Western Derby: The 60 greatest individual derby performances of all time
Was Harley Reid robbed? Did Dockers fans have the right to boo Chris Judd? We’ve ranked the best 60 derby performances of all-time to celebrate the 60th meeting of West Coast and Fremantle.
AFL
Don't miss out on the headlines from AFL. Followed categories will be added to My News.
It’s the game that stops a state.
Now, nearly 30 years on from the first western derby, West Coast will take on Fremantle for the 60th time at Optus Stadium on Sunday.
Both teams have endured a winless start to the season meaning plenty is on the line for the Eagles and Dockers.
With the help of Champion Data, and to celebrate 30 years of one of football’s fiercest rivalries, we have compiled the best 60 western derby performances of all time.
Was Harley Reid robbed? Who should’ve really won the Glendinning-Allan medal in 2003 that was controversially awarded to Michael Gardiner? Did Dockers fans have the right to boo Chris Judd?
Now we have the answers. Ranking points have determined who the ultimate derby specialist is.
Ranking points only go back until 1999 and the first derby was played in 1995.
But these are the 60 most statistically dominant derby performances on record.
60. CALEB SERONG (FREMANTLE) – 143
Round 3, 2023
Serong won his second Glendinning-Allan medal for this performance - 35 disposals and 9 score involvements.
59. SHAUN MCMANUS (FREMANTLE) – 143
Round 21, 2000
Fremantle’s favourite son had 25 touches as the Dockers got up in a one-point thriller.
58. DANIEL KERR (WEST COAST) – 144
Round 21, 2004
Kerr had 24 and a goal in West Coast’s 48-point win.
57. GLEN JAKOVICH (WEST COAST) – 144
Round 6, 2000
In a record-breaking day for the Eagles, Jakovich kicked two goals from 24 touches.
56. JACK REDDEN (WEST COAST) – 144
Round 4, 2019
A typical workman like performance from Redden, racking up 33 disposals.
55. STEPHEN HILL (FREMANTLE) – 144
Round 20, 2015
His second cousin Josh won the medal but Hill finished with 28 disposals and a goal.
54. MATT PRIDDIS (WEST COAST) – 145
Round 3, 2008
The Eagles lost a close one but Priddis made a stand with 28 touches and a goal.
53. JASON NORRISH (FREMANTLE) – 145
Round 16, 1999
On the day the Dockers won their first derby, Norrish finished with 32 touches.
52. GUY MCKENNA (WEST COAST) -145
Round 1, 1999
McKenna won the Glendinning-Allan medal for this performance – 21 touches and three rebounds.
51. DANIEL KERR (WEST COAST) – 146
Round 22, 2003
Kerr had 21 touches and two goals for the Eagles.
50. BEN COUSINS (WEST COAST) – 146
Round 6, 2004
Cousins fought hard against Bell and Hasleby to finish with 28 touches.
49. DAVID WIRRPANDA (WEST COAST) – 146
Round 16, 2002
Wirrpanda had 16 disposals and three goals in a loss.
48. BEN COUSINS (WEST COAST) – 146
Round 4, 2001
Cousins had 28 touches and two goals for the Eagles.
47. HARLEY REID (WEST COAST) – 147
Round 6, 2024
Playing his first western derby, Reid lit up Optus Stadium with three goals from 19 disposals, including an incredible pack mark. Was denied the Glendinning-Allan medal though being deemed to have been more influential than winner Elliot Yeo.
46. TONY MODRA (FREMANTLE) – 147
Round 16, 1999
In Fremantle’s first ever derby win, Modra kicked six.
45. MICHAEL BARLOW (FREMANTLE) – 147
Round 1, 2013
Barlow secured his second Glendinning-Allan medal, tying with David Mundy, with 27 disposals,
44. CHRIS JUDD (WEST COAST) – 147
Round 20, 2005
Judd picked up his second Glendinning-Allan medal with 28 touches and a goal.
43. DAVID WIRRPANDA (WEST COAST) – 147
Round 6, 2004
Wirrpanda had 21 touches and 13 rebounds in the close loss.
42. STEPHEN HILL (FREMANTLE) – 147
Round 15, 2014
Hill won his first Glendinning-Allan medal with 32 possessions and three goals.
