Wellington Phoenix defeat Newcastle Jets 2-1 amid VAR confusion

THE Mark Rudan era at the Wellington Phoenix has begun in style — and confusion — with a 2-1 win over the Newcastle Jets with players from both teams bewildered by the matchwinning penalty.

Nikolai Topor-Stanley of the Newcastle Jets and Liberto Cacace of the Phoenix contest the ball in the A-League.

THE Mark Rudan era at the Wellington Phoenix has begun in style — and confusion — with a 2-1 win over the Newcastle Jets.

In a performance which suggests the Phoenix have developed a spine under new coach Rudan, the main takeaway in Wellington on Sunday was further perplexing rulings via the VAR system.

Bewilderment surrounded the second goal in particular, in the lead-up to Roy Krishna scoring from the penalty spot.

VICTORY ANGER: A-LEAGUE BOSS SAYS VAR ‘DID ITS JOB’

ROAR CONFUSION: ALOISI SAYS ‘SOMETHING WRONG WITH VAR’

The reason for the 89th-minute penalty, awarded by referee Daniel Elder after viewing a replay, was unclear and appeared to bemuse players from both teams.

It matched the disorientation of half an hour earlier when midfielder Sarpreet Singh looked to have doubled Wellington’s lead. Elder’s VAR review resulted in it being nullified, apparently for hand ball, sparking an eruption from Rudan and some of his players.

Joss Hoffman of the Newcastle Jets controls the ball.

The hosts were the happier side when the final whistle blew, soon after Dimitri Petratos’s rifling goal for Newcastle deep into stoppage time had caused palpitations.

The scoring opened through a 32nd-minute own-goal from Daniel Georgevski, encapsulating a disjointed display from the Jets.

It was the same scoreline as their previous A-League match, last season’s grand final loss to Melbourne Victory.

They couldn’t break down a Phoenix team that has been rebuilt with a defensive bent by Rudan, and seemingly to good effect.

English centre back Steven Taylor showed why he forged such a long career at Newcastle United, superbly marshalling a defence which leaked 55 goals last season.

And it was Taylor who also sparked the own-goal, when he headed a Singh cross tantalisingly in the direction of goalkeeper Glen Moss.

Sensing danger, Georgievski rose but only succeeded in flicking his attempted headed clearance into the net.

Nigel Boogaard of the Jets speaks to referee Daniel Elder.

It is just the second time in 12 seasons that the Phoenix have won their opening match and continues a fine record against Newcastle, having emerged victorious in 12 of their 15 home encounters against the Jets.

Rudan surprised by naming Australian veterans Mitch Nichols and Nathan Burns on the bench and omitting Polish midfield signing Michal Kopcynski altogether. Counterpart Ernie Merrick had to make do without the suspended Roy O’Donovan and the injured Joe Champness and Ben Kantarovski, choosing to employ usual right- side player Jason Hoffman as a central striker.

Originally published as Wellington Phoenix defeat Newcastle Jets 2-1 amid VAR confusion