No campaigner’s comments on Stan Grant, Lidia Thorpe labelled ‘disgusting’, ‘grotesque’

Remarks from a key figure in the Voice No campaign about Indigenous journalist Stan Grant and independent senator Lidia Thorpe have been condemned and labelled disgusting and grotesque.

Australian Jewish Association head David Adler, who sits on the advisory board of top No outfit Advance with former prime minister Tony Abbott, insists he was not trying to insult the prominent Indigenous pair when he questioned Thorpe’s Aboriginal heritage and repeatedly suggested Grant had artificially darkened his skin.

David Adler’s comments about Stan Grant (left) and Lidia Thorpe have been condemned.Credit: Oscar Colman, Facebook, Alex Ellinghausen

Days after Grant stepped down as host of the ABC’s Q+A citing racist abuse in May, Adler posted pictures of the Wiradjuri man on social media that he said showed “STAN GRANT’S COMPLEXION SEEMS TO HAVE CHANGED”.

“Look at the 3 pics. Can anyone explain?”

In March, Adler posted the same image with the caption: “IS STAN GRANT DOING ‘BLACK FACE’? If so, why?”

On four occasions in 2022, the Voice opponent, involved in the outfit closely linked to Coalition Indigenous affairs spokeswoman Jacinta Nampijinpa Price, also raised questions about Thorpe’s background.

“What % Aboriginal are you? You appear quite white,” he posted on social media in March 2022. “Not so sure she’s Blak (or Black).”

Adler, who has used his leadership of the Jewish association to castigate other Australian Jewish bodies for supporting the Voice, claimed in January that, “What is ‘racist’ is allowing people to drink themselves to death they bash/rape/murder the women/children & turning a blind eye to it because they are Aboriginal!”

In relation to the ABC, Adler has said, “If you self-identify as a black lesbian, you’ll get the job.”

When asked about the comments, Adler said he would not apologise for them and said he could not recall the remarks about Thorpe.

“I am 100 per cent zero racism. I have Aboriginal friends, the most prominent being [leading No campaigner] Warren Mundine, and you’ll see photos of me with him."

Advance is a right-wing campaigning group started in 2018 as a counterweight to activist group GetUp. It is led by Matthew Sheahan and claims it has a 250,000-strong supporter base fighting “woke politicians and elitist activist groups … taking Aussies for a ride with their radical agenda”.

Separate from the Liberal Party’s referendum campaign, it is the main referendum outfit on the No side.

The most senior members of the Liberal Party, including mainstream conservatives, are wary of the Coalition being dragged to the right by association with Advance.

Three sources, who asked to remain anonymous to speak freely, said Liberal officials had worked to ensure the party was not sharing its databases and resources with Advance as it campaigned against the Voice.

This masthead decided to publish Adler’s comments because of the active public debate about Australian race relations enlivened by the referendum. Advance, which publicly discloses few details about its operations, and its leading figures are also worthy of scrutiny given the important role the group has in running the No side.

Responding to Adler, Thorpe said the No campaign should be ashamed to work with groups such as Advance.

“I called it out early that there is a racist No campaign that is encouraging racists and hurting our people,” she said in a statement. “The government created this space for them and has failed in its responsibility to deal with the rise in racism.”

Grant declined to comment.

Australia/Israel and Jewish Affairs Council chairman Mark Leibler said Adler had recently used anti-Semitic tropes to delegitimise support for the Voice expressed by several Jewish groups.

Leibler, who co-chaired the 2012 expert panel on constitutional recognition of Indigenous Australians and the later council that culminated in the Uluru statement, added: “The notion that someone who leads a so-called ‘Jewish organisation’ could post such disgusting comments about anyone from another minority group, in this case the highly regarded journalist and author Stan Grant, is nothing short of grotesque.

“While the Jewish community is already well aware that the views of this fringe organisation and its president are utterly incompatible with Jewish values, this latest revelation should make it clear to the broader Australian community that Adler is simply an unrepresentative extremist.”

Cut through the noise of federal politics with news, views and expert analysis from Jacqueline Maley. Subscribers can sign up to our weekly Inside Politics newsletter here.