KFC SuperCoach 2021 Rookie Bible: Best cheapies for your team
Unsure which rookies can make you cash? Check out the predicted averages, job security and potential cash generation of all the top cheapies.
SuperCoach
Don't miss out on the headlines from SuperCoach. Followed categories will be added to My News.
Nailing your rookies is integral to KFC SuperCoach succcess.
We’ve done the hard work for you, collating profiles on all the relevant rookies, including evaluations on their predicted SuperCoach average, job security and potential cash generation - courtesy of price magician Brice Mitchell.
And a host of rookies have already been confirmed for Round 1 debuts, making coaches’ lives a lot easier with 24-hour rolling teams.
Check out projected averages, cash generation and AAMI Series and who to lock in and trade out ahead of Round 1.
Brice Mitchell is a SuperCoach fixture and price analyst.
2020 v 2021-PreSeason AFL Kick In Analysis
— Brice Mitchell (@bricemitchell) March 13, 2021
Includes
-2020 top KI players for each team (10+ Total KIs)
-Compares 2021 Pre Season KI% for these players
What does this highlight to you?@AFLFantasy@Supercoachpic.twitter.com/CYndTxqGvL
ADELAIDE
Playing in AAMI Series (under $220k): Jordon Butts (70), James Rowe (63), Will Hamill (42) Nick Murray (39), Ned McHenry (29), Sam Berry (13) Riley Thilthorpe (12)
James Rowe $117,300 FWD
SC Average (SANFL 2020): 96
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 55 ($158k)
Job security: Very high
Rowe led the SANFL goalkicking with 35 majors for Woodville-West Torrens, posting seven scores above 110 on his way to a 96-point KFC SuperCoach average. The industrious small forward shapes as a player who can immediately step into a Crows forward line which struggled for potency last year as a 21-year-old talent. Rowe capped a strong first pre-season with a promising 15 touches, and 63 points against Port Adelaide, creating opportunities up forward but finishing with 0.3. He also slotted three goals in the Crows’ intraclub hitout and looks a certain Round 1 starter.
SC verdict: BUY. There aren’t a great deal of sure things among this rookie crop but he looks like one of them. His job security may be the strongest of this rookie crop. .
MORE: THE 11 PLAYERS YOU MUST PICK IN SUPERCOACH
Sam Berry $117,300 MID
SC Average (NAB League): 104
AAMI Series score: 13 (42 per cent TOG)
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 60 ($183k)
Berry was unable to show on field due to the NAB League shutdown but the signs were extremely positive from the inside midfielder as a bottom-ager, including one monster outing. Try these stats on for size – 20 disposals, 18 tackles, 17 contested possessions, nine clearances, three goals and 220 KFC SuperCoach points. Proved he is no slouch in covering the ground either, placing fifth nationally in the 2km time-trial at the draft combine. Along with Pedlar, Berry impressed for the weaker midfield brigade in the Crows’ intra-club clash but played just the second half against the Power, scoring 13 points.
SC verdict: BUY. A surprise debutant for Round 1 with Matt Crouch unable to get up. There’s a lot to like about this youngster and I think he can maintain his spot with strong form.
Nicholas Murray $102,400, DEF
SC Average (NEAFL 2019): 66
AAMI Series score: 39
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 45 ($123k)
Job security: Low
Murray joined the Crows’ list as a rookie after their second practice match with cross-town rivals Port Adelaide. The Giants academy graduate finished with eight disposals and 39 points as a key defender with Tom Doedee and Daniel Talia out with injury. Murray is in the frame to play a role early in 2021 if those two are missing. The 20-year-old averaged 12.9 disposals, 3.9 intercepts and 66 points as a defender in the NEAFL in 2019.
SC verdict: WATCH. His job security once Doedee and Talia return is a concern. But the lack of options in defence means Murray has to be considered for a bench spot in defence if playing, despite his fairly low scoring potential.
Jordon Butts $176,300 DEF
SC average: 47 (2 games)
AAMI Series score: 70 (82 per cent TOG)
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 55 ($98k)
Job security: High
No Kyle Hartigan means the key defender should benefit from greater opportunity in his third season at the club. He managed respectable scores of 54 and 40 in his two matches in 2020. The 21-year-old had the daunting task of spearhead Charlie Dixon in both Adelaide’s practice matches with defensive pillars Daniel Talia and Tom Doedee both injured – a nod to his improved job security. Butts tallied 13 disposals at 92 per cent efficiency, five marks and 70 points in his side’s AAMI Series thumping.
SC verdict: WATCH. We may be forced to entertain pricier options down back, but his role as a lockdown defender means it is probably too much to pay.
Luke Pedlar $162,300 MID
SC Average (SANFL U18 2020): 128
The bolter of last year’s draft class, swooped on by the Crows after attracting late interest, Pedlar is a big-bodied midfielder who wins contested ball and has a booming left boot. His draft year was curtailed by injury but he began his SANFL U18 season like a house on fire with scores of 155, 140 and 148 across his first four matches. Pedlar was among those to impress in their intraclub, holding his own against Adelaide’s first-choice midfield group. . However, he was selected in the Crows’ seconds side in both their practice matches against Port Adelaide.
SC verdict: Appears to be a fair way back at this stage but is one who could have an impact from a SuperCoach perspective when given the chance.
Riley Thilthorpe $202,800 FWD/RUCK
SC Average (SANFL 2020):85
AAMI Series score: 12 (39 per cent TOG)
Thilthorpe was the first player taken in the open draft and he should feature early if his body is right to go, after encountering groin trouble in 2020. The 200-centimetre beast is extremely mobile and clunks contested marks, showing off these traits at SANFL senior level, and can play either as a ruckman or a tall forward. Showcased his versatility in the Crows’ internal scratch match by playing on a wing in the second half. The ruck/forward wowed onlookers for Adelaide’s SANFL side in their first practice match and played the second half in the Community Series, gathering three touches.
SC verdict: Too expensive for a player with shaky job security who is likely to spend most of his time up forward while Reilly O’Brien holds the ruck fort.
Brayden Cook $117,300 MID
SC Average (SANFL U18 2020): 120
Took the SANFL U18’s by storm in a barnstorming top-age year, booting 26 majors – and 27 behinds – as a forward/tall wingman who won games off his boot. His high-impact style bodes well for his KFC SuperCoach prospects, although we are only likely to see flashes off this in the early stages of his career rather than the full package. His first pre-season has been stalled by a shoulder injury, which will keep him out for at least the first month of the season.
SC verdict: The Crows are crying out for players with X-Factor, but 2021 looks set to be a development year for Cook.
Will Hamill $210,900 DEF
SC average: 39.3 (8 games)
AAMI Series score: 42 (79 per cent TOG)
Hamill had a rollercoaster first year from a SuperCoach standpoint and his final four scores of the season tells the full story: 13, 96, 18 and 4 – the last one being the only injury affected game of the lot. However, Hamill looks to be among a bunch of young Crows who have upped their game over the pre-season and remains at the higher-end of the rookie price scale.
SC verdict: Al Paton’s rookie POD of 2020 could tempt some, but his 42-point score against Port Adelaide is well unders.
MORE: EXPERTS RATE BIGGEST SUPERCOACH BARGAINS
TOP 50: WHO TO PICK IN KFC SUPERCOACH DRAFT
BRISBANE LIONS
Played in AAMI Series (under $220k): Tom Fullarton (65), Harry Sharp (52)
Tom Fullarton $128,900, FWD/RUCK
SC average: 30 (2 games)
AAMI Series score: 65 (80 per cent TOG)
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 55 ($146k)
Job security: Medium
The former basketballer turned Category B rookie showed real promise on debut last year, kicking 1.2 as a ruck/forward before suffering an in-game injury in their next match. The ruck make-up of the Lions without Stefan Martin could see opportunities come his way in support the emerging Oscar McInerney. He entered the seemingly never-ending list of rookie ruckman with an impressive 65-point display against the Suns, booting two goals. He may get an opportunity up forward with tall Dan McStay in doubt for the early rounds.
