Coronavirus in Australia: Labor attacks Finance Minister Mathias Cormann after labelling protesters ‘selfish’
A war of words is erupting over protesters in Australia being described as “reckless” and “self-indulgent” during the coronavirus pandemic.
Labor has attacked Finance Minister Mathias Cormann for labelling protesters in Australia as being “reckless” and “self-indulgent” during a pandemic.
Opposition indigenous Australians spokeswoman Linda Burney described Senator Cormann’s comments as “tone deaf” and “politically expedient”.
“I am not going to get into a two and fro between myself and Mathias Cormann, except to say that it would be helpful, I think, for him to look at the record and look at what the reality is in the state that he represents,” she said.
Earlier, Cormann lashed out at protesters who attended Black Lives Matter demonstrations across the country on Saturday.
Tens of thousands of people attended rallies across Australia, with Senator Cormann labelling their actions “selfish” and “self-indulgent”.
“It’s quite irresponsible what we’ve seen there,” he told Sky News.
“As I think about the heartbreak of families who haven’t been able to attend funerals for their loved ones because they were doing the right thing by taking the health advice, my heart just goes out to them. I mean, as they see people going recklessly to these sorts of demonstrations, that must be just awful for them to watch.
“I think it is incredibly selfish. It’s incredibly self indulgent. And yes, it does impose unnecessary and unacceptable risk on to the community.”
Questions have been raised over the future of coronavirus restrictions in the wake of the rallies.
Most protesters wore face masks and used hand sanitiser as they marched in protest of police brutality in Australia and the United States.
But social distancing proved difficult, with many forced to huddle shoulder-to-shoulder as crowds swelled in Sydney, Melbourne, Adelaide and Brisbane.
“If we can have this protest then there is no justification for the ongoing (illogical) restrictions on our lives,” former Queensland premier Campbell Newman tweeted on Saturday, along with an aerial view of the huge protest in Brisbane.
“I bet the protesters’ details weren't recorded as would be required at any pub, club, restaurant or gym,” he added.
If we can have this protest then there is no justification for the ongoing (illogical) restrictions on our lives. I bet the protesters details weren't recorded as would be required at any pub, club, restaurant or gym. And btw, have some courage and open the border now https://t.co/a8Y3W8NQ8b
— Campbell Newman (@CampbellNewman) June 6, 2020
But earlier this week, Prime Minister Scott Morrison and Health Minister Greg Hunt warned people not to attend the protests, saying the pandemic was far from over.
“We respect deeply people’s right to express themselves. It’s fundamental to who we are. We respect the compassion behind those concerns, but we say at this moment in time there is a better way,” Mr Hunt said.
“There’s always a time for protests, but it’s not at this moment, not in a mass gathering form.
“The means of coming together and risking the spread of COVID-19 is something we say to people: please think again, please do not do this, exercise your compassion, express yourself, but do it in a way that is safe, sound and respectful of our most vulnerable Australians.”
In Victoria, police said they were concerned that such a large gathering had occurred in Melbourne “without regard” for the need to social distance.
Assistant Commissioner Luke Cornelius said the force would now consider what action to take “in relation to the organisation and conduct of this unlawful gathering”.
Officers have already said the organisers of the rally – the Warriors of the Aboriginal Resistance (WAR) – will be fined $1652 each for breaching the directions of the chief health officer.
Wurundjeri woman Mandy Nicholson, who spoke at the protest, said it was ridiculous to fine people for fighting injustice and she would contest a fine if she received one.
“It’s a democratic right to protest,” she told AAP. “We also had police marching with us and talking with us.
“It was very peaceful and a life-changing event for not only black people but everyone.”
Despite the rally being unlawful, police said they were generally pleased with the public’s behaviour and reported no arrests.
The protest in Sydney was also described as “peaceful” with just three men arrested before it began.
About 20,000 people gathered in the city’s CBD after the Court of Appeal declared the rally an authorised public assembly.
The decision, overturning a Supreme Court ruling on Friday night, gave protesters immunity from arrest for blocking roads along the planned route from Town Hall to Belmore Park.
“Whether the police want to say it’s unjust, whether the government wants to say it’s unjust, think of the unjust things they’ve done to our people,” Lugad Omido, 25, said.
“This is what it’s here for – for us to trigger a change.”
RELATED: NSW Supreme Court rules against Sydney protest
RELATED: Activists slam ‘appalling’ Supreme Court protest ban
Bob Jones, 75, said attending the protest was worth the risk of contracting the coronavirus.
“If a society is not worth preserving, then what are you doing? You’re perpetuating a nonsense,” he told AAP.
Following the march, protesters clashed with police at Central Station. A short scuffle broke out between officers and protesters as police tried to move forward in an underground section of the station.
At least two officers used pepper spray, with up to 30 people in the firing line.
It appears pepper spray may have been used at Central Station with @newscomauHQ observing several people on the floor of the concourse following the #blacklivesmatteraustralia rally. pic.twitter.com/1iGlNIDmfK
— Benedict Brook (@BenedictBrook) June 6, 2020
#blacklivesmatteraustralia perfectly peaceful if it weren't for the cops kettling everyone in for no bloody reason. endangering protesters and bystanders pic.twitter.com/6gUo21Dvmo
— larrikin (@the_larrikin) June 6, 2020
One of the protesters at Central on the platforms after what appeared to pepper spray in the concourse below. @newscomauHQ pic.twitter.com/Sh4hVFz4xo
— Benedict Brook (@BenedictBrook) June 6, 2020
In Queensland, thousands of people flocked to inner-city Brisbane, with crowds spilling from King George Square to neighbouring blocks.
People packed stairwells and balconies to get a view while speakers, including elders, traditional owners and African Australians, detailed police brutality against members of their own families and the racism they’d experienced.
“We rise together and we speak in one voice against racism … and legislation that takes away our freedom in this country … our right to have a voice, our right to be free,” Wangan and Jagalingou man Adrian Burragubba said.
In Western Australia, the Indigenous community is calling for answers after a 40-year-old Aboriginal man collapsed and died at a prison.
The Acacia Prison inmate was found on Friday but he could not be revived and was pronounced dead at hospital, the state's Department of Justice said in a statement on Saturday.
Police said there did not appear to be anything suspicious, but they were investigating and there would be an inquest given it was a death in custody.
The Department of Justice will also conduct an internal review.
More than 5000 people packed into Victoria Square in Adelaide after its protest was given it an exemption from COVID-19 restrictions.
“This is a unique and extraordinary event … There is a sentiment that suggests people should have a right to protest on significant matters,” Commissioner Grant Stevens had said on Friday.
But he also called on protesters to be mindful of their own health and the health of others amid the ongoing pandemic.
As the protest began, many in the crowd tried to social distance, but it became less evident as they made their way down King William Street towards Parliament House before returning to the square.
Assistant Commissioner Peter Harvey acknowledged that it was very difficult for such a large crowd to effectively keep their distance.
“A lot of people did try and I must commend them,” he said.
Police said there were no arrests or injuries.
A total 7255 cases of coronavirus have been confirmed across Australia since the beginning of the pandemic, with 102 deaths.
— with wires
NRL star charged with threatening police
Canberra Raiders veteran player Josh Papalii has been charged over an ugly confrontation with police inside a licensed venue, just weeks before he won a prestigious award.
Man creeps into 7yo’s bedroom, rapes her
A man has been found guilty after he broke into a Perth home and sexually assaulted a seven-year-old girl who was asleep in her bedroom.
TV host announces her own tragic death
A beloved Australian TV host has announced her own death on social media after she lost her battle with motor neurone disease.