NewsBite

Analysis

NRL player ratings: Parramatta Eels v Penrith Panthers round 5

BRYCE Cartwright and Jamie Soward saved the day in a thrilling local derby between the Panthers and Eels. See how each player fared.

Panthers players Jamie Soward and Isaah Yeo celebrate their win in the round 5 NRL match between the Parramatta Eels and the Penrith Panthers at Pirtek Stadium in Sydney, Sunday, April 3, 2016. (AAP Image/Dan Himbrechts) NO ARCHIVING, EDITORIAL USE ONLY
Panthers players Jamie Soward and Isaah Yeo celebrate their win in the round 5 NRL match between the Parramatta Eels and the Penrith Panthers at Pirtek Stadium in Sydney, Sunday, April 3, 2016. (AAP Image/Dan Himbrechts) NO ARCHIVING, EDITORIAL USE ONLY

BRYCE Cartwright was the matchwinner in a thrilling local derby between the Panthers and Eels.

See how each player fared.

VS
Michael Gordon6.5
Some good moments but have seen him far more involved.
FULLBACK
Matthew Moylan7
Will be better for the run but all class out there.
Semi Radradra7
A real handful in the first half but the opportunities dried up.
WING
Josh Mansour8
Angry ant who is always busy and tough to bring down.
Michael Jennings7.5
His best game for the Eels. Involved and always looked a threat.
CENTRE
Waqa Blake6.5
Had his hands full with Jennings but solid most of the game.
Brad Takairangi7
Real strong. He made it a difficult afternoon for Peta Hiku.
CENTRE
Peta Hiku4.5
Was poor defensively. His worst game for the Panthers.
Clinton Gutherson5
Decent involvement but two fumbles cost his side two tries.
WING
Dallin Watene-Zelezniak6.5
Big part in final try but generally well contained.
Corey Norman8
In everything and could not have done more to get his side home.
5/8
Te Maire Martin6
Handled big defensive workload but no real influence with footy.
Kieran Foran7.5
Looking much fitter. Schemed and probed all game.
H/BACK
Jamie Soward6.5
Nothing flash but came up with the perfect kick when it mattered.
Junior Paulo7
Another barnstorming try and plenty of strong carries.
PROP
Sam McKendry7.5
Was a powerhouse late in the game when result was on the line.
Isaac De Gois7.5
Much better with the footy out of dummy half than he has been.
HOOKER
Peter Wallace7.5
Scored a try and picked his moments well. Influential figure.
David Gower5
Copped an early head knock and no real influence on the outcome.
PROP
Reagan Campbell-Gillard5
Hardly sighted after a few early charges.
Manu Ma'u7
Another strong effort with plenty of tough carries and big defence.
2ND ROW
Bryce Cartwright8.5
Matchwinner. Two tries, six tackle busts and plenty of metres.
Beau Scott6.5
Some uncharacteristic tackle misses in final minutes were costly.
2ND ROW
Isaah Yeo6.5
Another consistent effort without being one of the standouts.
Tepai Moeroa7
A real handful at times. Some big carries and took stopping.
LOCK
Trent Merrin7
Have seen him more dominant but still a solid effort.
Kaysa Pritchard3
No impact at all with limited minutes.
I/CHANGE
Tyrone Peachey5
Not the creative force he can be.
Peni Terepo4.5
Not a heap of action and didn’t stand out.
I/CHANGE
Leilani Latu8
Huge impact. An x-factor with the skill of his passing game.
Danny Wicks7.5
Thrown in early and a big influence off the bench.
I/CHANGE
James Fisher-Harris4.5
Used in the second half but not big minutes.
Ken Edwards6
One try-saver on Moylan but has been more dominant.
I/CHANGE
Jeremy Latimore5.5
Made a couple of decent charges but not much impact.
109.5
TOTAL
110

Originally published as NRL player ratings: Parramatta Eels v Penrith Panthers round 5

Add your comment to this story

To join the conversation, please Don't have an account? Register

Join the conversation, you are commenting as Logout

Original URL: https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/nrl/footy-form/nrl-player-ratings-parramatta-eels-v-penrith-panthers-round-5/news-story/3450c178e3a590e51a841e5bb501da08