SC verdict: WATCH. One to seriously look at if named with his handy ruck/forward status – especially after Josh Treacy’s suspension.
Harry Sharp $117,300 FWD/MID
SC average: N/A
AAMI Series score: DNP
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 60 ($183k)
Job security: Low
Sharp, who shattered the Draft Combine 2km time-trial record last year, put his hand up for a surprise debut with 10 touches, a goal and 52 KFC SuperCoach points in under a half of footy. A national steeplechase champion, the running machine mixed his time between football and athletics as a junior and has come on quicker than first thought.
SC verdict: WATCH. A playing DEF/MID rookie is extremely ideal. Watch Brisbane’s Round 1 team with interest.
Nakia Cockatoo $123,900, FWD/MID
AAMI Series score: DNP
Cockatoo had a strong summer on the track but missed the Lions’ pre-season games with a hamstring injury. Haven’t we seen this show before? Cockatoo has a heap of talent but an interrupted pre-season sees him very unlikely to play in their first-choice line-up in round one.
SC verdict: AVOID. Alarm bells! The Lions will be extra cautious with the perennially injured playmaker. Look elsewhere.
Blake Coleman $117,300 FWD
SC average (NAB League, 2019): 66
AAMI Series score: DNP
Coleman has tricks akin to his older brother, fellow Lions Academy graduate Keidean. The small forward has speed and strong goal sense which could see him called upon at some stage. But did not feature in either of Brisbane’s practice matches.
SC verdict: A similar player to his brother, who averaged 60 points from his four home-and-away matches. Appears to be well back in the queue.
Deven Robertson $176,800 MID
SC average: 47 (1 game)
AAMI Series score: DNP
The prolific junior ball-winner earned a last-minute Round 1 debut in 2020 but was unsighted for the rest of the season. Robertson’s 2019 national carnival sticks in the memory, upstaging Matt Rowell and Tom Green to win the Larke Medal and averaging 30 disposals and 128 points. Keen observers noticed via a coach whiteboard that he was named in the Lions’ stronger team for their intra-club clash – granted, with the returning Jarrod Berry in the seconds – playing through the midfield and up forward. However, he did not in their second practice match against the Suns.
SC verdict: He may be a key KFC SuperCoach player one day but the Lions are full to the brim with quality inside midfielders.
Ely Smith $123,900 FWD/MID
SC average: N/A
AAMI Series score: DNP
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 60 ($176k)
Job security: Low
Drafted as an inside bull, Smith has converted to a running midfielder and has turned heads in his third pre-season. The former No.21 draft pick finished fourth in the Lions’ pre-season time-trial and is in the mix for a Round 1 berth on the wing. He flourished in his new role during the Lion’s intra-club and did his chances no harm in his practice match showing against the Suns, but he didn’t make the cut for the AAMI Series.
SC verdict: PASS. Appeared to be a solid Cockatoo replacement but look to another MID/FWD option now.
CARLTON
Played in AAMI Series (under $220k): Paddy Dow (54)
Paddy Dow $202,400 FWD/MID
SC Average: 38 (3 games)
AAMI Series score: 54
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 75 ($173k)
Job security: High
Remarkably, less than $10k separates Dow’s cost in 2021 from the price he started at in 2018, after being prized with the third pick in the 2017 National Draft. It’s been a patchy start to the young midfielder’s career due to injury and form, but we saw signs of his enormous potential in his eye-catching display against Essendon. A beefed-up Dow slotted two goals and showcased his blistering speed, a standout trait in his draft year. He also looks to have improved his polish – one of the major knocks on him thus far – significantly. Dow was more prominent than his 54-point total against St Kilda suggests, and was Carlton’s third most used centre bounce player (18 CBA’s) behind Patrick Cripps and Sam Walsh – a clear sign of his enhanced midfield role.
SC verdict: BUY. One of the leading forward rookie candidates at the expensive end with that sort of midfield time. Although, it is worth remembering he has scored above 80 points just once in his career to date.
Corey Durdin $117,300 MID/FWD
SC Average (SANFL 2020): 55
Capable of slotting into the Blues line-up this season as a small forward and started strongly in his first pre-season. The 172cm product made his SANFL debut for Central District as a 17-year-old and managed another nine games in 2020, where he averaged 55 points — including an injury-affected score of four. However, his Round 1 chances took a dint when he missed out on selection in Carlton’s two practice matches.
SC verdict: Should feature in SuperCoach calculations at some stage and his DPP is handy.
Liam Stocker $186,500 DEF
SC Average: N/A
We didn’t get to see Stocker in action last season after leaving the hub in July due to personal reasons. As a defender, Stocker averaged a serviceable 49.5 points across five matches as a cash-cow in 2019 and could better that if he receives more senior opportunity. Blues midfield coach John Barker said earlier in the pre-season that Stocker was training in the engine room, where he won a Morrish Medal for the Sandringham Dragons as a junior. But he appears to be well back in the queue after being left out of the Blues’ 25-man squad that faced St Kilda.
SC verdict: Might become a factor during the season.
Luke Parks $117,400 DEF
SC Average (SANFL 2020): 73
Parks is a mature-age medium defender who became a Blue via last year’s rookie draft following stints in the SANFL and the NEAFL as part of the Swans Academy. He averaged 73 points last season for Glenelg in 2020 and hit the target with 72 per cent of his kicks.
SC verdict: While he has senior experience on his side, the Blues look well stocked in defence.
COLLINGWOOD
Played in AAMI Series (under $220k): Will Kelly (11), Oliver Henry (7).
Oliver Henry $135,300 FWD
SC average (NAB League 2019): 67
AAMI Series score: 7 (72 per cent TOG)
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 45 ($90k)
Job security: Medium
All signs point to a Round 1 debut for Henry after impressing in Collingwood’s practice match against Geelong and in its intra-club clash (two goals). However, his chances took a dint in their next hitout, with the forward’s 72 per cent gametime yielded just seven points from six disposals against the stingy Tigers defence. The Geelong Falcons product displayed his marking prowess at both ends of the ground in the NAB League, posting five tons as a bottom-ager.
SC verdict: PASS. Likely to be an inconsistent scorer, epitomising this in the AAMI Series. With options popping up in the forward line, it’s probably best to ignore Henry despite being named for Round 1.
Finlay Macrae $126,900, FWD/MID
SC average (NAB League 2019): 83
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 65 ($199k)
Job security: Low
Macrae moves exactly like his half-brother, Bulldogs star Jack, and was rated higher in his bottom-age draft year. Despite being unable to take the field last year due to COVID-19, Macrae has the class and poise to make a case for selection and can play anywhere on the ground. While track watchers have been impressed with what they have seen from him in his first pre-season, Macrae missed out on selection in their first practice match, with Pies assistant coach Hayden Skipworth’s saying he may have to wait for his chance in 2021. “He’s been around the mark. He’s one of the kids who’ll be close in the coming weeks. I’ve no doubt he’ll get his chance in the year. We couldn’t squeeze every one in.”
SC verdict: AVOID... for now. Macrae is extremely unlikely to be in the Pies’ Round 1 side. It means plenty of coaches will have to make a late change.
Trent Bianco $123,900 DEF/MID
SC average: N/A
AAMI Series score: DNP
Bianco received ample time in the engine room in the second half in the Pies’ practice match against Geelong with Collingwood opting to rest their first-choice midfielders after three-quarter time. The second-year midfielder – who averaged 26.5 disposals and 119 KFC SuperCoach points as skipper of the Oakleigh Chargers in 2019 – was used at 10 centre bounces. He is perhaps more likely to crack in as an outside midfielder, though, where his tidy skills come to the fore. He was one of two Magpies who were benched for the entirety of the contest against Richmond but was among the best in their reserves practice match the next day.
