New evidence ‘proves’ Lucy Letby is not the killer

Lucy Letby’s lawyer has claimed he has “fresh evidence” that could exonerate the convicted baby killer.

Lucy Letby’s lawyer Mark McDonald said that when he first met his client, he took her at her word when she said she was innocent.

Now, the British barrister has claimed he has fresh evidence proving that the convicted neonatal nurse is a victim, not a killer.

He believes Letby, the notorious baby murderer who is serving 15 whole-life orders for killing seven babies, has suffered “the biggest miscarriage of justice in the criminal justice history of the United Kingdom,” he told 60 Minutes on Sunday night.

“The evidence that went before the jury, has been demolished now by the fresh evidence. And we need to get back to the criminal Court of Appeal,” he claimed.

Lucy Letby, the notorious baby killer, is serving 15 life sentences for murdering seven babies. Picture: South West News Service

Letby, 35, who also tried to kill seven other infants – including one baby twice – at Countess of Chester Hospital, Cheshire, in 2015 and 2016, is destined to die in jail.

Concerns about the nurse were initially sparked in 2015, following a surge in deaths at the National Health Service hospital that was three times the yearly average.

In 2017, police began their investigation, and Dr Dewi Evans, a retired pediatrician, began investigating all the baby deaths and collapses in the neonatal ward, and led police to suspect foul play.

Seven deaths and nine unexplained collapses were referred for further investigation.

“These were babies who were under control. In other words, they were not requiring huge amounts of oxygen. They were not requiring breathing support. They were quite stable, and suddenly from being quite stable, they suddenly would collapse,” Dr Evans explained.

Police had a suspect they were closing in on, Letby, the then 28-year-old who had worked at the hospital since 2012.

In 2018, police arrested the nurse and questioned her regarding the suspicious deaths and collapses that occurred while she was on duty.

Although she denied any wrongdoing, a search of her home revealed incriminating evidence, including hundreds of hospital case notes – some relating to the children who had died – along with handwritten notes, one of which Letby had written in capital letters: “I AM EVIL I DID THIS”.

It was found that the nurse also repeatedly looked up the families of her victims on social media.

Letby’s defence barrister Mark McDonald says he has fresh evidence that will exonerate his client. Picture: Nine

Following the longest criminal trial in British history and a retrial on one count of attempted murder, Letby was sentenced to 15 life sentences for her crimes last year, and her bid to appeal was rejected.

Dr Evans was the key prosecution witness, and his medical evidence was vital to the Crown’s case against Letby.

Having ruled out all other explanations, he concluded Letby was harming some babies by injecting air into their bloodstream and others by forcing milk and air into their stomachs. Two babies were poisoned using insulin.

But Mr McDonald, Letby’s lawyer, has since claimed the case had “no direct evidence against” his client.

He said the medical evidence was disproved by a team of international experts he put together to examine the babies’ cases.

Professor Neena Modi, a leading British neonatologist on the panel, said they found no evidence of murder.

“What jumped out at us, absolutely jumped out at us were these very, very plausible alternative explanations that did not involve wrongdoing of any kind,” she said.

“In each and every one of these cases, there was a very, very plausible alternative explanation.”

She claimed the babies died from natural causes or a lack of proper care and called for the case to be reviewed.

Dr Dewey Evans was the lead prosecution witness in the case against Letby and denies that there is any evidence that could prove her innocence. Picture: Nine

Mr McDonald also stated that other experts dismissed the insulin cases after it was found that the tests which helped convict Letby were proven to yield false results.

He claims to have fresh evidence, and he is confident it will exonerate his client.

“We have new hope here, and she sees it, but she also sees it as her last chance, her last chance from her point of view to get the truth out there. All Lucy Letby wants is a fair hearing,” he said.

But Dr Evans is sure that the truth has already been heard and there’s “no new evidence”, just “a new opinion”.

“And the opinion has not been tested in court,” he added.

He said he was absolutely certain of Letby’s guilt and believes “She’s the worst female serial killer in English history”.

Originally published as New evidence ‘proves’ Lucy Letby is not the killer