‘I’m done’: The Our Planet scene shocking viewers

It is truly shocking to watch and is leaving some viewers in tears. Critics say the scene is misleading but Netflix is standing by the footage.

WARNING: Confronting content

Climate change is reshaping the natural world as rising temperatures cause polar ice to melt, and some animals are less equipped to adapt to their new environment than others.

A gut-wrenching scene in Netflix’s new David Attenborough series Our Planet brings that reality into sharp focus.

It’s been labelled the Walrus scene and if you haven’t watched it yet, consider yourself warned. It’s no walk in the park.

It takes place in the Bering Strait, which separates Russia and Alaska slightly south of the Arctic Circle.

According to the show’s producers, because the icy habitat of the walrus population is shrinking, the animals are being driven on to land to haul-out in large numbers where they can sometimes be a danger to themselves.

In the Netflix footage, a conflict between walruses is believed to have prompted others to scramble to safety, some climb up a steep cliff face to find solace.

But it’s not a usual place for animals that can weigh up to two tonnes to find themselves. In their clumsy and desperate attempts to get back to the water, they stumble from the cliff’s edge.

Horrified filmmakers look on as they bounce off the jagged rocks below. Many dying on impact, or crushing other walruses beneath them.

There’s no question the scene depicts animals in an environment they’re unsuited for, but filmmakers have continued to receive backlash for placing the blame on climate change. Researchers not involved in the Netflix series believe it was polar bears that drove the walruses over the cliff.

Netflix is standing by the scene, pointing to the fact that producers worked with a Russian biologist who has worked on that stretch of coastline, and with those walruses, for more than three decades.

They teeter on the edge and appear as though they can’t work out how to get down. Picture: Netflix

Some walruses can weigh as much as two tonnes. Picture: Netflix

Filmmakers said it was the hardest thing they have ever had to film. Picture: Netflix

As their preferred habitat disappears, deadly scenes like this one are becoming a more common occurrence, the World Wildlife Fund says. Ordinarily they would gather in smaller groups and often lay about on ice.

Even the show’s producer, Sophie Lanfear, was startled by what she saw and recalled how hard it was to witness during filming.

“The walrus scenes were the hardest things I’ve ever had to witness or film in my career,” she told The New York Times.

When planning the story, she chose the location because she knew about the mega haul-outs that were taking place in the region, which are the largest in the world. But she wasn’t aware of the potential carnage.

“I was expecting that perhaps the walruses would tumble down, but at the end, they’d be okay. I really wasn’t prepared for the scale of death,” she said.

“What we think is going on is that the ones at the top can probably hear the ones in the water, and they can sense that there is water below. They teeter on the edge, and they just can’t work out how to get down there.

“A small group of maybe six or seven would make it down safely, and we’d all celebrate. But the vast majority do not. They basically walk themselves off the cliff.”

She has not publicly addressed the criticisms levelled at the scene by those who believe it is misleading and deliberately overemphasised the role of climate change, but has tweeted that it was not polar bears that caused the walrus behaviour.

The bears were not driving them off the cliffs.

— Sophie Lanfear (@sajlanfear) April 8, 2019

The scene has had a lasting impact. Picture: Netflix

‘EMOTIONAL MANIPULATION AT ITS WORST’

The show’s creators partnered with the WWF, as well as a team of scientists, to depict how various ecosystems around the world are being impacted by human-led climate change. The series is unapologetic in its advocacy.

Some critics have questioned the link between the grisly scene and climate change, instead asserting it was the threat of polar bears that drove the animals off the cliff during an event in 2017. At the time, it was reported that hundreds of walruses fell to their death after being frightened by polar bears in the Russian Arctic, where the Netflix scene was filmed.

“This must be the most ridiculous thing ever ascribed to “climate change’” said Patrick Moore, a self proclaimed sensible environmentalist and Greenpeace co-founder.

Those who believe the circumstances around the Netflix scene have been misportrayed have labelled the episode “tragedy porn” and fake news.

Speaking to the UK’s Telegraph, zoologist Dr Susan Crockford called the narrative of the scene “contrived nonsense”.

“This powerful story is fiction and emotional manipulation at its worst,” she said.

“The walruses shown in this Netflix film were almost certainly driven over the cliff by polar bears during a well-publicised incident in 2017,” she added.

“Even if the footage shown by Attenborough was not the 2017 incident in Ryrkaypiy, we know that walruses reach the top of cliffs in some locations and might fall if startled by polar bears, people or aircraft overhead, not because they are confused by shrinking sea ice cover.”

However the reaction to the show — and particularly the hard to watch scenes like this one — show it is having the desired impact for filmmakers.

Netflix is standing by the scene, pointing to the fact that producers worked with a Russian biologist who has worked on that stretch of coastline — and with those walruses — for 35 years. The streaming giant has not responded to a request for comment by news.com.au.

To those who say climate change isn’t a legitimate threat I implore you to watch just the second episode of Our Planet and watch a Walrus fall off a cliff it should never have had to scale were it not for its natural hahitat literally melting before them

— James Humphreys (@J_Humphreys16) April 5, 2019

Burst into tears watching #OurPlanet , that walrus scene was the most harrowing thing I've ever seen on a documentary. But well done #netflix, sometimes the heartbreaking scenes are what will inspire people to make a difference

— Rhiannon (@_rhiannonirving) April 7, 2019

I never thought I'd be destroyed like this. That walrus scene was heavyyy 😩 #OurPlanet

— Stephen Chambers (@smisidore_) April 8, 2019

Literally full on sobbed to the walrus moment. This whole docu series is so heart breaking. #OurPlanet I wish as humans we can do more.

— 🌿▪ Jessica ▪ 🌿 (@Fernevie) April 5, 2019

Ok. I just saw the walrus scene on our planet. #imdone

— Paul Fernando (@borsche28) April 8, 2019

A behind the scenes segment (seen above) shows the impact it had on filmmakers.

“There’s probably two or three hundred dead walrus on probably a half mile stretch of beach here,” a camera man explains through tears.

“They’re exhausted because they’re having to swim a hundred miles now to get to food and then coming back here because it’s the only place to sleep,” he says.

“They used to sleep on the ice and dive down, eat the food and sleep on the ice.

“And now they’re swimming a hundred miles, coming to this place and climbing cliffs, getting exhausted and falling down and either being killed falling or crushing each other because there’s several thousands crammed onto little tiny bits of beaches.”