SC verdict: WATCH. His DPP status and the lack of rookie defenders makes him close to a lock if playing. May just miss the cut, though.
Isaac Chugg $102,400 DEF/FWD
SC average: 64 (NAB League 2019)
Chugg loomed as a Round 1 bolter early in the pre-season, staking his claim for a spot across halfback, but didn’t make the cut for their practice matches. He was taken by the Magpies with pick 28 in the 2020 rookie draft after impressing for Launceston in the Tasmania State League.
SC verdict: Could still serve a purpose as a DEF/FWD loophole.
Tom Wilson $123,900 FWD
SC average: N/A
Wilson looks to have hit his straps entering his third season on Collingwood’s list. The basketball convert has changed significantly since he first arrived in 2019, averaging 46 points in the VFL that year, and is in the mix to fill a spot on the wing in time. Like Chugg, he did not feature in the Pies’ practice hitout.
SC verdict: At 23, he is one to keep in mind if he breaks in.
Will Kelly $135,400 FWD
SC average: 36 (1 game)
AAMI Series score: 11
The father-son prospect was burning up the track this pre-season until a calf setback last month which forced him out of the practice game with Geelong. A third tall forward, Kelly slotted a goal with his first kick last season in his debut, which was later soured by a serious elbow injury. His horror luck continued in the AAMI Series, breaking his collarbone in the opening half against the Tigers.
SC verdict: His latest setback puts a line through him.
Reef McInnes $117,300 MID
SC average (NAB League, 2019): 84
The Next Generation Academy prospect played all over the park as a junior and impressed with his blistering speed at the national combine. A unique 193cm-talent, McInness posted scores of 122, 132 and 159 across a three-game stretch as an inside midfielder as a bottom-ager. McInnes suffered a pre-season finger setback and remains on the sidelines.
SC verdict: Maybe not this year, but his scope to become a hulking contested ball-winner means he should be a KFC SuperCoach favourite in the future.
Caleb Poulter $117,300 MID/FWD
SC average (SANFL U18s 2020): 130
Poulter dominated the SANFL U18s tallying 25.2 disposals, 10.6 contested possessions and a tick under a goal per game to go with 130 KFC SuperCoach points. A taller midfield option, Poulter has a raking kick and, like McInnes, would add something different to the Magpies’ midfield mix.
SC verdict: You’d pick him for the mullet alone. One who is probably more likely to break in mid-season.
Nathan Murphy $123,900 DEF
Murphy has been on the outer since breaking in for two games in his maiden season. An intercepting medium defender, Murphy should be used at some stage in his fourth season at the Holden Centre. Interestingly, he was named in Collingwood’s 25-man squad against Geelong.
SC verdict: May not play right away but keep him in mind.
ESSENDON
Played in AAMI Series (under $220k): Ned Cahill (52), Nik Cox (32), Nick Bryan (29), Alec Waterman (13), Archie Perkins (3)
Harrison Jones $123,900 FWD
SC average: N/A
AAMI Series score: 43 (75 per cent TOG)
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 45 ($101k)
Job security: High
The second-year key forward has added to his frame and appears set to pull on an Essendon guernsey in the early stages of 2021 – perhaps even Round 1. Coming off a strong pre-season, Jones impressed with two goals against the Blues and did enough in the AAMI Series with nine disposals and five marks.
SC verdict: WATCH. Looks to have reasonable job security, so keep him in mind for a bench spot – yes, even though he is a key forward – if other forward rookies aren’t named for Round 1.
Nik Cox $175,800 DEF/FWD
SC Average (NAB League 2019): 75
AAMI Series score: 32 (80 per cent TOG)
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 45 ($49k)
Job security: High
Cox has extraordinary running gifts for a player standing 200cm, winning the Bombers’ pre-season 2km time-trial. It gives him the ability to play as a tall wingman or at either end, helping his chances of an early debut. He was a noted performer in the Bombers’ intra-club, slotting a goal, and also featured in their practice match against Carlton. These efforts earnt him a full game against the Cats on the wing, finishing with nine disposals, 0.2 and 32 points.
SC verdict: PASS. Cox has KFC SuperCoach versatility as a FWD/DEF. But will he average enough to justify the inflated price? Judging by his practice match outing, probably not.
Alec Waterman $102,400 FWD
SC Average (WAFL): 110
AAMI Series score: 13 (25 per cent TOG)
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 60 ($198k)
Job security: Medium
Waterman received a perfect 10 from the judges in his first Essendon audition, sealing a spot on the Bombers’ list through the supplemental selection period by bagging four goals against Carlton. The former Eagle led the WAFL goalkicking in 2020 with 26 majors for Claremont, averaging 14 disposals, 6.1 score involvements, 4.9 marks and 110 KFC SuperCoach points. The 24-year-old appeared certain to feature in Round 1 after his standout performance but he was given just 25 per cent game time in their AAMI Series match.
SC verdict: WATCH. A rock-solid bench option when he does play. Whether that will be in the Bombers’ season opener against Hawthorn remains to be seen.
Alec Waterman's past two WAFL seasons (averages)
— Tim Michell (@tim_michell) March 1, 2021
2019
Matches: 12
Rank Pts: 95
Best: 142 pts
Disp: 14.8
Goals: 1.6
Behinds: 0.8
Marks: 4.4
2020
Matches: 10
Rank Pts: 111
Best: 143 pts (6 119+)
Disp: 14
Goals: 2.6
Behinds: 3.3
Marks: 4.9
Our forward saviour #SuperCoach
Archie Perkins $171,300 FWD/MID
SC Average (NAB League 2019): 82
AAMI Series score: 3 (19 per cent TOG)
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 55 ($104k)
Job security: Medium
Perkins has loads of potential as an athletic beast with genuine X-Factor. The top-10 draft pick was due to play through the midfield during his draft year before the competition shutdown, averaging 82 KFC SuperCoach points for the Sandringham Dragons as a forward/mid in 2019. While the Bombers have signalled that they will give their youngsters early opportunities, Perkins was another who received limited minutes against Geelong.
SC verdict: PASS. Will begin his career up forward which is off-putting at his price, but, in time, he could be anything.
Ned Cahill $161,200, FWD
SC Average: 30 (3 games)
AAMI Series score: 52 (83 per cent TOG)
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 55 ($104k)
Job security: Low
Cahill failed to pass 50 points in his three matches last season after breaking in as a small forward, but his move to halfback will pique the interest of SuperCoaches. The second-year Bomber was prominent against Carlton in his new role, giving credence to assistant coach Daniel Giansuracusa’s pre-season pump up of Cahill. The role change may not be as permanent as we first thought, spending time in the forward half against Geelong, scoring 52 points from 10 touches.
SC verdict: PASS. Forking out the extra $20,000 for young Swan Braeden Campbell looks to be the safest bet.
FREMANTLE
Played in AAMI Series (under $220k): Michael Frederick (77), Lloyd Meek (75), Liam Henry (34), Josh Treacy (27), Heath Chapman (16)
Lloyd Meek $123,900 RUCK
SC average: 87 (WAFL 2019)
AAMI Series score: 75 (83 per cent TOG)
Meek, 22, has been waiting in the wings for some time now and an injury to Sean Darcy coupled with strong pre-season form has earnt him a debut against Max Gawn in Round 1. The ruckman impressed around the ground during the Dockers’ trial match against West Coast while assuming the No.1 ruck mantle. Perhaps more significantly, Meek held his own competing against the athletic Nic Naitanui in the AAMI Series, until the reigning All-Australian ruckman was rested. The 203cm tall finished with 12 disposals, five clearances, 18 hitouts and 75 points in an encouraging showing, after he averaged 87 KFC SuperCoach points in seven WAFL games in 2019.
