NewsBite

Updated

Democratic debate in Nevada live: Bloomberg, Sanders face off for first time

Donald Trump has slammed fellow billionaire Mike Bloomberg’s first debate performance, calling it “perhaps the worst in the history of debates”.

Elizabeth Warren digs into Michael Bloomberg  in relation tosexual harassment allegations

US President Donald Trump has attacked Michael Bloomberg’s first debate performance as “stumbling, bumbling and grossly incompetent”.

“Mini Mike Bloomberg’s debate performance tonight was perhaps the worst in the history of debates, and there have been some really bad ones,” Mr Trump tweeted.

“He was stumbling, bumbling and grossly incompetent. If this doesn’t knock him out of the race, nothing will. Not so easy to do what I did!” he added.

Former New York Mayor Mike Bloomberg, who has spent hundreds of millions of dollars on ads for his presidential run, made his debut on the debate stage ahead of Nevada’s party caucuses on Saturday.

Yesterday's debate was the first time former New York mayor Michael Bloomberg had appeared on stage with his rivals. It finally gave them a chance to attack him, and they did so, without mercy.

Senator Elizabeth Warren delivered perhaps the most effective moment of the evening when she ripped into Mr Bloomberg over accusations of sexism.

Read on for all the details from a feisty debate.

Updates

Talking points from the debate

And that's it, the debate is over. Now there will be two more days of desperate campaigning before the Nevada caucuses, the results of which we'll bring you on Sunday, Australian time.

If you don't feel like reading a gazillion posts below this one, here are the main points from today's rhetorical fisticuffs, as I saw them:

+ In his first appearance on a debate stage, billionaire candidate Michael Bloomberg quite simply imploded. Everyone ganged up on him, but Elizabeth Warren struck the killing blow, repeatedly asking whether Mr Bloomberg would release women from the nondisclosure agreements they had signed with his company over his allegedly sexist behaviour. He refused. It was cringeworthy;

+ Pete Buttigieg and Amy Klobuchar spent much of the debate fighting with each other, and it's not clear that either benefited from the exchanges. He looked a little smarmy. She lost her cool. Not a great evening for these two;

+ Bernie Sanders, the frontrunner for the nomination, repeated his usual talking points very competently and probably wasn't hurt at all, batting away questions about the unpopularity of socialism in the American electorate;

+ Joe Biden had perhaps his strongest debate of the primaries so far, particularly when he went forcefully after Mr Bloomberg. That admittedly isn't saying much. But he may have done enough to revive a campaign that was starting to seem terminal;

+ And Ms Warren dominated the stage more than anyone else, launching broadsides against pretty much everyone and pitching herself as the candidate who could deliver a more thought-through version of progressivism than Mr Sanders.

Picture: One of several brutal moments between Ms Warren and Mr Bloomberg.

The closing arguments

The candidates just delivered their closing statements. Here's the best line from each.

Klobuchar: "We have a President right now who doesn't have a heart. I love the people of this country, and I ask for the vote of the people of Nevada."

Bloomberg: "This country has to pull together and understand that the people that we elect, they should have experience, they should have credentials, they should understand what they are doing."

Buttigieg: "The only way we can do this is to create a sense of belonging in this country that moves us out of the toxic moment we are in."

Warren: "For me, I am of all the people on this stage, I've been a politician the shortest time, but I've been the one out fighting for families the longest time. Give me a chance, I'll go to the White House and fight for your family."

Biden: "I've been knocked down a hell of a lot. And I know you have to get back up."

Sanders: "Bottom line here, real change never takes place from the top down, never takes down from an oligarchy controlled by billionaires. We need to mobilise millions of people to stand up for justice."

Candidates argue about their houses

Michael Bloomberg tried to label Bernie Sanders a hypocrite, pointing out that America's "leading" democratic socialist was a millionaire with three houses.

Mr Sanders was quick to respond.

"I work in Washington. House one. I live in Burlington. House two. And like thousands of other Vermonters, I have a summer camp. Forgive me for that," he said.

"Where is your home? In which tax haven do you have your home?" he shot at Mr Bloomberg.

"New York City, thank you very much. And I pay all my taxes. And I'm happy to do it, because I get something for it," Mr Bloomberg replied.

'Are you saying I'm dumb?'

