NewsBite

Which players failed to secure a new home this trade period?

NOT everyone got their wish this trade period. Find out which players missed out on a new home and where they go now.

Bryce Gibbs wanted out of Carlton. Picture: Getty Images
Bryce Gibbs wanted out of Carlton. Picture: Getty Images

IT WILL go down as one of the biggest trade periods in AFL history. A total of 39 deals were done with club greats, Rising Star winners, favourite sons, exciting youngsters and veterans among those to find new homes.

However, not everyone was so lucky. A host of players went into the trade period hoping for a different result.

REPORT CARD: HOW DID YOUR CLUB TRADE?

WHO WON: LIVE CHAT: TRADE WINNERS AND LOSERS

So what were the deals that didn’t get done and where to next for those players?

Could your club be about to snap up a bargain?

Hayden Ballantyne will return to Fremantle in 2017. Picture: Getty Images.
Hayden Ballantyne will return to Fremantle in 2017. Picture: Getty Images.

HAYDEN BALLANTYNE

The Fremantle small forward had been linked with a move to cross-town rival West Coast or relocation to Geelong during the season but interest cooled in the trade period. Ballantyne will return to the Dockers and the club says it is happy to have him.

XAVIER RICHARDS

After playing in Sydney’s Grand Final side earlier this month, Richards pulled a big surprise when he requested a trade to a Victorian club in the second week of the trade period. However, no deal was able to be done. The Swans are keen to reopen talks with the forward but Richards wants to return home to Melbourne.

Football manager Tom Harley said on Friday that Richards, Dean Towers, Abe Davis and Jack Hiscox were all yet to agree to new deals.

“We will sit down with their respective managers to work out what we do going forward,” Harley said. “List lodgement is not until the end of October so we have some time to work through that and we will pick up those conversations as soon as we can.”

LISTEN: SAM EDMUND, MICK WARNER and ANTHONY HUDSON ON THE TRADE PERIOD

MICHAEL BARLOW

Despite talk of a possible move, Barlow wasn’t able to secure a deal for a fresh start during the trade period. His contract at Fremantle is up so he can be recruited as a delisted free agent. While he has his limitations, Barlow could be a good pick-up for a side needing midfield depth.

BRYCE GIBBS

Was the asking price too high or were the Crows not giving enough? It doesn’t matter now because Gibbs is staying at Carlton. He still has three years to run on his deal but it is highly unusual for a player to be held to his contract after requesting a trade. The Giants did it with Cam McCarthy, which only delayed his move by 12 months. Will Gibbs try again this time next year?

DREW PETRIE

With West Coast picking up Nathan Vardy on the last day of trade period, Petrie’s chances of extending his 316 game career took a hit. Although the Eagles will be without Nic Naitanui for 2017, they have plenty of forward line depth with Vardy joining Jack Darling and Josh Kennedy.

Tom Rockliff will remain at Brisbane. Picture: Getty Images
Tom Rockliff will remain at Brisbane. Picture: Getty Images

TOM ROCKLIFF

Rockliff was there for the taking if another club made a serious trade bid, but no one did. The Lions confirmed on Wednesday that Rockliff won’t be traded and will see out his contract at Brisbane. However, he is seen as a long shot to retain the club captaincy with Dayne Beams and Dayne Zorko the frontrunners to replace him.

REECE CONCA

After initially being on the trade block, Conca will return to the Tigers in 2017. The former number six draft pick signed a two year deal on Thursday.

NICK DAL SANTO

The 32-year-old looks unlikely to extend his AFL career at a third club. However, Dal Santo won’t be lost to the game. He is set to take on a coaching role somewhere in 2017.

MITCH BROWN

Who needs a key defender? Mitch Brown’s time at West Coast is over after debuting in 2007. Brown has expressed an interest in playing for a Victorian club. Could it be one Brown out (Nathan) and one Brown in for the Pies?

BRENDON AH CHEE

While Ah Chee requested a trade, he also said he was happy to remain at Port Adelaide if a deal couldn’t be done. After playing 22 games across his first two seasons at the Power, Ah Chee has one year left to run on his contract. When that expires he may try and link up with his brother Callum, who plays at the Gold Coast.

Will Minson played in a premiership with Footscray VFL. Picture: Getty Images
Will Minson played in a premiership with Footscray VFL. Picture: Getty Images

WILL MINSON

Finished at the Bulldogs, Minson flew to Perth last week for a medical with the Eagles. With Nic Naitanui set to be sidelined to 2017, the Eagles could still use a bit of ruck depth to help Scott Lycett. They could do worse than put Will on the rookie list.

BEN LENNON

A former No. 12 draft pick, Lennon requested a trade out of Richmond in late August. However, he received little interest throughout the trade period. Lennon’s career has stalled with hip and shoulder injuries, concussion and glandular fever limiting him to just 19 games over the past three seasons. He in contracted at Richmond for 2017.

RICKY HENDERSON

Henderson, 28, is considered a strong chance to find a new home after being overlooked for a new deal at Adelaide. Since debuting in 2010, Henderson has played 90 games for the Crows and could be a handy including for a team looking to improve its depth. There are three delisted free agency windows — from November 1-8, November 10-18 and November 26-27 — when delisted free agents can switch clubs. They can also nominate for the pre-season draft on November 28.