41. STEPHEN HILL (FREMANTLE) – 149
Round 3, 2015
Hill was electric with 30 disposals and three goals.
40. ANDREW EMBLEY (WEST COAST) – 150
Round 6, 2004
Embley finished with 25 touches and eight tackles in a loss.
39. BEN COUSINS (WEST COAST) – 150
Round 21, 2006
Cousins had 31 disposals and three goals in a losing side.
38. SEAN DARCY (FREMANTLE) – 150
Round 22, 2021
Serong won the medal for his last-gasp heroics but Darcy was also influential with 29 hitouts and 17 touches.
37. AARON SANDILANDS (FREMANTLE) – 150
Round 20, 2015
Sandilands was typically busy in a losing side with 51 hitouts.
36. ELLIOT YEO (WEST COAST) – 151
Round 6, 2017
Josh Kennedy won the medal with six goals but Yeo had 32 touches.
35. MATTHEW PAVLICH (FREMANTLE) – 152
Round 16, 2002
Pavlich finished with 27 touches playing in a defensive role.
34. DAVID WIRRPANDA (WEST COAST) – 152
Round 21, 2004
22 touches and five rebounds made it a productive day at the office.
33. DAVID MUNDY (FREMANTLE) – 153
Round 4, 2019
Mundy had 36 disposals and 10 clearances in a losing team.
32. CHAD FLETCHER (WEST COAST) – 154
Round 21, 2004
Fletcher won his second Glendinning-Allan medal with 38 touches.
31. LACHIE NEALE (FREMANTLE) – 154
Round 6, 2018
Neale (35 disposals) was named joint winner of the medal with Hurn in the first derby at Optus Stadium.
30. DREW BANFIELD (WEST COAST) – 155
Round 4, 2001
Banfield won the medal thanks to his 30 disposals and three goals.
29. CHAD MORRISON (WEST COAST) – 155
Round 4, 2001
Morrison had 21 touches.
28. NAT FYFE (FREMANTLE) – 155
Round 15, 2014
The Dockers won a tight one and Fyfe had 31 and a goal.
27. SEAN DARCY (FREMANTLE) – 155
Round 22, 2022
Darcy won his first Glendinning-Allan medal with a derby record 56 hit-out.
26. SHANNON HURN (WEST COAST) – 156
Round 3, 2022
The Dockers won and Lachie Schultz got the medal but Hurn was dominant with 27 touches.
25. DANIEL KERR (WEST COAST) – 156
Round 20, 2005
Judd won the medal but Kerr had 34 disposals and 12 clearances.
24. CHRIS JUDD (WEST COAST) – 157
Round 3, 2005
Judd copped boos from the Fremantle fans in the crowd for winning the medal in a losing team with 33 disposals and a goal.
23. LUKE MCPHARLIN (FREMANTLE) – 157
Round 18, 2008
Kicked five goals from 21 touches but Pavlich won the medal with four.
22. PETER BELL (FREMANTLE) – 158
Round 22, 2003
Halseby won the medal but Bell was also influential with 27 touches.
21. MATT ROSA (WEST COAST) – 160
Round 9, 2012
Rosa won his first Glendinning-Allan medal with a career-high 43 touches.
20. DALE KICKETT (FREMANTLE) – 160
Round 16, 1999
In Fremantle’s first ever derby win, Kickett led the way with 28 disposals.
19. TROY COOK (FREMANTLE) – 160
Round 19, 2001
Cook had 32 disposals in a losing team.
18. MICHAEL BRAUN (WEST COAST) -160
Round 6, 2000
Cummings was a clear choice for the medal with 10 goals but Braun had 26 touches and seven rebounds.
17. PETER BELL (FREMANTLE) – 161
Round 5, 2003
The most controversial Glendinning-Allan medal decision in western derby history just got more complicated. Infamously, the five voters chose Ashley Sampi. But Ross Glendinning overruled them and awarded the medal to Michael Gardiner. Champion Data says that Bell was actually the best player on the ground with 28 disposals. Long may the debate continue.