The debate was already feisty, but it turned downright ugly when Senator Amy Klobuchar was asked about her failure to remember the name of the Mexican president at an event earlier this week.

For the record, his name is Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador. Mexico is America's southern neighbour and one of its most important trading partners.

“I don’t think that that momentary forgetfulness actually reflects what I know about Mexico and how much I care about it,” Ms Klobuchar said.

Pete Buttigieg – who did remember Mr Obrador's name at that event – attacked her.

“You’re on the committee that oversees border security,” he said.

“You’re on the committee that does trade. You’re literally on the committee that’s overseeing these things. And you're not able to speak to the first thing about the politics to our south.”

Ms Klobuchar got extremely animated in response.

“Are you trying to say that I’m dumb? Are you mocking me here Pete?” she said.

Elizabeth Warren interjected to defend her Senate colleague, saying the attack on her was "not fair".

“Let’s be clear, missing a name all by itself does not indicate that you do not understand what’s going on and I just think that’s a mistake,” Ms Warren said.

'Dismantled': Billionaire implodes on stage

Michael Bloomberg spent hundreds of millions of dollars – albeit out of a $96.4 billion ($US64 billion) personal fortune – to get on the debate stage.

But over the course of a couple of minutes, his candidacy may have imploded.

The former mayor of New York got beaten up badly on his alleged record of sexism towards female employees.

Asked about that record, Mr Bloomberg reeled off a list of women he had employed in prominent positions.

Elizabeth Warren, standing at the lectern next to him, pounced.

“I hope you heard what his defense was. ‘I’ve been nice to some women,'" Ms Warren said.

“What we need to know is what exactly is lurking out there,” she continued.

She brought up the unknown number of non-disclosure agreements women had signed with the billionaire's company over the years.

“Mr Mayor, are you willing to release all those women from those nondisclosure agreements so we can hear their side of the story?” Ms Warren asked.

Mr Bloomberg refused.

"We're not going to end these agreements because they were made consensually and they have every right to expect that they will stay private," he said.

The crowd groaned when he suggested some of the agreements related to the women "maybe not liking a joke I told".

And there was another awful moment when he insisted all the agreements were signed "consensually". Bad wording there.

Ms Warren continued to press, repeatedly asking Mr Bloomberg how many nondisclosure agreements there were. He did not provide an answer.

And Joe Biden joined the pile-on, urging Mr Bloomberg to release the women from the agreements.

"If they want to release it they should be able to release it themselves. Say yes!" Mr Biden said.

Big blow-up on health care

The second phase of the debate focused on health care, and it was cranky.

The moderates on stage – Joe Biden, Pete Buttigieg and Amy Klobuchar – went after Bernie Sanders' plan, which would end private health insurance and put every American on a government plan.

The more liberal candidates – Mr Sanders and Elizabeth Warren – returned fire, accusing the others of not having a proper health care plan at all.

"Mayor Buttigieg really has a slogan, that was thought up by his consultants, to paper over a thin version of a plan that would leave millions of people unable to afford their health care. It's not a plan, it's a Power Point," Ms Warren said.

"And Amy's plan is even less. It's like a Post-it Note, insert plan here."

Sanders grilled on rude supporters

Bernie Sanders just got into an extended tiff with Pete Buttigieg over the behaviour of his supporters.

Mr Buttigieg suggested Mr Sanders' fans, particularly online, were more vitriolic than other candidates'.

Mr Sanders said "99.9 per cent" of his supporters were well behaved but he "disowned" any who weren't.

"But leadership is what you draw out of people," Mr Buttigieg countered.

The back-and-forth continued for some time, and was not terribly productive.

Mr Buttigieg framed his candidacy against both Mr Sanders' and Mr Bloomberg's.

"Most Americans don't see where they fit if they've got to choose between a socialist who thinks that capitalism is the root of all evil and a billionaire who thinks that money ought to be the root of all power," he said.

"Let's put forward somebody who actually lives and works in a middle-class neighborhood in an industrial midwestern city. Let's put forward somebody who's actually a Democrat."

That last jab drew some guffaws. Mr Bloomberg was, until recently, a Republican. Mr Sanders sits in the Senate as an independent.

Everyone attacks Bloomberg

Bernie Sanders got the first question of the debate. Moderator Lester Holt asked why he thought he was better positioned than Mike Bloomberg to beat Donald Trump.