JARRYD BLAIR

The small forward is expected to sign a new deal at Collingwood in the coming days.

MITCH CLARK

After two years and nine games, Clark is currently without a contract at the Cats. The recruitment of Aaron Black adds even more pressure on the likelihood of him holding his place.

JONATHON MARSH

The young Collingwood defender requested a trade home to Perth for personal reasons. No deal was able to be done with either Fremantle or West Coast. Fremantle’s successful trade period, including luring premiership Dog Joel Hamling, isn’t good news for Marsh’s prospects.

JOSH GREEN
The Lions said they would make a call on the uncontracted Green after the trade period finished, but the signs aren’t good.

BIG DAY — HOW DEADLINE DAY UNFOLDED

Trade 1

Suns & Bulldogs

Gold Coast gets picks 35 & 43, Bulldogs get picks 26 & 80

Trade 2

Witts on the move

Suns get Jarrod Witts, Collingwood get picks 44 & 62

Trade 3

Hrovat to Roos

Western Bulldogs trade Nathan Hrovat, their future third & fourth-round picks to North Melbourne in exchange for the Kangaroos' future third & fourth-round picks.

Trade 4

Cat heads West

Geelong trade Shane Kersten to Fremantle in exchange for pick No.63.

Trade 5

Tuohy’s new club

Zach Tuohy is a Cat. Carlton get: Billie Smedts, 2017 first-round pick & pick 63. Geelong get: Tuohy, 2017 second-round pick.

Trade 6

Caddy on the move

Josh Caddy traded by Geelong to Richmond for picks 24 and 64. Tigers also send pick 56 to Cats. Richmond’s football general manager Dan Richardson said the club was delighted. “We love what Josh is going to bring to our team, he’s a big-bodied, aggressive midfielder that can run, win the contested footy, and also kick goals,” he said.

Trade 7

NSW clubs trade

Sydney Swans trade picks 39 & 52 to rivals GWS Giants in return pick 31. Not sure what that accomplishes but there you go. Another deal done.

Trade 8

Lyons heading north

Adelaide trade Jarryd Lyons and pick 71 to Gold Coast in return for picks 43 and 67. Suns football general manager Marcus Ashcroft said the midfielder was a great fit. “We’re delighted to confirm that Jarryd Lyons will be joining the Gold Coast Suns,” Ashcroft said.

Trade 9

Unexpected trade

GWS & Melbourne agree to a deal from out of the blue. The Giants get picks 57 & 59 in exchange, Melbourne get Pat McKenna and picks 51 & 69.

Trade 10

Vardy goes West

Big man Nathan Vardy traded to West Coast. Geelong receive pick 72 in return.

Trade 11

Cloke a Dog

It took two weeks but Travis Cloke can stop waiting by his phone. Collingwood trade the key forward to the Western Bulldogs in exchange for pick 76.

Trade 12

Essendon get their man

James Stewart joins Essendon. Greater Western Sydney receive pick 77 in return.

Trade 13

Cats get their man

Key forward Aaron Black traded by North Melbourne to Geelong for pick 92

Trade 14

GWS join the party

GWS Giants trade Will Hoskin-Elliott to Collingwood for a future second-round pick

Trade 15

Frost makes his move

Collingwood trade Jack Frost, pick 76 and a future third-round pick to Brisbane in exchange for a future third-round pick and future fourth-round pick.

Trade 16

Dunn deal

Lynden Dunn is a Magpie after Melbourne gave up pick 47. Collingwood get 51 back.

Trade 17

Pie now a Roo

Collingwood trade Marley Williams to North Melbourne for pick 105.

Trade 18

Last gasp deal

Marcus Ashcroft confirms Jaeger O'Meara will be a Hawthorn player with just minutes left. Gold Coast secure pick 10 and multiple future second-round picks.

Trade 19

Late pick swap

This is the deal that ended up helping seal the Jaeger O'Meara deal. Carlton send their future second-round pick from GWS to Hawthorn in return for picks 48, 66 and 70.

Trade 20

Carlton & GWS

Carlton gets Rhys Palmer, GWS receives pick 135

Trade 21

Bulldogs late trade

Western Bulldogs trade midfielder Koby Stevens, pick 50 and a future fifth-round pick to St Kilda for pick 61 and a future fourth-round pick. Paperwork filed on time but deal confirmed well after the 2pm deadline.

Trade 22

Carlton get their man

Carlton gets Caleb Marchbank, Jarrod Pickett and ’17 future pick (rnd 2) GWS pick up 45, 58 & future pick (rnd 1).

Trade 23

Deledio details confirmed

Richmond receive GWS's future first-round pick (originally from Geelong) & future third-round pick. The Giants get Deledio.

Trade 24

Late pick swap

Freo get picks 35 & &1, GC Suns get No 73 and future pick (rnd 2).

Trade 25

Late pick swap

Sydney this time and they claim picks 9, 19 and 49, Port gets 14, 17 and 31.

Add your comment to this story

To join the conversation, please Don't have an account? Register

Join the conversation, you are commenting as Logout

Original URL: https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/which-players-failed-to-secure-a-new-home-this-trade-period/news-story/621b7ab4dd441f08fb8bf6b630f71ba1