NewsBite

‘On what grounds do you conclude what he did was not a barbarous act of murder?’

DAMIEN Little drove into the water, killing himself and his two boys, and yet he has been described as a “perfect father”.

A supplied image obtained Tuesday, Jan. 01, 2016 of the Little family, Damien Little, Koda (older child), Melissa and Hunter (smaller child). A South Australian father drove off a wharf, killing himself and his two young children. The bodies of Damien Little and his children - Hunter, aged about one, and four-year-old Koda - were pulled from the water off Brennen Wharf in the Eyre Peninsula town on Monday. (AAP Image/ South Australia Police) NO ARCHIVING, EDITORIAL USE ONLY
A supplied image obtained Tuesday, Jan. 01, 2016 of the Little family, Damien Little, Koda (older child), Melissa and Hunter (smaller child). A South Australian father drove off a wharf, killing himself and his two young children. The bodies of Damien Little and his children - Hunter, aged about one, and four-year-old Koda - were pulled from the water off Brennen Wharf in the Eyre Peninsula town on Monday. (AAP Image/ South Australia Police) NO ARCHIVING, EDITORIAL USE ONLY

ON the wharf where South Australian man Damien Little drove into the water, killing himself and his two young boys, family and friends have laid flowers and even raised their glasses to toast a man and his children “gone too soon”.

And that has left Phil Cleary truly revolted.

“It’s disgusting,” the former federal Independent MP and sportsman turned-anti domestic violence campaigner told news.com.au.

“What we have is a man who has driven his car at high speeds off a wharf, terrifying the children, and left them to drown in the sea. It’s an horrendous, appalling, brutal, violent act. How can anyone go to that setting and put a wreath down and feel sympathy for the man who’s done that? Not only to the children but the mother of those children.”

Mr Cleary knows keenly what it is like to be left behind. In 1987, his sister Vicki was stabbed to death by a former boyfriend in a fit of jealous rage. He later used Victoria’s now-defunct provocation law to be found guilty of the lesser crime of manslaughter.

Mr Cleary doesn’t believe men who kill their children in murder-suicides should receive a shred of sympathy, and has taken aim at the media’s treatment of the Little incident.

Media coverage has touched on 34-year-old Little’s three-year spiral into depression before he drove his car off a Port Lincoln wharf at 80kmh on Monday with sons Koda, 4, and Hunter, nine months, strapped inside.

Since then, he has variously been described as a “top bloke”, “perfect father” and “devoted husband” in media coverage.

“He wanted to do everything right. He was very hard on himself. He wanted to live a perfect life,” his mother Sue Little was quoted as saying, including by news.com.au.

Koda and Hunter Little.
Koda and Hunter Little.

“Over the past three years he had a bit of a problem, we had noticed a change. When we saw [it] the whole family tried to help him. He had a lot of people offering help. We tried to help him, we all did. But you can’t help somebody who can’t help himself.”

Local football club President Brenton Dennis was reported as saying: “You couldn’t have asked for a better bloke.”

South Australian Commissioner for Victim’s Rights, Michael O’Connell, urged people not to rush to judgment.

“We do not know the reasons Damien did what he appears to have done and speculating helps neither the family nor the people of Port Lincoln,” he was quoted as saying.

Mr Cleary agreed the full picture was yet to emerge. But he drew comparisons with the killing of Rosie Batty’s son Luke by his father Greg Anderson in 2014 and questioned why the public had reacted with horror to that case, but not this one.

“Greg Anderson’s murder of Luke Batty was an act of revenge against the boy’s mother. I believe Rosie accepts that,” Mr Cleary, 63, said.

“One interesting thing about this is we don’t quite know if this is an act of revenge murder. Most children killings by men are revenge killings [for example] Robert Farquharson in Victoria and Darcey Freeman off the bridge.”

Family members of Damien Little raise a toast to Damien and the boys at the scene. Picture: Dean Martin
Family members of Damien Little raise a toast to Damien and the boys at the scene. Picture: Dean Martin
Friends and family at the wharf where Damien Little and his children died.
Friends and family at the wharf where Damien Little and his children died.

“What this man has done is in the same territory I think.”

A rifle was also found in Little’s car but police have not said what, if any, connection it has to the incident.

Victims rights campaigner Phil Cleary is horrified by the reaction to the Port Lincoln double killing of two boys.
Victims rights campaigner Phil Cleary is horrified by the reaction to the Port Lincoln double killing of two boys.

Among the tributes left between flowers, teddy bears and footballs were several handwritten cards.

“May their little souls rest in peace,” one read, while another said: “RIP little fellas 2 angels back in the loving arms of God. With deepest condolences to the family.”

Mr Cleary said the starting point in cases of family violence had to be “abject shock”.

“The Prime Minister said on White Ribbon Day we need cultural change. [Port Lincoln] is another example of how deep the disregard is for women [and] how high the sympathy for violent men is.”

He pointed to scenes played out in courtrooms around the country when men were put on trial for murdering their partners. The women’s personal lives become fair game for defence lawyers to try and find some way to explain why their client had killed, he said.

Tributes left at the wharf where Damien Little drove his sons to their deaths.
Tributes left at the wharf where Damien Little drove his sons to their deaths.

“It’s dominated by sympathy of them and condemnation [of] the women. Anyone who goes into courts comes to see it.

“I think we have a deeper problem around men’s violence in domestic settings. Maybe it confronts it so much we can’t condemn it outright because men think ‘there go I, but for the grace of God?”

Luke Batty was killed by his father in 2014.
Luke Batty was killed by his father in 2014.
Darcey Freeman who was thrown from the West Gate Bridge in Melbourne by her father.
Darcey Freeman who was thrown from the West Gate Bridge in Melbourne by her father.
Robert Farquharson, pictured here in early 2005 with his three sons. Within months of this photo being taken, he plunged his car into a dam, drowning all three children.
Robert Farquharson, pictured here in early 2005 with his three sons. Within months of this photo being taken, he plunged his car into a dam, drowning all three children.

Mr Cleary has been outspoken on other murder-suicides, including the case of Geoff Hunt who murdered his wife and three children before taking his own life in 2014.

“The logical extension of depression is not murder,” he said at the time. “It is still driven by a view of women and children as commodities to be controlled by a man. Even if a man makes a decision to kill his family because he thinks it is virtuous, it is a disgraceful act that we should condemn.”

Mr Cleary said the Little case brought back terrible memories of his own sister’s death.

“It was incomprehensible, it was painful, it was devastating. Then we had to go to court and saw a narrative where my sister was blamed for the act of violence from a man.

“Now nearly 29 years later I see a man drive his children into the sea in a terrifying act of murder, and clusters of men want to celebrate [him] as [a] decent, good man. Doesn’t that suggest we have a serious problem?”

Despite that, he remains hopeful the current debate about domestic violence in Australia will lead to change. “Because this is not how I believe good men behave.”

If you or someone you know needs help, please call Lifeline on 13 11 14.

andrew.koubaridis@news.com.au

Original URL: https://www.news.com.au/lifestyle/real-life/news-life/on-what-grounds-do-you-conclude-what-he-did-was-not-a-barbarous-act-of-murder/news-story/16f8aa8be0cc8dc5432b2ba724e991df