"In order to beat Donald Trump, we're going to need the largest voter turnout in history," he said.

"What our movement is about is bringing working class people together. Black and white and latino, Asian Americans, around an agenda that works for all of us, and not the billionaire class."

Mr Bloomberg replied that he didn't think there was "any chance" of Mr Sanders beating Mr Trump.

"You don't start out by saying I've got 160 million people, I'm going to take away the insurance plan that they love," he said, referring to Mr Sanders' health insurance plan, which would end private insurance and put everyone on a government system.

"If he is the candidate, we will have Donald Trump for another four years, and we can't stand that," said Mr Bloomberg.

Senator Elizabeth Warren then jumped in, drawing an unflattering comparison between Mr Bloomberg and Mr Trump.

"I'd like to talk about who we're running against. A billionaire who calls women fat broads and horse-faced lesbians," she said.

"And no, I'm not talking about Donald Trump, I'm talking about Mike Bloomberg," she said, drawing dramatic oohs from the crowd.

"Understand this, Democrats take a huge risk if we just substitute one arrogant billionaire for another," she continued.

"This country has worked for the rich for a long time and left everyone else in the dirt. It is time to have a president who will be on the side of working families."

Senator Amy Klobuchar joined the pile-on, referring to the suggestion from Mr Bloomberg's campaign today that other moderate candidates get out of the race and endorse him.

"I've been told many times to wait my turn and to step aside, and I'm not going to do that now, and I'm not going to do that because of a campaign memo from Mayor Bloomberg," she said.

Mr Bloomberg then got a chance to respond.

"I think we have two questions to face tonight. One is who can beat Donald Trump, and two is who can do the job if they get into the White House. I am the candidate that can do both of those things," he said.

"I'm a New Yorker, I know how to take on an arrogant con man like Donald Trump."

Candidates take the stage

At every debate the candidates are made to line up and engage in awkward chit chat, pretending they don't hate each other's guts, as the TV broadcast introduces them.

It is excruciating to watch, in the most pleasurable way. A bit like The Office.

'Absolute lie': TV guest's claim slammed

Bernie Sanders has been criticised in the last 24 hours for refusing to release his medical records.

Mr Sanders, 78, suffered a heart attack last October. In the immediate aftermath, he promised to release his records. That has not happened – and at a CNN town hall event yesterday, he made it clear it was never going to happen.

When moderator Anderson Cooper pressed him on the issue, Mr Sanders said he felt the letters his doctors had released, declaring him healthier than the average 78-year-old, would suffice.

"We have released, I think Anderson, quite as much as any other candidate has. We released two rather detailed letters from cardiologists and released a letter that came from the head of the US Congress medical group, the physicians there. So I think we have released a detailed report, and I'm comfortable with what we have done," Mr Sanders said.

"If you think I'm not in good health, come on out with me on the campaign trail, and I'll let you introduce me to the three or four rallies a day that we do."

Cooper pushed him again, asking specifically whether he would release any more medical information.

"I don't think we will, no," Mr Sanders replied.

You can understand why voters might want to see Mr Sanders' medical records. If he wins the general election in November, he will become the oldest president ever inaugurated for a first term. And he had a heart attack mere months ago.

To put it bluntly, people should probably know whether he is likely to die in office.

The controversy blew up a little more today when Mr Sanders' campaign spokeswoman Briahna Joy Gray went on morning television and tried to turn questions about her boss's health against his rival, Michael Bloomberg.

"It's really telling none of the same concern is being demonstrated for Bloomberg, who's the same age as Bernie Sanders, who's suffered heart attacks in the past," she said, dismissing the questions as a "smear campaign".

The problem is that Mr Bloomberg has never had a heart attack. He had two coronary stents inserted back in 2000, but that is obviously not the same thing.

Mr Bloomberg's campaign manager labelled Ms Grey's claim an "absolute lie", drawing parallels with the sort of weird, easily disprovable fibs Donald Trump is in the habit of telling.

Add your comment to this story

To join the conversation, please Don't have an account? Register

Join the conversation, you are commenting as Logout

Original URL: https://www.news.com.au/finance/work/leaders/live-coverage-of-the-democratic-presidential-debate-in-nevada/live-coverage/f44dfa49f1e2fee1e71dadc765848605