtical development splashes $61m on Courthouse, Kinselas pubs

Two of Sydney’s well-known watering holes, Kinselas and the Courthouse have been snapped up by private property developers, Virtical, for a combined $61 million which has plans to give the popular Taylor Square precinct a revamp and facelift.

They will be added to Virtical’s expanding portfolio which has seen it buy $126 million worth of assets within five months. These deals include The Republic Hotel on the corner of Pitt and Bridge Streets, bought for $40 million last month, and the Adelphi Hotel in Melbourne in May for $25 million.

The buyer is the former Core Asset Development led by managing director Mark Toma, who changed the name to Virtical and owns more than $500 million in completed projects, ranging from Eden on the NSW South Coast to Newcastle West and the city pubs.

Kinselas, Taylor Square, Darlinghurst.

Toma said he was “delighted with the acquisition”.

“We have a strong track record in construction and development across various real estate sectors, including hospitality projects, and we’re well positioned to realise the potential of the precinct.”

Virtical MD Mark Toma

“The addition of the Taylor Square hotels complements our broader strategy for the assets in our portfolio,” Toma said.

“We have a strong track record in construction and development across various real estate sectors, including hospitality projects, and we’re well positioned to realise the potential of the precinct.”

MA Financial sold the two pubs after buying them in late 2020 for a combined $67 million. There are currently a number of high profiles pubs on the market with agents saying demand has come back after a slower start to the year due to the rising interest rates

The famous Darlinghurst pubs – Kinselas started operations in 1910, and before its conversion to a pub in 1982, the building served as a funeral parlour and headquarters of funeral director Charles Kinsela from 1933 – were previously owned by businessmen and long-time mates Geoff Dixon and John Singleton’s Australian Pub Fund. They sold them in 2017 to long-time hoteliers, the Kospetas family’s Universal Hotels group.

Universal sold them to the MA Financial Taylor Square Fund in late 2020, which had ambitious plans to consolidate the prime city fringe site through repositioning and potentially redeveloping it into a significantly expanded hospitality offering.

But with the onset of COVID-19 and slow planning approvals during the past three years, the fund has opted to sell.

Chris Unger, managing director of MA Financial’s hospitality platform, said the original investment strategy was dependent upon favourable trading conditions emerging from the first COVID lockdown, and the anticipated resurgence of Oxford Street following the repeal of the city’s lockout laws.

“However, the precinct and surrounding area has taken an extended period of time to revitalise,” Unger said.

“While we are confident the precinct will thrive over the longer term, this combined with changes in the construction and funding markets has meant the timeframes associated with redeveloping the iconic site now sit outside the fund’s target investment horizon.”

The Courthouse Hotel, Taylor Square, Darlinghurst.

He said the opportunity came up to sell to Virtical, which can now pursue its own repositioning strategy on a “different timeline and as part of a broader portfolio”.

Nick Lower and Tony Bargwanna of Savills Australia brokered the sale of the assets.

Lower, state director, hotels at Savills Australia, said the sale of Taylors Square, comprising the Kinselas and Courthouse pubs, “underscores the appeal of well-located operational pubs with solid property fundamentals”.

“Virtical’s acquisition of this prime property showcases their commitment to enhancing Sydney’s hospitality scene. Their reputation for adding premium opportunities to their portfolio is a testament to their vision and expertise,” Lower said.

Bargwanna, national director, hotels at Savills Australia, added the transaction is a clear indication of the ongoing confidence in Sydney’s pub market. It reflects the strong demand for assets that offer both operational success and the potential for future growth.

“Kinselas and Courthouse have long been cherished by the local and surrounding community alike. This transaction ensures the continuation of their legacy under Virtical’s capable stewardship,” Bargwanna said.

The Business Briefing newsletter delivers major stories, exclusive coverage and expert opinion. Sign up to get it every weekday morning.