SC verdict: PASS. I feel that Flynn and Hunter are ahead. Meek could certainly surprise and keep Darcy out for long enough to be a great pick, but Flynn has much better long-term job security.
Love to see it! Watch the moment JL gives Lloyd Meek his debut dream âš“ï¸ðŸ’œ #foreverfreopic.twitter.com/a5aSitZVGm
— Fremantle Dockers (@freodockers) March 17, 2021
Heath Chapman $148,800, DEF
SC average (WAFL Colts, 2019): 132
AAMI Series score: 16 (16 per cent TOG)
While Fremantle have key position duo Alex Pearce and Joel Hamling returning, Chapman could enter selection calculations. The intercept defender, who will likely start his career as a third tall, dominated in the WAFL Colts for West Perth tallying 22.4 touches, 10.6 intercept possessions and 4.6 intercept marks across eight matches. Chapman was seriously impressive in the Dockers’ three intra-clubs but played just the final quarter against the Eagles in the AAMI Series – despite several teammates going down with injury during the match.
SC verdict: WATCH. Has the tools to score well — keep on your watch-list for down the track.
REVEALED: THE PHANTOM’S KFC SUPERCOACH TEAM FOR 2021
Josh Treacy $102,400 RUCK/FWD
SC average: 90 (NAB League 2019)
AAMI Series score: 27 (75 per cent TOG)
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 45 ($123k)
Job security: N/A (suspended)
An extremely popular pick as the cheapest dual-position R3 available, Treacy rocketed into Round 1 contention until a WAFL practice match suspension on the eve of the season. The rookie-listed key forward has been recognised for his physicality and determination and is a ready-made size. Like Chapman, Treacy has been banging the door down this pre-season, kicking three goals in their most recent intra-club match and adding another two in the Dockers’ first practice match. A serious knee injury to forward/ruck Rory Lobb in the Community Series looked to improve Treacy’s chances of being handed a Round 1 debut, playing in the same role after Lobb went off the ground and showing glimpses, despite scoring just 27 points.
SC verdict: LOOPHOLE. Things have gone full circle. Loomed as a great option as a forward until he was slapped with a two-game suspension in a WAFL practice game. Now he remains a solid VC loophole option — which is where coaches picked him in the first place.
Luke Valente $123,900 MID
SC Average: N/A
AAMI Series score: DNP
On the cusp of senior opportunity last season, Valente had been a standout performer in his first full pre-season since joining the club in 2018, after averaging a whopping 159 points in four SANFL U18 games. This was until his wretched injury luck continued, kicking himself in the calf at training while being tackled, which has delayed his preparation. Building fitness after the setback, he did not feature in either of the Dockers’ practice games.
SC verdict: We may be waiting a bit longer for a Valente debut. Watch with interest once he enters the selection frame.
Liam Henry $184,500 FWD
SC average: 34.3 (three games)
AAMI Series score: 34 (34 per cent TOG)
Henry broke in for three games in his first season, with the ninth pick of the 2019 draft starting at about the same price in 2020. The dynamic forward was another star performer in Fremantle’s practice match, slotting three goals as he stakes his claim for a Round 1 spot.
SC verdict: Too expensive for a player likely to play predominantly as a small forward.
Michael Frederick $175,700 FWD
SC average: 32.7 (10 matches)
AAMI Series score: 77 (94 per cent TOG)
Frederick was one of the better performing rookie-priced players in the Community Series, posting 77 points from 17 disposals and two goals. The small forward is at that price for a reason, though, averaging a mere 32.7 points in his debut season – including four scores under 30.
SC verdict: The numbers tell the story. Not worth the price.
GEELONG
Played in AAMI Series (under $220k): Francis Evans (38), Sam De Koning (34)
Francis Evans $123,900 FWD
SC average: N/A
AAMI Series score: 38 (39 per cent TOG)
Drafted from obscurity in 2019 – playing just two NAB League matches – Cats fans caught their first glimpse of Evans against Collingwood and it was an encouraging one at that. The 182cm small forward booted two goals, putting his hand up for a Round 1 debut. Evans was benched until halftime in his side’s Community Series clash with Essendon but showed good signs once he came on, kicking a goal and finishing with 38 points.
SC verdict: Job security is the big question mark here, given Geelong’s stacked line-up. Appears to be just outside the frame.
Cooper Stephens $123,900 MID
SC Average: N/A
Stephens has had a wretched run over the past two seasons with most of his draft year wiped out by a broken leg and COVID-19 leaving him stuck in scratch matches in 2020. The midfielder was named emergency five times last year, however a knee setback has held him back this pre-season.
SC verdict: His KFC SuperCoach exploits as a 17-year-old, averaging 100, points to him being a fantasy player of promise. But cementing a spot in the Cats side will be difficult.
Sam De Koning $123,900 DEF
SC Average: N/A
AAMI Series score: 34 (51 per cent TOG)
Drafted as a key defender, De Koning arrived at the club underdeveloped but the 2019 first round pick is a highly rated talent. The 201cm tall was used as a forward/ruck in both Geelong’s practice matches. Interestingly, he was picked as the first-choice ruck in the Community Series while Rhys Stanley sat out with concussion, collecting 11 disposals and three hit-outs. Former Crow Josh Jenkins appears to be the frontrunner for the second ruck spot with Stanley set to be right to go for Round 1.
SC verdict: Keep him in your thinking if he gets an opportunity as a back-up ruck.
GOLD COAST
Played in AAMI Series (under $220k): Nil
Alex Davies $102,400 MID
SC average (NEAFL, 2019): 55
AAMI Series score: DNP
Gold Coast secured the Suns Academy product outside the open draft – a massive win for them and KFC SuperCoaches. Davies is a 191cm clearance specialist who is fantastic in traffic, breaking in for seven NEAFL games as a bottom-ager and didn’t look out of place. Averaged 104 points per game in the NAB League in 2019.
SC verdict: Plenty of young talent in the Suns’ midfield but don’t be surprised if he earns a call-up. And when he does, pounce.
Elijah Hollands $180,300 FWD/MID
SC average (U18 Championships 2019): 78
Hollands slid to pick seven in the draft and will be eased into his first season while recovering from a serious knee injury sustained in February last year. His game-breaking play as a 189cm midfield-forward had some consider him the best talent in the 2020 draft pool despite his injury, but he is unlikely to feature in the first half of the season.
SC verdict: Did someone say mid-season downgrade?
Rhys Nicholls $102,400 DEF
SC average: (NAB League, 2019): 45
Another Suns academy pre-draft selection from 2020, Nicholls was present in one of Heath Shaw’s first team reveals. Word from up north suggested he was that he is flying in his first pre-season at the Suns, coming off solid form for Labrador in the QAFL in his draft year, but he did not feature in either of the Suns’ practice games.
SC verdict: May find it tough to break into Gold Coast’s emerging side.
GWS GIANTS
Played in AAMI Series (under $220k): Kieren Briggs (81), Connor Idun (64), Tanner Bruhn (62), Nick Shipley (-2)
Jacob Wehr $117,300 DEF
SC Average (2020 SANFL): 75
AAMI Series score: DNP
One of several mature-agers prized from the SANFL, Wehr is a pin-point-kicking defender who went at 74.8 per cent by foot for Woodville West Torrens last season. While the shopping list of departures for the Giants gave the 22-year-old the chance to emerge in his first season, he missed out on selection in both their practice matches against Sydney, which just about puts a line through him for Round 1.
SC verdict: It’s time for 20 per cent of teams to look elsewhere. One who should come onto the radar during the season.