16. JOSH CARR (FREMANTLE) – 162
Round 6, 2006
On this particular day, the Glendinning-Allan medal was awarded to Chris Judd, which attracted boos from the Fremantle fans in the crowd. Champion Data says that Carr was actually the most impactful player on the ground with 26 touches and three goals.
15. PETER BELL (FREMANTLE) – 164
Round 1, 2002
West Coast kicked off the coaching career of favourite son John Worsfold with a classy win but Bell was prolific with 39 disposals and lost the medal to Chad Fletcher.
14. PAUL HASLEBY (FREMANTLE) – 165
Round 4, 2001
Hasleby didn’t win the medal but he Fremantle’s best with 30 disposals and 11 clearances.
13. SHANNON HURN (WEST COAST) – 165
Round 17, 2017
The first of three Glendinning-Allan medals for the Eagles skipper who a rock in defence with 34 disposals.
12. PAUL HASLEBY (FREMANTLE) – 165
Round 6, 2004
It was a tight call for the between Peter Bell (33 and one goal) and Paul Hasleby (30 disposals and two) for the Glendinning-Allan medal but the latter won his third.
11. PAUL HASLEBY (FREMANTLE) -167
Round 22, 2003
Hasleby picked up his second Glendinning-Allan thanks to 29 disposals and eight clearances.
10. PETER BELL (FREMANTLE) - 169
Round 19, 2001
West Coast won the game, Glen Jackovich won the medal but Pell was deemed to have been the best player on the ground with 31 disposals and seven clearances.
9. PETER BELL (FREMANTLE) – 169
Round 21, 2006
Bell won the Glendinning-Allan medal for his 28 disposals and two goals in a 57-point win.
8. LACHIE NEALE (FREMANTLE) – 170
Round 3, 2015
The Dockers kicked the first 11 goals of the match and Neale won the Glendinning-Allan medal courtesy of his 42 disposals.
7. PAUL DUFFIELD (FREMANTLE) – 173
Round 6, 2009
The Dockers won by 13 points and Duffield was exceptional down back with 34 disposals but the Glendinning-Allan medal went to Hasleby who had 35.
6. ADRIAN FLETCHER (FREMANTLE) – 174
Round 16, 1999
July 18, 1999, the day Fremantle stepped out of cross-town rival West Coast by winning the Western Derby for the very first time. On a historic day, Fletcher was the pick of the bunch, finishing with 39 disposals 10 clearances and a goal. Also became the first Docker to win a Glendinning-Allan medal.
5. PAUL HASLEBY (FREMANTLE) – 176
Round 16, 2002
Hasleby won his first Glendinning-Allan in a fiery 30-point win, finishing with 30 disposals and nine clearances.
4. DEAN COX (WEST COAST) – 177 POINTS
Round 3, 2005
The medal went to Chris Judd but Cox finished with 20 disposals, 18 hitouts and two goals and was incredibly influential.
3. SCOTT CUMMINGS (WEST COAST) – 178 POINTS
Round 6, 2000
This clash still holds the record for the biggest margin in derby history (117) and Cummings was the instigator, kicking 10 goals to win the Glendinning-Allan medal.
2. MATTHEW PAVLICH (FREMANTLE) – 180 POINTS
Round 19, 2012
An eight goal haul from the Dockers skipper delivers the second-best derby performance of all-time. Pavlich took full advantage of Darren Glass’ absence and piled on the pain, leading his side to a 65-point win and securing his third Glendinning-Allan medal.
1. PETER BELL (FREMANTLE) – 189 POINTS
Round 6, 2004
Here it is, the best derby performance on record. And controversially, Bell didn’t win the Glendinning-Allan for this 189 ranking point effort. In a 10-point win, that honour went to Paul Hasleby who had 30 touches and kicked two goals. Bell finished with 33 and one.
Originally published as Western Derby: The 60 greatest individual derby performances of all time
Legend savages captain over rival meeting
An AFL great says he “can’t have” West Coast co-captain meeting with a rival coach about potentially leaving the club at year’s end.
Star slapped down in bombshell AFL ruling
A landmark ruling at the AFL Tribunal has been handed down with a star being hit with a bombshell ban in the wake of an ugly act.