Matthew Flynn $123,900 RUC
SC Average: N/A
AAMI Series score: DNP
Job security: Very high
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 75 ($251k)
Drafted as a project ruckman way back in 2015, Flynn will take the ruck reins and make his long-awaited debut following a pre-season blow to Braydon Preuss. The former Demon could miss half the season, giving Flynn the opportunity to shine for SuperCoaches. After playing as the Giants’ number one ruckman in their first practice match, coaches were shocked to see Flynn miss the Community Series with an ankle setback. The injury was only minor, and the Giants announced on Monday that he will make his debut in Round 1. Flynn has scoring pedigree in the state leagues, averaging above 95 KFC SuperCoach points in his last two NEAFL seasons in 2018 and 2019.
SC verdict: BUY. Remember Reilly O’Brien and Marc Pittonet as R3 selections? Flynn is set to make coaches a truckload of cash in 2021. The top R3 option — and perhaps the best 2021 rookie — of the lot.
One had to wait 1944 days. The other just 102.
— GWS GIANTS (@GWSGIANTS) March 15, 2021
But Matt Flynn and Tanner Bruhn will both make their AFL debuts against the Saints on Sunday at GIANTS Stadium.
Tanner Bruhn 157,800, MID
SC Average (2019 NAB League): 113
AAMI Series score: 62 (82 per cent TOG)
Job security: Medium
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 50 ($92k)
Bruhn has made an immediate impression at the Giants since being prized with pick 12 in last year’s draft and his scintillating Community Series display may have booked him a Round 1 debut. Playing as a small forward, Bruhn bagged four goals – including a staggering snap from outside 50 – from 11 disposals, scoring 62 KFC SuperCoach points. The classy 182cm youngster played just two NAB League games in two years due to injury and the COVID-19, but scored tons in both.
SC verdict: PASS, despite being handed a round one debut. It was an impressive display, but he is not going to kick four every week. Bruhn’s role makes it tough to justify him at the price.
Kieren Briggs $123,900, DEF/FWD
SC Average (2019 NAB League): 113
AAMI Series score: 81 (75 per cent TOG)
Job security: Low
Predicted average (cash gen potential): $251k
Briggs has emerged as one of the biggest cash cow surprises of the pre-season, impressing as the Giants’ No.1 ruckman against Sydney with Matthew Flynn sidelined. The 21-year-old posted 81 points from five disposals and 22 hit-outs and had the better of journeyman ruckman Tom Hickey statistically. Fantasy Freako pointed out that Briggs won the hitout battle against Hickey 16-10 and the hit-outs-to-advantage 6-2. Drafted as an aggressive ruckman, averaging 116 points per game in his draft year in 2018, Briggs is DEF/FWD in SuperCoach, which adds to his appeal.
SC verdict: WATCH. A must-have if he breaks in as a ruckman, but it won’t be in Round 1.
HAWTHORN
Played in AAMI Series (under $220k): Jacob Koschitzke (130), Tyler Brockman (80), Conor Nash (64), Connor Downie (40), Lachlan Bramble (29)
Jacob Koschitzke $123,900 MID
SC Average: N/A
AAMI Series score: 130 (84 per cent TOG)
Koschitzke is closing in on his first game as a Hawk in his third season after being reinvented as a key forward. The 196cm tall capped a strong pre-season with a dominant six-goal haul against North Melbourne, registering a monster score of 130 – the best score from a rookie throughout the Community Series. Koschitzke played as the number one forward for the Hawks with Mitch Lewis pulling out late, but a Round 1 debut beckons for him regardless of whether Lewis returns.
SC verdict: BUY. While key forwards are generally not our friends in KFC SuperCoach, we’re going to have to make an exception here. Unrealistic to expect a 130-point return every week – or even half of that – but he shapes as a solid choice for your defensive bench.
Connor Downie $117,300 MID
SC average (NAB League, 2019): 82
AAMI Series score: 40 (78 per cent TOG)
Job security: Med-High
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 60 ($183k)
Downie is primed for a Round 1 debut after a stellar pre-season campaign, including two strong practice match performances. The NGA academy graduate caught the eye on a wing against the Western Bulldogs and in Hawthorn’s internal trial for the ‘probables’ side. Downie had a modest SuperCoach return of 40 against the Roos but still won 17 disposals, spending time in defence. The running midfielder/defender is professional as they come and has an AFL-ready body at 185cm and 82kg.
SC verdict: BUY. A likely SuperCoach type who is a perfect midfield bench option – perhaps even slot him on field.
Tyler Brockman $117,300 FWD/MID
SC average (WAFL Colts, 2020): 86
AAMI Series score: 80 (84 per cent TOG)
Job security: High
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 55 ($155k)
A lively small forward, Brockman produced quite the highlight reel in the WAFL Colts last year, averaging 86 points, 14 touches and five tackles per game. His X-Factor was evident in an outstanding three-goal opening quarter against the Roos with a combination of goalkicking nous and speed. Brockman finished with 80 points from 10 disposals and looks set to join Koschitzke and Downie as Round 1 debutants.
SC verdict: BUY. Another who won’t be lining up against the Roos every week, but his FWD/MID status and job security makes him a very solid pick.
Jarman Impey $212,800 FWD
SC Average: 39.6 (5 matches)
AAMI Series score: 39 (43 per cent TOG)
Job security: Very high
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 75 ($162k)
Impey has been training exclusively in defence this pre-season, which increases his KFC SuperCoach relevance. The 25-year-old produced paltry returns from five matches as a swingman last season after recovering from a knee reconstruction, but averaged a career-high 74 points in 2019 – including an injury-affected score of 19. He is grabbing the attention of coaches with a price-tag of just above $200,000. Impey had six touches and scored 39 points from a half of gametime against North Melbourne.
SC verdict: WATCH. Difficult to get a read on his Community Series performance, but it wasn’t the impressive display that coaches were hoping for. Could still be a solid selection but he may not have an overly attacking role.
Denver Grainger-Barras $184,800 DEF
SC average (WAFL, 2020): 75
Grainger-Barras looked close to a sure thing of making his debut in Round 1 after a strong pre-season, but he appears set to be overlooked. The key defender featured for the Hawks’ reserves side in both their practice matches and lined up for the ‘possibles’ in their intra-club. He was named in the best despite having a bag of goals kicked on him by teammate Tim O’Brien, so he must have done something right. The intercept gun averaged 10.3 disposals, 7.4 intercept possessions, 3.0 intercept marks and five spoils in the WAFL last year and it will be a matter of when, not if, he makes his mark in 2021.
SC verdict: WATCH. Will be one of the top rookie options in defence when he gets a run.
Finn Maginness $195,600 MID
SC Average: 52 (1 game)
AAMI Series score: DNP
Maginness may have been beaten by teammate Changkouth Jiath in the time-trial stakes but the midfielder has a lot of improvement left in him on the footy field. He broke in for a debut at the back-end of last season, scoring 52 points. Maginess did not feature in the Community Series despite being selected in Hawthorn’s squad.
SC verdict: May be an option as an inside midfielder if injuries strike.
Lachlan Bramble ($102,400, MID)
SC Average: 52 (1 game)
AAMI Series score: 29 (85 per cent TOG)
Hawthorn whisked Bramble from its VFL program, adding him as a rookie as part of the supplementary selection period. The 22-year-old had been used as a forward and through the midfield for the Hawks in their practice games, attending five centre bounces against the Roos and scoring 29 points from 11 touches. Bramble averaged just the 48 points in six VFL games for Williamstown in 2018 but looks to have improved considerably since then.
SC verdict: The scoring isn’t inviting but his price certainly is. Watch teams to see if he earns selection for their Saturday night blockbuster with Essendon. One to consider if other midfield rookies aren’t named.
MELBOURNE
Played in AAMI Series (under $220k): Kade Chandler (59), James Jordon (37), Jake Bowey (31)
Jake Bowey $117,300 FWD/MID
SC average (NAB League 2019): 79
AAMI Series score: 31 (57 per cent TOG)
Job security: Low
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 60 ($183k)
Bowey is small in stature but has what the Demons often lack – pinpoint ball-use by foot. He has scope to play all over the ground and has been used as a backline distributor in his two pre-season matches for the Demons. Bowey dominated for the Demons’ second team in their hitout with Richmond, standing out with his exceptional skills. The 175cm prospect, who has drawn comparisons to Caleb Daniel, showed glimpses against the Bulldogs when he came on after quarter time, tallying seven disposals and 31 points.
SC verdict: WATCH. The likeness to Daniel means he must be considered when he breaks in, but Round 1 may be a stretch.
James Jordon $123,900 MID
SC average: N/A
AAMI Series score: 37 (79 per cent TOG)
Job security: Low
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 50 ($126k)
Entering his third season, Jordon looks to be nearing a debut after a positive showing against Richmond in the Demons’ ‘A’ team. Jordon slotted a goal up forward and had a reasonable impact through the midfield, and attending eight centre bounces, having been a big improver for the Demons this pre-season. He won 14 disposals and attended the same number of centre bounces in the Community Series.
SC verdict: AVOID. Not an overwhelming score by any means and if he does debut in Round 1, he is likely to be pushed out by Angus Brayshaw and Jack Viney – who didn’t feature against the Bulldogs – in the early stages.
Kade Chandler $161,200, FWD
SC average: N/A
AAMI Series score: 59 (72 per cent TOG)
Job security: Medium
Predicted average: 50
Chandler has been another standout on the track following a 2020 campaign marred by several hand injuries, putting his name up in lights with three goals in Melbourne’s practice match as a lively small forward. The 21-year-old kicked a goal and went at 100 per cent disposal efficiency on his way to 59-points on a tough day for the Demons’ forward line. The 21-year-old appears set to add his sole game to date this season, scoring 60 KFC SuperCoach points from seven disposals late in 2019.
SC verdict: PASS. A touch pricey given the likes of Braeden Campbell and Ned Cahill – playing attractive half-back roles – are around the same mark.
Bailey Laurie $117,300 DEF-FWD
SC average (NAB League 2019): 90
Laurie has been hitting targets left, right and centre in his first pre-season at the Demons. The lively 179cm product was named in a weakened Demons’ squad to face the Bulldogs but did not get a run.
SC verdict: Could bob up at some point in 2021 and coaches will be watching with that DEF/FWD status.
NORTH MELBOURNE
Played in AAMI Series (under $220k): Tom Powell (57), Lachie Young (50), Atu Bosenavulagi (38), Tom Campbell (28), Charlie Lazzaro (21), Will Phillips (19), Phoenix Spicer (8)
Tom Powell $153,300 MID
SC average (SANFL U18s 2020): 154
AAMI Series score: 57 (67 per cent TOG)
Job security: High
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 60 ($162k)
It was a numbers game for Powell in the SANFL U18s last year, averaging 33.5 disposals, 14.6 contested possessions, 8.0 clearances and 3.6 tackles and a whopping 154 KFC SuperCoach points. The midfielder clearly knows how to find the footy and he proved this in the Community Series, leading all comers for disposals per minute in the first half against Hawthorn, finishing with 16 disposals and 57 points despite being benched for the final term. The ball-winner was a solid performer in the Roos’ thumping loss to the Saints, and also lined up for the stronger Roos midfield group in their internal trial. Powell is ready to play a role in the Roos side from the get-go and a Round 1 berth looms large.
SC verdict:BUY. Scored two double tons last season and his pre-season has gone from strength to strength. Lock him in.
Will Phillips $198,300 MID
SC average (NAB League, 2019): 103
AAMI Series score: 21 (22 per cent TOG)
KFC SuperCoaches were dealt a blow when Phillips was left out of North Melbourne’s 25-man squad for its scrimmage with St Kilda. From all reports, he has hardly put a foot wrong in his first pre-season but may have to bide his time. Phillips featured for a quarter in the Community Series, gathering five disposals – all won in a contest – in a sign of things to come when he does get his chance. Behind Gold Coast prized picks Matt Rowell and Noah Anderson in the Chargers midfield in 2019, Phillips still managed to average a formidable 103 KFC SuperCoach points as a bottom-ager. The consistent midfielder was set to take the NAB League by storm in 2020 if it went ahead. While he is a footy nut like Rowell, his year out of action could count against him.
SC verdict: AVOID... for now. A high asking price for a player that appears destined to miss Round 1. Should be a prominent rookie at some stage this year.
Charlie Lazzaro $117,300 MID
SC Average (NAB League): 104
AAMI Series score: 21 (35 per cent TOG)
Job security: Medium
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 50 ($133k)
Lazzaro has boosted his stocks significantly across his first pre-season at Arden St, culminating in a lively display against St Kilda. Previously playing as an inside midfielder at under-18 level, averaging 104 KFC SuperCoach points for Geelong Falcons in his bottom-age year, Lazzaro has been used as a high-energy forward. His day finished early after a knee knock against the Hawks but he wasn’t present on North Melbourne’s injury list this week.
SC verdict: WATCH. Among a list of youngsters jostling for a KFC SuperCoach bench midfield spot. Started in the Roos’ 22 on Saturday which is a good sign, but his likely role isn’t particularly enticing.
Phoenix Spicer $117,300 FWD/MID
SC Average (SANFL R 2020): 72
AAMI Series score: 8 (22 per cent TOG)
Spicer jumped into Round 1 calculations following a scintillating two-goal display in a pre-season scratch match, but was an absentee for their practice match. Intra-club highlights suggest the Roos could inject some Spicer spark in 2021. The small forward/midfielder was elevated to South Adelaide’s reserves side last season, booting five goals and averaging 72 KFC SuperCoach points. Like Phillips, he played just the final quarter against the Hawks.
SC verdict: One who could enter calculations during the season.
More of this please, Phoenix ✅.
— North Melbourne (@NMFCOfficial) February 8, 2021
The defensive pressure, then the perfect pass from Phoenix Spicer. Impressive! pic.twitter.com/SEINXuTard
Atu Bosenavulagi $175,500, FWD
SC Average: 32.7 (3 matches)
AAMI Series score: 38 (52 per cent TOG)
The forgotten man in the shock Jaidyn Stephenson trade, Bosenavulagi has stood out with his pace and ball-use in match simulation at Arden St. The former Magpie has showcased his versatility, playing at both ends of the ground after managing three games in 2020.
SC verdict: Averaged 32 points playing as a pressure forward last year, so he will only be of interest if he is stationed in defence.
Eddie Ford $117,300 FWD
SC Average (2019 NAB League): 71
AAMI Series score: DNP
The high-flying forward was added to KFC SuperCoach watch-lists after teammate Luke McDonald touted him as a player to look out for in 2021. Ford was a big-game player as a junior and is another youngster who could feature early for the rebuilding Roos, and took part in their first practice match.
SC verdict: Appears likely to miss Round 1 but should play at some point this year.
Connor Menadue $201,500 DEF
SC average: 62.5 (AFL, 2019)
Menadue’s surprise revival via the 2020 rookie draft could help out KFC SuperCoaches in 2021 if there are a shortage of cheap defenders. The former Tiger didn’t take the field for VFL club Werribee last year but averaged 62.5 points from five AFL matches in 2019.
Didn’t feature in either of the Roos’ practice matches.
SC verdict: Looks to be a fair way back.
Lachie Young $202,000 DEF-MID
SC average: 47 (2 matches)
AAMI Series score: 50 (85 per cent TOG)
North Melbourne secured Young in a three-way deal during last year’s trade period. The medium defender averaged 47 points from two games for the Bulldogs last year after six matches in 2019. Young had 11 disposals and 50 points against the Hawks.
SC verdict: His job security appears solid, but a sub-50 average from eight matches is a concern given the exorbitant price. Pass.
PORT ADELAIDE
Played in AAMI Series (under $220k): Miles Bergman (77), Lachie Jones (43), Jackson Mead (25)
Miles Bergman $123,900 FWD
SC Average: N/A
AAMI Series score: 77 (52 per cent TOG)
Job security: Medium
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 60 ($176k)
The 2019 first-round draftee has been reprogrammed as a playmaking defender is staking his claim for Round 1 debut following notable performances in the Power’s practice games. He thrived in this role in the Community Series, gathering 17 disposals and four marks and scored 77 points against Adelaide and, significantly, starting ahead of Jones. Bergman has a high-impact per possession style of play, averaging 91 points from his 14 touches per game in his draft year. Standing 188cm and blessed with a raking kick, Bergman has added size ahead of his second season and is staking his claim for an early debut following notable performances in the Power’s practice game and internal trial.
SC verdict: BUY. Has he overtaken Jones? If he is named for Round 1, which is looking good at this stage, he will be one of the leading rookie options up forward.
Lachie Jones $139,800 DEF
SC Average (SANFL 2020): 65
AAMI Series score: 43 (42 per cent TOG)
Jones has been a source of intrigue for KFC SuperCoaches with nobody quite sure whether he will line up for the Power in Round 1. The 188cm, 88kg defender was benched for the first half behind Miles Bergman in the Community Series but gave coach Ken Hinkley plenty to think about after coming on, finishing with 43 points from six disposals and four tackles. In another positive sign for Jones’ prospects, the youngster held his own in their first hitout with Adelaide and was selected among a “best 22” side against the rest in the Power’s internal trial. There is no doubt he is ready to step in after an eye-catching SANFL season that got better as it went on. The big-bodied defender averaged 16 touches, 10 intercepts and 93 KFC SuperCoach points in Woodville West-Torrens’ successful finals series and proved he can compete with senior bodies.
SC verdict: WATCH. Yes. No. Maybe … I don’t know? Can you repeat the question? Fortunately for SuperCoaches, Hinkley generally reveals his changes ahead of time, meaning we are unlikely to be left hanging until the Saturday night (the Power play on the Sunday in Round 1). If he is named, pick him.
Jackson Mead $123,900 MID
SC Average: N/A
AAMI Series score: 25 (41 per cent TOG)
Mead was mooted as a possible debutant in the 2020 pre-season before a hamstring injury put a line through him. With another pre-season under his belt, could the father-son prospect squeeze out one of their ball-winners for a spot in the midfield? Besides missing the internal trial with a minor hamstring injury, Mead has had a promising summer at Alberton.
SC verdict: Should bob up at some stage in 2021.
RICHMOND
Played in AAMI Series (under $220k): Will Martyn (26), Riley Collier-Dawkins (16)
Riley Collier-Dawkins $123,900 MID
SC Average: N/A
AAMI Series score: 16 (39 per cent TOG)
Richmond fans and KFC SuperCoach players have been waiting for a couple of seasons now for a Collier-Dawkins debut. Another pre-season for the big-bodied midfielder may see him added to their on-ball brigade, winning 57.6 per cent of his VFL possessions in a contest in 2019. Collier-Dawkins has been lauded by skipper Trent Cotchin and coach Damien Hardwick in recent weeks and was firming for an early debut until he was ruled out of their practice match with concussion following a collision with Jack Ross at training. He played in the AAMI Series but only came on after halftime.
SC verdict: On last Friday night’s evidence, Collier-Dawkins is outside Richmond’s best-22 – a common theme. Wasn’t among Richmond’s emergencies for Thursday night, either.
Hugo Ralphsmith $123,900 FWD/MID
SC average: N/A
AAMI Series score: DNP
Ralphsmith has been a standout this pre-season and put his name forward for a Round 1 debut after a promising display against Melbourne. Playing across a halfback flank and on the wing, Ralphsmith was prominent early playing for the Tigers’ first side and could feature early given Bachar Houli (calf) is in a race against time to play against the Blues. However, he was a surprise absentee for Richmond’s second game against Collingwood.
SC verdict: Could be a solid bench option during the season.
Thomson Dow $146,100 MID
SC average: 34 (2 matches)
AAMI Series score: DNP
Dow made his Richmond debut in Round 14 last season, winning 12 disposals in an encouraging first display, but failed to register a kick in his next game. It means he enters his second season at an affordable rookie price. He wasn’t selected in the Tigers’ Community Series squad.
SC verdict: Debuting as a midfielder in their premiership year says there is a bit about this youngster. Another Tiger midfielder waiting in the wings.
Will Martyn $123,900 MID
SC average: N/A
AAMI Series score: DNP
Martyn was another Tiger youngster to impress in their first practice match at Casey Fields, finding plenty of the footy against the Demons. The 19-year-old scored 26 points in a quarter against the Pies, in a sign that he is just outside their best team. Drafted from the Lions academy in 2019, Martyn has been a big off-season improver after an injury interrupted debut season.
SC verdict: Gee, it is tough to get into this Richmond side.
ST KILDA
Played in AAMI Series (under $220k): Paul Hunter (77), Tom Highmore (47)
Tom Highmore $117,300 DEF
SC Average (SANFL 2020): 88
AAMI Series score: 47 (57 per cent TOG)
Job security: Medium
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 60 ($183k)
Coaches have found it difficult to get a read on Highmore, who was one of the prime ball-users and interceptors of the SANFL in 2020, averaging 3.7 intercept marks and 88 KFC SuperCoach points. At 23, Highmore could have an immediate impact at AFL level if given the opportunity. Injuries to backline regulars Jarryn Geary, Ben Paton and then veteran James Frawley on Friday night on have left the door wide open for the 193cm defender, and he impressed his coach after he came on to replace the veteran in the second quarter. Highmore scored more points than any other player on the ground from this period, finishing with nine disposals and 47 points. The comments from Brett Ratten last month are indicative of SuperCoaches’ confusion: “Is he going to play Round 1? We’re not sure. Is he going to play this year? We’re not sure,” Ratten told the AFL website.
SC verdict: WATCH. Have to pick him if he’s playing in Round 1 but look to have a contingency plan – considering we won’t see the Saints’ team until midway through the round.
Paul Hunter $102,400 RUC
SC Average: 136 (Nine matches, SANFL)
AAMI Series score: 77 (76 per cent TOG)
Job security: Medium
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 75 ($273k)
An injury to Rowan Marshall saw former Adelaide Hunter elevated onto the St Kilda list via the pre-season supplementary selection period. The 28-year-old earned his spot with a strong showing in the ruck for the Saints’ ‘A’ side in a recent internal trial. Hunter was also prominent early against Carlton without Paddy Ryder – who has since taken personal leave from the club – tallying 13 disposals, 23 hit-outs and 77 KFC SuperCoach points. It means the ruck reins are Hunter’s for the taking until Marshall returns. The ruckman produced some insane SANFL numbers in 2020, averaging a whopping 136 KFC SuperCoach points along with 16.6 disposals, 11.6 contested possessions, 30.3 hit-outs and 4.7 clearances across nine games for South Adelaide.
SC verdict: PASS... if you’re going with one rookie ruck. If he keeps his spot in the side for longer than the first month, Hunter could be the best ruck rookie of 2021. But does he make way as soon as Marshall returns, slated to be back around Round 5? Probably, which makes it tough to start him ahead of Flynn. For those taking the punt on Flynn at R2, BUY.
SYDNEY
Played in AAMI Series (under $220k): Chad Warner (89), Braeden Campbell (85), Errol Gulden (77), Logan McDonald (61), Matt Ling (8)
Braeden Campbell $189,300 MID/FWD
SC average (NAB League 2019): 123
AAMI Series score: 85 (80 per cent TOG)
Job security: Very high
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 70 ($161k)
Campbell showcased his ability to impact games with limited possession as a junior, with his speed and raking left-boot providing X-Factor forward of centre. The top-five draft pick is set to fill a role across halfback in his first season at the Swans, where he turned heads in an exceptional Community Series showing. The Swans Academy ace tallied 18 disposals and 85 KFC SuperCoach points and will make his debut in round one. His teammates were looking for him up the ground and a couple of his penetrating kicks inside 50 showed his damaging capabilities.
SC verdict: BUY. A straight swap from Phillips in midfield or a nice option at F4-5. Big ticks for job security and scoring potential.
Logan McDonald, Braeden Campbell and Errol Gulden will all make their debut against the Brisbane Lions at the Gabba on Saturday night.
— Sydney Swans (@sydneyswans) March 16, 2021
Errol Gulden $117,300 MID
SC average (NEAFL 2019): 88
AAMI Series score: 77 (81 per cent TOG)
Job security: High
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 60 ($183k)
A hardworking 175cm midfielder, Gulden is one of the most consistent performers of the 2020 draft class. His endurance is one of his major assets, finishing fourth in the Swans’ pre-season time-trial and he could crack in earlier than expected. Was one of the Swans’ best in their practice match against GWS. Has been named along with fellow Swans Academy graduate Campbell and Logan McDonald.
SC verdict: BUY. Another must-have Swans rookie. You can have confidence fielding him given his precise ball-use and consistency.
Chad Warner $144,000 FWD
SC average: 33.5 (two matches)
AAMI Series score: 89 (70 per cent TOG)
Job security: Medium
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 60 ($156k)
A KFC SuperCoach bolter, Warner has emerged as a forward rookie candidate after a prominent 89-point outing against the Giants. Playing as a forward/midfielder, the second-year Swan booted a goal, won 19 disposals and attended six centre-bounces. Warner had limited impact in his two games for the Swans last year with scores of 38 and 29. A prolific scorer as a junior, Warner averaged a formidable 156 KFC SuperCoach points in the WAFL Colts.
SC verdict: BUY. A shame we can’t watch him in another pre-season game. Was Saturday a once in a blue moon display, or is there genuine improvement? I am leaning more towards the latter and picking him (for now). He should get consistent opportunities in the young Swans side.
Logan McDonald $193,800 FWD
SC average (WAFL 2019): 97
AAMI Series score: 61 (46 per cent TOG)
Job security: Medium
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 55 ($81k)
McDonald was the best performing draftee of 2020, finishing the WAFL home-and-away with the second-best goalkicking tally. Senior opportunities beckon for the third-tall forward, who averaged an impressive 97 KFC SuperCoach points last year.
SC verdict: AVOID. While he is set to feature prominently in 2021, it is a huge sum to pay for a rookie key forward.
Will Gould $123,900 DEF
SC Average: N/A
AAMI Series score: DNP
The KFC SuperCoach community waited, waited and waited some more for Gould to debut in 2020, but to no avail. Perhaps John Longmuir wanted Gould to earn a place the hard way after having his tyres pumped up on a weekly basis by News Corp’s SuperCoach contributors.
A Round 1 debut looked on the cards for Gould this year, until he was left out of Sydney’s extended Community Series line-up – despite playing their first practice match.
SC verdict: It’s Groundhog Day. Time to trade out Gould for another rookie defender.
WEST COAST
Played in AAMI Series (under $220k): Jarmaine Jones (54), Jack Petruccelle (51), Zane Trew (22), Isiah Winder (11)
Mark Hutchings $157,600 FWD/MID
SC Average: 29.3 (3 matches)
An Eagles regular in previous seasons, Hutchings managed just three games in 2020, going down with a hamstring injury in Round 16 after returning to the side a fortnight earlier. It means a player who has averaged 70-plus in four previous seasons – admittedly all before 2017 – is priced favourably in 2021.
SC verdict: A knee injury has ruled him out of the early rounds.
Zane Trew $102,400 MID
SC Average (WAFL Colts): 125
AAMI Series score: 22 (26 per cent TOG)
Trew was a major slider in last year’s draft after being touted as a possible top-30 selection, taken by the Eagles in the rookie draft. A taller contested ball-winner who does his best work in the coalface, Trew averaged 25 disposals, 5.4 clearances, 6.4 tackles and 125 KFC SuperCoach points at WAFL Colts level.
SC verdict: May not play this season but a brief run in the AAMI Series was a positive sign. His great junior numbers and low price make him one to keep an eye on.
WESTERN BULLDOGS
Played in AAMI Series (under $220k): Anthony Scott (79), Buku Khamis (37), Lachie McNeil (35), Dominic Bedendo (11)
Anthony Scott $102,400, FWD/MID
SC average: 88 (VFL 2019)
AAMI Series score: 79 (82 per cent TOG)
Another Bulldog off the Footscray VFL factory line, Scott won a SSP spot on the list with a promising practice match showing against Hawthorn. The 25-year-old then sealed a Round 1 debut — announced by the Dogs on Wednesday — with two goals, 14 disposals and 79 points against the Melbourne on Monday. Scott booted 19 goals and averaged 16.6 disposals and 88 KFC SuperCoach points as a forward/midfielder in the VFL in 2019.
Job security: High
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 60 ($198k)
SC verdict: BUY. We love a rookie bolter, especially as a DPP at bargain basement price. Looms as a perfect M8/F6 play.
Lachlan McNeil ($102,400, MID)
SC average: 78 (SANFL 2020)
AAMI Series score: 35
Job security: Medium
Predicted average (cash gen potential): 45 ($123k)
McNeil will join Scott on Marvel Stadium, named to debut against the Pies. Bulldogs assistant coach Rohan Smith heaped praise on forward-mid McNeil, who impressed in the Bulldogs’ first practice match: “I thought he was fantastic – that’s really exciting for us, for Lachie to come in.” McNeil, 19, averaged 18.8 disposals and went at tidy 75 per cent disposal efficiency last year in the SANFL, prized from Woodville-West Torrens in the rookie draft. He was less prominent against the Dees but played a full game, finishing with eight touches, 1.1 and 35 points.
SC verdict: WATCH. Scott is the better pick of the two, but he will be difficult to pass up at that price if we don’t get confirmation of other midfield debuts.
Anthony Scott to debut! You beauty
— Tim Michell (@tim_michell) March 17, 2021
102k FWD-MID #SuperCoachpic.twitter.com/kicI8lF3hn
Jamarra Ugle-Hagan $207,300 FWD
SC average: 84 (NAB League 2019)
The Bulldogs aren’t going to rush the No. 1 pick of the 2020 draft, lining up for the reserves in their first practice game. Ugle-Hagan’s lethal combination of goalkicking nous, speed and overhead marking should see him piece together some fantastic first year highlights, but it is unreasonable to expect the lean tall forward to score well and the Dogs say they won’t rush him.
SC verdict: Unsighted in practice matches. 12 per cent of coaches need to trade him out, quick smart.
More Coverage
Join the conversation
Bargain watch: AFL Trade period SuperCoach specials
It’s never too early to start planning 2025 SuperCoach success, and the trade period has delivered some potential steals. Here are the names and numbers you need to know.
Read more
AFL obsession to NBL addiction: How SuperCoach hooked me on hoops
I hadn’t watch the NBL since the Andrew Gaze and Shane Heal days. Now I’m taking my son to United games and watching Phoenix on Kayo because of one reason.
Read more